Advertisement

We need your help now

Support from readers like you keeps The Journal open.

You are visiting us because we have something you value. Independent, unbiased news that tells the truth. Advertising revenue goes some way to support our mission, but this year it has not been enough.

If you've seen value in our reporting, please contribute what you can, so we can continue to produce accurate and meaningful journalism. For everyone who needs it.

Fanning claims that article made seriously false and damaging statements about him. Alamy Stock Photo
Courts

Dave Fanning files defamation case over publication of news story wrongly linking him to criminal trial

Fanning’s solicitors at this time believe his image may have been included after an artificial intelligence programme used to aggregate stories failed to function properly.

BROADCASTER DAVE FANNING has launched defamation proceedings against a Hong Kong news site and Microsoft over the publication of his picture alongside an article stating that an Irish broadcaster had gone on trial for alleged sexual misconduct.

The article was published by an online news network entity called BNN of an article on 11 October last year and was headlined “Prominent Irish Broadcaster faces trial over alleged sexual misconduct”.

The defamatory article, which states that the broadcaster’s identity was being “withheld due to legal restrictions”, was also allegedly republished on Microsoft’s News Service (MSN) on the same date as it had been published by BNN.

Fanning claims that article made seriously false and damaging statements about him.

The trial in question had nothing to do with him, and related to another broadcaster, who was subsequently acquitted of all charges. As a result, he has brought proceedings and he seeks damages for the alleged defamation.

The article, the court heard, was removed the day after it was published.

The court heard that the article is completely false, has wrongly suggested that Fanning is a criminal, is a person of low moral standing, a danger to minors, is a paedophile and has gravely damaged Fanning’s reputation and good character.

As a result Fanning, represented by Garrett Cooney Bl instructed by solicitor Paul Meagher, wants to sue BNN, Microsoft Operations Ireland Ltd and its US-based parent Microsoft Corporation.

As the defendants are both located outside of the European Union, Fanning required the permission of the High Court to serve the proceedings on them.

Counsel told the court that, after an extensive search by Meagher, his side have discovered that BNN is registered as an non-governmental organisation, founded by a Mr Gurbaksh Chahal, located at the Prudential Tower, the Gateway Canton Road, Tsim Sha Tsui, Hong Kong.

Counsel said that at this stage of the proceedings, it is believed that Fannings image may have been included with the article after an artificial intelligence (AI) programme, used to collect and aggregate news stories, failed to function properly.

Today, Mr Justice Cian Ferriter said that he was satisfied, on an ex-parte basis, to allow Fanning serve the intended action on BNN.

However there were certain issues he needed clarified in relation to the application regarding Microsoft’s US based parent, which the court wanted clarified.

The judge said he would like to know if there was any evidence the allegedly defamatory article was published on any MSN services outside of Ireland or in jurisdictions under the control of Microsoft’s US parent.

The judge adjourned that aspect of the application for a week.

Author
Aodhan O Faolain