Readers like you keep news free for everyone.

More than 5,000 readers have already pitched in to keep free access to The Journal.

For the price of one cup of coffee each week you can help keep paywalls away.

Support us today
Not now

Google to change how it displays search results in Europe

The company announced the move in a bid to appease concerns it might be abusing its dominant market position.

Image: Paul Sakuma/AP/Press Association Images

GOOGLE HAS AGREED to change how it displays search results in Europe — including a better labeling of its promoted content and displaying links to competitors — to appease concerns it might be abusing its dominant market position, the European Union’s antitrust body said today.

Google’s search engine, which is the world’s most influential gateway to online information and commerce, enjoys a near-monopoly in Europe.

The EU Commission, which acts as the 27-nation bloc’s antitrust authority, has since 2010 been investigating whether the company is unfairly stifling competition.

It pointed out several areas of concern that Google is now trying to address through the proposed concessions.

Google has offered to more clearly label search results stemming from its own services such as Google News, Google Maps or its shopping and flight search functions.

That would allow users to distinguish between natural search results and others promoted by Google. It also agreed to display some search results from its competitors and links to their services, the EU Commission said.

The Commission has often taken a harder line with US tech companies than its American counterparts, the Federal Trade Commission and the Justice Department.

Google, which is based in Mountain View, California, was able to settle a similar antitrust complaint on its search business with the FTC in January without making any major concessions on how it runs its search engine.

The EU Commission is now proposing a market test of the concessions for a month. That would give competitors the chance to say whether they deem them sufficient.

‘A settled outcome’

“The objective of this process is to try to see if we can achieve a settled outcome in this antitrust investigation,” said Commission spokesman Antoine Colombani.

A group of 17 companies competing with Google — including tech giants and internet companies such as Microsoft, Nokia Expedia and TripAdvisor — vowed to carefully study the concessions proposed by Google.

“The most important remedy to Google’s abuse of dominance is to require the search monopoly (…) to subject its own products and services to the same policy it uses to rank and display all other websites,” said the group, collectively called FairSearch.

Legally binding

Once the Commission accepts the concessions — revised or not — they become legally binding for the company for the next five years. If the deal is accepted, Google would avoid a fine and a finding of wrongdoing.

If Google were then to break its commitments, the Commission could impose a fine of up to 10 percent of its annual worldwide revenue — that would be close to a whopping $5 billion in Google’s case.

The Commission said Google will “clearly separate promoted links from other web search results by clear graphical features” and “display links to three rival specialized search services close to its own services, in a place that is clearly visible to users.”


Google will also give all websites the option to keep their content from being used in Google’s specialized search services, “while ensuring that any opt-out does not unduly affect the ranking of those web sites in Google’s general web search results,” it said.

In addition, the proposed remedies will give newspaper publishers greater control over what appears in Google’s news aggregator, Google News.

Google is also giving marketers greater ability to buy ads on rival networks — one of several concessions aimed at appeasing fears it is abusing its dominance of the online advertising market.

To normal users in Europe, the changes in the display of search results will only be visible once the Commission accepts the settlement, most likely later this year.

Algorithm unchanged

However, Google’s algorithm — the unique mathematical formula that ranks its search results — will remain unchanged. That means the company retains the power to decide what search results are displayed most prominently.

Making a difference

A mix of advertising and supporting contributions helps keep paywalls away from valuable information like this article.

Over 5,000 readers like you have already stepped up and support us with a monthly payment or a once-off donation.

For the price of one cup of coffee each week you can make sure we can keep reliable, meaningful news open to everyone regardless of their ability to pay.

The Commission’s investigation was initially triggered by complaints from Google’s rivals.

One of them, British comparison-shopping site Foundem, said that at first glance the proposed concessions “fall far short” of ensuring a level playing field in the search results market.

“Instead of promising to end its abusive practices, Google’s proposal seems to offer a half-hearted attempt to dilute their anti-competitive effects, by labeling Google’s own services and throwing in some token links to competitors’ services alongside them,” the company said.

The measures won’t “make a dent in Google’s ability to hijack the traffic and revenues of its rivals,” it added.

Google worked closely with the Commission on the concessions’ design until formally submitting them earlier this month.

“We continue to work cooperatively with the European Commission”, Google spokesman Al Verney said today.

90 per cent market share

Google’s web search service has a market share of over 90 percent in the EU, a bloc of over 500 million people that makes up the world’s largest economy. In the U.S., competitors Bing and Yahoo have a share of about 30 percent of the search market.

Separately, major tech companies led by Microsoft Corp. this month also filed another EU antitrust complaint against Google, alleging the company uses the dominant position of its Android smartphone operating system to illegitimately promote its own array of internet services.

Microsoft, which has been a leading player in the complaints against Google, has had its own protracted run-ins with the EU Commission. The company from Redmond, Washington, has paid €2.2 billion in various fines since investigations began in 1998.

Read: From Budapest to Everest, Google Street View reaches 50 countries >

About the author:

Associated Press

Read next: