#Open journalism No news is bad news

Your contributions will help us continue to deliver the stories that are important to you

Support The Journal
Dublin: 10°C Wednesday 23 June 2021

It would be 'astounding' to expect TDs to pay damages to Angela Kerins - barrister

Kerins claims she was treated unfairly by TDs serving on the committee at the time in their questioning on Rehab accounts.

Image: Laura Hutton/Photocall Ireland

A BARRISTER REPRESENTING members of the Oireachtas Public Accounts Committee has said it would be ‘astounding’ for them to have to pay damages to Angela Kerins because of comments they made during a Dáil inquiry.

Kerins is seeking damages over her treatment by TDs in the committee and is also seeking an order that would prevent them from further pursuing her in any investigation into Rehab’s accounts. She claims she suffered “devastating” injuries as a consequence of her questioning in February last year.

Paul Gallagher, who is senior counsel for the PAC members, told Justice Isobel Kennedy in court today that it is “both novel and astounding” to hold members of the Oireachtas liable for utterances they made in conducting their inquiry.

Gallagher opposed an application for discovery of documents, telling the judge that none of these documents were relevant to or necessary for Kerins’ case.

He said Kerins’ legal team could not just go “trawling” to see if there was something in the documents that were relevant, referring to their discovery application a number of times as a “fishing exercise”.

If Kerins’ team wish to argue that her treatment was unfair, they need only use the transcript of the PAC hearing to demonstrate that, Gallagher argued.

Among the documents requested are those relating to correspondence sent to people asking them to come before the committee, correspondence between members of the PAC and the HSE and other departments, and any legal advice members of the PAC sought ahead of Kerins’ appearance before the committee.

The case resumes on Friday.

Read: John McGuinness has ‘no response’ to being told to step down as PAC chair>
Read: Meet Rehab’s new CEO (and have a look at her salary)>

Read next: