Readers like you keep news free for everyone.

More than 5,000 readers have already pitched in to keep free access to The Journal.

For the price of one cup of coffee each week you can help keep paywalls away.

Support us today
Not now
Thursday 8 June 2023 Dublin: 14°C
Hugh O'Connell via Brendan Howlin speaking to reporters today
# Absolutely normal
‘We get on extremely well’: Brendan Howlin ‘annoyed’ by report of rift with James Reilly
Brendan Howlin has faced questions over a report today that his department warned the Health Minister that plans for universal health insurance threaten the financial stability of the State.

Updated 2pm

PUBLIC EXPENDITURE And Reform Minister Brendan Howlin has said that he is annoyed by a report that his department if at loggerheads with the Health Minister James Reilly over plans for universal health insurance (UHI).

A report in today’s Irish Times suggests that the Department of Public Expenditure and Reform has warned that Reilly’s plans for UHI pose a risk to the financial stability of the State and could add as much as €5 billion to the cost of healthcare.

Speaking to reporters at the Labour conference in Meath this morning, Howlin said that he has been a “strong supporter” of universal health insurance and said that the correspondence reported in today’s story is “the absolute norm”.

“I am surprised to see that early interaction at official level migrating itself into the national newspapers today,” he said.

Asked if the health plans pose a risk to the financial stability of the State, Howlin said: “My department has responsibility to look at the costings of every proposal.

“It’s part of a process, it’s not a finished or polished issue. There will be lots of dialogue at official level before it gets to a political level.”

On his relationship with the Health Minister, Howlin said: “On a personal level we get on extremely well. It annoys me to see it being personalised by some. I think that it is not true.”

He said that the correspondence reported today is “official interaction following from official discussions which is absolutely normal in the way that my department deals with every line department” .


Speaking this lunchtime, the Social Protection Minister Joan Burton (above) said it is important that any universal health insurance model is “cost-effective” and warned that models similar to the one proposed here have proved expensive in other countries.

“I think it has to be at the right price because certainly, when I’ve been in other European countries, and certainly having met people from the Netherlands, some of their pricing has been extremely high,” she said.

“We all know how difficult it has been for a lot of people, particularly young, single people and young families to maintain health insurance cover with the price increases in recent times. I think it’s critically important in designing a system that will be of huge benefit to people in Ireland that it is really is cost-effective.”

She also said that “robust discussion” about spending plans is “extremely important”.

First published 10.33am

Read: Here’s what’s planned for Labour’s conference in Meath today

Your Voice
Readers Comments