#Open journalism No news is bad news

Your contributions will help us continue to deliver the stories that are important to you

Support The Journal
Dublin: 4°C Wednesday 25 November 2020

Garda launches High Court challenge aimed at preventing dismissal from force

The action has been brought by Garda Paul Mulcair, who is stationed at Kinsale Garda Station in Co Cork.

Image: Graham Hughes via RollingNews.ie

A GARDA HAS launched a High Court challenge aimed at preventing his dismissal from the force. 

The action has been brought by Garda Paul Mulcair, who is stationed at Kinsale Garda Station in Co Cork, who the High Court heard was found following an internal Garda probe to have breached Garda Discipline Regulations. 

The allegations against Garda Mulcair, who denies any wrongdoing, were that on dates between 2014 and 2017 he asked 10 persons from the community he both lived and policed in for a total of €140,300 and was in receipt of €9,700.

Following an investigation into the allegations a Board of Inquiry was convened by An Garda Síochana to determine if Garda Mulcair had committed a serious breach of discipline. 

The Garda accepted that he had approached persons seeking to borrow money, which he said was repaid. 

The court heard that one person who was asked by Garda Mulcair for a loan, allowed the garda use the credit facility in his shop so he could buy food. 

The Garda accepted he had written to one individual asking for money, he denied asking that individual for €120,000 as alleged and said he had not requested a specific amount in his letter. 

In its decision of 27 January last the board held that the Garda was in breach of garda discipline. 

Garda Mulcair rejected the finding that he has used his position as a police officer for his own personal advantage, or that he could not carry out his duties because he was beholden to other persons.

These findings were illogical and there was no evidence that the Garda had ever failed to properly carry out his duties.

Arising out of its findings the board made a recommendation to the Garda Commissioner that Garda Mulcair, who is currently suspended from duty, be dismissed. 

Last August the then acting Garda Commissioner John Twomey, having regard for the board’s recommendation, decided that Garda Mulcair should be dismissed for two breaches and that he should resign in lieu of dismissal on five breaches. 

The Garda claims that the disciplinary process, which commenced in 2018 and concluded in January of this year, was flawed, that irrelevant considerations were taken into account and that he has not been treated fairly by the board.

He claims that on 22 November last the three-person board said that having considered all matters it was in a position to deliver its decision.  

This announcement was made by the board before his solicitor, who was taken aback by this, had made submissions that the evidence did not support the allegations against the Garda. 

The Garda claims that this action by the board amounted to a predetermination by the board of the allegations against him and has tainted the entire inquiry.

#Open journalism No news is bad news Support The Journal

Your contributions will help us continue to deliver the stories that are important to you

Support us now

He also claims that the he was prejudiced because the board heard allegations of events that occurred in 2013, which were not the subject of the investigation.  

He further claims that no reasons were given by the Acting Commissioner for his decision.

He has brought judicial review proceedings against the Garda Commissioner where he seeks orders quashing the board’s findings, recommendations and the decision that he dismissed or resign.   

Permission to bring the challenge was granted, on an ex-parte basis, by Mr Justice Charles Meenan.

The judge adjourned the matter to a date in December. 

Comments are closed as legal proceedings are ongoing.

About the author:

Aodhan O Faolain

Read next: