Readers like you keep news free for everyone.

More than 5,000 readers have already pitched in to keep free access to The Journal.

For the price of one cup of coffee each week you can help keep paywalls away.

Support us today
Not now
Wednesday 1 February 2023 Dublin: 9°C
Photocall Mould in an apartment at Dolphin House
# horrible
Ireland is facing a human rights case over the awful state of social housing here
The state has until 28 May to respond to a complaint made to the EU

RESIDENTS OF 20 Local Authority housing estates around Ireland have had a complaint they’ve taken against the Irish State regarding the dire conditions of their housing ruled admissible by the European Committee of Social Rights (ECSR) in Strasbourg.

The case is a landmark one given the collective nature of the complaint.  The tenants of the houses in question were assisted in lodging the complaint by several agencies including the Housing Law department of NUIG and Community Action Network (CAN), together with the International Federation of Human Rights (FIDH).

The complaint has been five years in the making and alleges that Irish law and policy on Local Authority housing breaches tenant rights under the European Social Charter.  It was first lodged with Strasbourg in July 2014.

carmel Photocall / Mark Stedman Damp in Carmel Lynam's childrens' bedroom, Dolphin House Photocall / Mark Stedman / Mark Stedman

Specific issues raised include:

  • Substandard housing conditions both internally and externally
  • Failure of Local Authorities to accept structural deficiencies in housing
  • Health impacts on children, families, and vulnerable people
  • No national survey of housing conditions for over a decade

The 20 estates include Balgaddy, Dolphin House, and Ballymun in Dublin and Moyross in Limerick.

Common housing issues reported include living with dampness, mould, sewerage, poor maintenance and pyrite.

Dolphins Barn Regeneration Reports James Horan / Photocall Ireland Dolphin House in Dublin's south inner city James Horan / Photocall Ireland / Photocall Ireland

Dolphin House in Dublin’s south inner city is a strong example of regeneration gone wrong.  Phase one of the process has been delayed several times and is now more than two years behind schedule.

One resident there, Debbie Mulhall, spoke of how breaches of tenants’ rights has resulted in third-class citizenship for over 350,000 people around the country.

debbie RTE Debbie Mulhalll RTE

“Your home and where you raise your family is so much more than just bricks and mortar,” she said.

We are being denied basic rights and being treated like third class citizens simply because we are tenants of the state.
The regeneration is already well over 18 months behind time and at this rate it could be years before it really happens.
In the meantime, tenants continue to live in conditions that  we allege are unacceptable, unhealthy and uninhabitable.

alan kelly Photocall / Sam Boal Environment minister Alan Kelly Photocall / Sam Boal / Sam Boal has requested comment from the Department of the Environment.

Although the decision by the ECSR is not legally binding a continued breach of the Social Charter could see Ireland facing a resolution from the ECSR’s council of ministers.  No EU member state has ever ignored such a resolution.

Ireland has until May 28 to respond to the ECSR’s decision.

Read: ‘I’m sleeping on a friend’s sofa on the verge of becoming homeless, I don’t know what to do’

Read: From tower blocks to BER ratings… the housing landscape has changed a lot in sixty years

Your Voice
Readers Comments