We need your help now

Support from readers like you keeps The Journal open.

You are visiting us because we have something you value. Independent, unbiased news that tells the truth. Advertising revenue goes some way to support our mission, but this year it has not been enough.

If you've seen value in our reporting, please contribute what you can, so we can continue to produce accurate and meaningful journalism. For everyone who needs it.

Members of National Assembly parliamentary group La France Insoumise and left-wing coalition NUPES hold signs reading "64 is a no", "See you in the street" after the vote of one motion of no confidence at the French National Assembly. Alamy Stock Photo
no confidence motion

French government narrowly survives no-confidence votes amid anger over pension reform

Emmanuel Macron’s widely disliked campaign pledge to raise the retirement age was passed last week without a vote.

LAST UPDATE | 20 Mar 2023

THE FRENCH GOVERNMENT under President Emmanuel Macron has survived two no-confidence motions in parliament, but still faces intense pressure over its handling of a controversial pensions reform.

Prime Minister Elisabeth Borne incensed the opposition last week by announcing the government would impose the pension reform without a parliamentary vote, sparking accusations of anti-democratic behaviour.

The opposition filed two motions of no confidence in the government as a result.

The 577-seat National Assembly lower rejected the first motion – brought by the centrist LIOT coalition and supported by the left – by a margin of just nine votes, much narrower than expected.

It then overwhelmingly rejected a motion brought by the far-right National Rally (RN) with just 94 votes in favour.

The rejection of the motions means that the reform to raise the pensions age from 62 to 64 has now been adopted by the legislature.

It still needs to be signed into law by Macron and may yet face legal challenges from the left who have filed a request with the Constitutional Court for a referendum on the issue.

“I am determined to continue to carry out the necessary transformations in our country with my ministers and to devote all my energy to meeting the expectations of our fellow citizens,” Borne said in a statement to AFP after surviving the votes.

paris-france-20th-mar-2023-protesters-during-a-protest-on-vauban-square-in-paris-monday-march-20-2023-the-french-government-has-survived-two-no-confidence-votes-in-the-lower-chamber-of-parliam Protesters during a protest on Vauban square in Paris this evening. Alamy Stock Photo Alamy Stock Photo

But it far from represents the end of the biggest domestic crisis of the second mandate in office of Macron, who has yet to make any public comment on the controversy.

Trouble ahead

A new round of strikes and protests has been called on Thursday and are expected to again bring public transport to a standstill in several areas.

There has been a rolling strike by rubbish collectors in Paris, leading to unsightly and unhygienic piles of trash accumulating in the French capital.

The future of Borne, appointed as France’s second woman premier by Macron after his election victory over the far right for a second mandate, remains in doubt after she failed to secure a parliamentary majority for the reform.

Meanwhile, it is unclear when Macron will finally make public comments over the events, amid reports he is considering an address to the nation.

Since Borne invoked article 49.3 of the constitution, there have also been daily protests in Paris and other cities that have on occasion turned violent.

An unsanctioned protest was taking place in central Paris today, with a tense standoff between protesters and anti-riot police, AFP correspondents said.

A total of 169 people were arrested nationwide on Saturday during spontaneous protests, including one that assembled 4,000 in the capital.

Hard-left figurehead Jean-Luc Melenchon said people “should express themselves everywhere and in all circumstances to force the withdrawal of the reform”.

full-bins-on-march-15-2023-in-paris-france-a-strike-by-waste-collectors-in-france-has-led-to-rubbish-trash-piling-up-in-the-streets-of-paris-leaving-locals-and-tourists-to-the-french-capital-dea Rubbish collectors striking over government reforms to the pension system have been blockading six of the Paris region's seven incinerators. Alamy Stock Photo Alamy Stock Photo

Government insiders and observers have raised fears that France is again heading for another bout of violent anti-government protests, only a few years after the “Yellow Vest” movement shook the country from 2018-2019.

‘Problem of legitimacy’

In order to pass, the main multi-party no confidence motion needed support from around half the 61 MPs of the traditional right-wing party The Republicans.

Even after its leadership insisted they should reject the motions, 19 renegade Republicans MPs voted in favour.

One of the Republicans who voted for the ousting of the government, Aurelien Pradie, said afterwards Macron should withdraw the “poisoned law”.

“It is obvious today that the government has a problem of legitimacy and the president cannot remain a spectator of this situation,” he told BFMTV.

The leader of the far-right in parliament Marine Le Pen, who challenged Macron in the 2022 elections, said Borne “should go or be made to resign by the president”.

A survey on Sunday showed the head of state’s personal rating at its lowest level since the height of the “Yellow Vest” protest movement in 2019, with only 28 percent of respondents having a positive view of him.

Macron has argued that the pension changes are needed to avoid crippling deficits in the coming decades linked to France’s ageing population.

Opponents of the reform say it places an unfair burden on low earners, women and people doing physically wearing jobs. Opinion polls have consistently shown that two thirds of French people oppose the changes.

© AFP 2023 

Your Voice
Readers Comments
This is YOUR comments community. Stay civil, stay constructive, stay on topic. Please familiarise yourself with our comments policy here before taking part.
Leave a Comment
    Submit a report
    Please help us understand how this comment violates our community guidelines.
    Thank you for the feedback
    Your feedback has been sent to our team for review.

    Leave a commentcancel