#Open journalism No news is bad news

Your contributions will help us continue to deliver the stories that are important to you

Support The Journal
Dublin: 12°C Monday 20 September 2021

The gloves are off: Socialists slam Brid Smith for splitting Dublin vote

Socialist MEP Paul Murphy lost his seat tonight but told reporters we haven’t seen the last of him yet…

Image: High O'Connell via Twitter

SOCIALIST PARTY MEP Paul Murphy and party leader Joe Higgins, have this evening criticised People Before Profit’s Brid Smith for splitting the vote in the European election as it becomes ever-clearer that Murphy will not retain his seat.

In the first count last night, Murphy received 29,953 votes while Smith took 23,875. Sinn Féin’s Lynn Boylan swept ahead of all other candidates, receiving a whopping 83,264 votes in the first count. The socialist candidate was eliminated on the fourth count.

When asked last night if he thought Smith had created problems for him by splitting the vote, Murphy said “I think, unfortunately, that’s a fact – that’s what the figures will demonstrate,” telling reporters he would have preferred it if the People Before Profit candidate hadn’t run.

Backing him up on this front, his party leader said it was ”very regrettable that People Before Profit decided to put forward a candidate against Paul, who is an incumbent with three years of highly credible activity in the European Parliament.”

It’s clear that there was room here for one serious left MEP. I believe that we could have taken that seat or been very, very strongly contesting but when the vote is split it kind of denies you some momentum in the earlier stages of the campaign, say a month or so out.
So, yes it was regrettable and shouldn’t have been done but now, as Paul indicated, we want to work with those on the left – genuine anti-austerity campaigners – to build the type of campaigns that are needed to protect the ordinary people from the ongoing ravages of austerity.

Bríd Smith, on the otherhand, doesn’t think she’s to blame.

“Well, see, I don’t think that even if you added my total and Paul’s total together, you’re looking at about 50,000, 52,000 votes, that would never have been enough to get Paul over the line and it certainly wouldn’t have been enough to, you know, win him a seat,” she said, speaking after the first count tonight.

“The point about it is, nobody ever asks Fianna Fáil or Fine Gael why are they both running and splitting their vote when there’s less than a cigarette paper’s thickness between them, in the difference between their policies.”

She said “nobody was going to overtake Sinn Féin today” and that’s the different factor in this election, “not Paul and Bríd”.

What’s next for Murphy?

Higgins has already said he will not be running in the next general election and Murphy indicated this will be his next move.


“This is the beginning – not the end – for me, for the Socialist Party, for the left,” he said.

“There is a desperate need to build a left in this country and I think I can, hopefully, be a very important party of that.”

Read: Sinn Féin’s Lynn Boylan wins the first MEP seat in Dublin as count heads into Monday morning>

Read: Who is your new local councillor? Here’s a list of everyone elected so far>

Read next:


This is YOUR comments community. Stay civil, stay constructive, stay on topic. Please familiarise yourself with our comments policy here before taking part.
write a comment

    Leave a commentcancel