Readers like you keep news free for everyone.

More than 5,000 readers have already pitched in to keep free access to The Journal.

For the price of one cup of coffee each week you can help keep paywalls away.

Support us today
Not now
Saturday 23 September 2023 Dublin: 14°C
Google Maps The town square in Newcastle where the assault took place.
# Limerick
"A cowardly and vicious assault" - 3 men avoid jail after attacking man outside nightclub
The men paid €9,000 in compensation to the victim.

Three men, who admitted beating up a young man after he spoke to a girlfriend of one of his attackers, have avoided jail sentences.

The men paid €9,000 in compensation to the victim who was chased and tripped up by the men who then delivered kicks and blows as he lay on the ground.

The victim James O’Donnell was left with a broken jaw and broken teeth following the unprovoked vicious assault, which occurred in the town square, Newcastle West, Co Limerick.

O’Donnell, an IT graduate, was set upon by the three others after he was seen speaking to a girl in Club Vision nightclub in the town, on 12 July 2014.

Judge Tom O’Donnell said he wanted to “send out a strong message against the violent actions” of the defendants.

He sentenced them to three years in prison but suspended it provided the be of good behaviour for a three-year period.

“This was a cowardly and vicious assault on a victim who had no chance to defend themselves,” the judge said.

Cathal O’Brien (22) of The Cross, Ardagh; Shane Kelly (23) of Ballaugh, Abbeyfeale; and Deniss Permanickis (27) from Ballaughbehy, Abbeyfeale, each pleaded guilty to one count of assault causing harm, and to one count of violent disorder.

Judge O’Donnell described the attack as “a callous and cowardly outing”.


The victim O’Donnell previously told the court in a victim impact statement how he was left with both medical and psychological scars from the night.

“I was in hospital for three days; my jaw was broken. I had to have a metal plate inserted and my teeth were wired together,” he said.

I was unable to eat solid food for six weeks.

Cathal O’Brien tripped up O’Donnell and punched him, before the other two defendants set upon him.

Gardaí discovered O’Donnell “lying on the road bleeding from his head and mouth”.

“He had a head wound, a broken tooth and bruising to his arms,” Michael Collins, prosecuting counsel, said.

Judge O’Donnell noted the “deep remorse” shown by the three defendants.

“It was an attack on an innocent person who was extremely exposed, unaccompanied,” the judge said.

Remanding the men on bail at an earlier sentencing hearing in the matter, judge O’Donnell remarked:

I don’t want to be (seen) as allowing these three young men to buy their way out of these matters.

Read: Man who fell off hospital trolley settles €60,000 claim

Read: Man allegedly made bomb threats before visit of the Queen in 2011, trial hears

Your Voice
Readers Comments
    Submit a report
    Please help us understand how this comment violates our community guidelines.
    Thank you for the feedback
    Your feedback has been sent to our team for review.