#Open journalism No news is bad news

Your contributions will help us continue to deliver the stories that are important to you

Support The Journal
Dublin: 17°C Saturday 24 July 2021

'No social or economic sense': IPRT criticise prison sentence after woman jailed for damaging a €1.50 tube of Pringles

Judge Brian O’Shea described Kathleen McDonagh’s actions as “smart-alec behaviour”.

Image: Shutterstock/Faiz Zaki

THE IRISH PENAL Reform Trust (IPRT) has criticised a court ruling after a woman, who caused criminal damage by opening a €1.50 tube of pringles at a Tesco supermarket, was sentenced to two months in prison by a judge in Cork. 

Kathleen McDonagh (24) from Mahon, Co. Cork pleaded guilty to causing criminal damage to the tube of Pringles crisps on 27 December 2016. 

Judge Brian O’Shea sentenced Mahon to four months in prison, with half of the sentence suspended, the Irish Examiner has reported. 

The offence took place after McDonagh – who had 14 previous theft convictions – entered a Tesco store in Mahon Point and went to the self-scan area with the packet of Pringles and proceeded to open it. 

Reacting to the judgement, Deputy Executive Director of IRPT Fiona Ní Chinnéide says that such prison sentences make “no social or economic sense.”

“It’s a poor use of taxpayer money when community service has proven to be a more cost effective response, particularly for women who offend.”

Since 2011, judges in Ireland have been obliged to consider community service “in lieu” of sentences of less than 12 months, says Ní Chinnéide. “What’s important is that it’s not about letting anyone off the hook. It’s about the most effective response to crime.”

Ní Chinnéide says that robust data and evidence underpinning any response to crime is what is needed. 

In sentencing McDonagh, Judge O’Shea said that it’s difficult not to view her actions as anything other than “smart-alec behaviour”. 

The judge proceeded to impose the partially suspended sentence, with recognisance pending an appeal set at €200.

About the author:

Read next: