We need your help now

Support from readers like you keeps The Journal open.

You are visiting us because we have something you value. Independent, unbiased news that tells the truth. Advertising revenue goes some way to support our mission, but this year it has not been enough.

If you've seen value in our reporting, please contribute what you can, so we can continue to produce accurate and meaningful journalism. For everyone who needs it.

File photo: British soldiers searching people in Shankill Road, Belfast in October 1969. KEMP AP/Press Association Images

Taoiseach Jack Lynch confronted Prime Minister on torture claims in Northern Ireland

In documents seen by Channel 4, the Ministry of Defence admitted that they found some claims of torture credible.

DOCUMENTS FROM THE UK’s Ministry of Defence (MOD) have suggested that torture techniques such as waterboarding and electro shock were used by the British army in Northern Ireland in the 1970s.

Channel 4 News also reports that Taoiseach Jack Lynch had directly raised the issue of torture being used in the North with Prime Minister Ted Heath in late-1972.

MOD memos show that they considered the torture claims to be credible, and sought to compensate some of the victims.

The Pat Finucane Centre in Belfast helped to uncover the documents and said that they provide “new evidence of what both British and Irish governments knew at the highest level”.

The alleged torture was said to have been carried out by the British parachute regiment, who’d taken to the streets of Belfast in 1972, and who were said to have commandeered a primary school in Ballymurphy in west Belfast to use for this purpose.


Reporter Alex Thomson spoke to some of the alleged torture victims, one who was only 17 at the time, who told him of their experiences.

“I was brutalised,” one said. “A lot of physical beating and kicking, and then it progressed onto other forms of torture. One that is now being described as waterboarding.

There was a cloth tied round my head. I was held face down by two soldiers and water was poured down the back of head which filled the cloth. It was the sensation of drowning. I was convinced [I was going to die].

Another man told of his own experience of being waterboarded before he was subjected to electro shock treatment.

He said: “I remember being told to hold two sort of attachments. Behind me, I could hear a machine.

“I could hear the noise of the cranking. Suddenly a massive explosion came around the centre of your head.”

Secret minutes from a meeting in Downing Street in late 1972 show that then-Taoiseach Jack Lynch raised this issue with Tory Prime Minister Ted Heath.

Irish PM Jack Lynch Taoiseach Jack Lynch on his way to visit Prime Minister Ted Heath PA Archive / PA Images PA Archive / PA Images / PA Images

Lynch said: “He was forced to lie on his back on the floor, a wet towel had been placed over his head, and water had been poured over it to give the impression that he would be suffocated.”

“Improper use of power”

Other memos obtained from the MOD indicate that the claims of torture were found to be credible.

One said: “I think we must accept counsel’s advice that he was assaulted… having been subjected to electric shock treatment and having had his head immersed in water for prolonged periods of time.” It is understood the man in question was compensated in an out of court settlement.

In another case, an MOD document read: “A court is likely to award exemplary damages to mark the improper use of executive power.”

In 2014, an RTÉ documentary revealed how torture methods were used during internment in 1971 by the British State. The 14 “Hooded Men” were taken to a secret location in rural Derry, and were then subjected to a horrific series of interrogations.

This led to a case being reopened by the Irish government and brought to the European Court of Human Rights in Strasbourg, where a verdict has yet to be reached.

Just last week, former colonel and current Conservative MP, Bob Stewart, said he was “kind of a torturer” during his seven tours of Northern Ireland.

A statement from the MOD released yesterday said: “The UK government considers torture or inhuman treatment to be an abhorrent violation of human rights and human dignity, and consistently and unreservedly condemns the practice. It would not be appropriate to comment further on specific allegations.”

Speaking to RTÉ’s Morning Ireland, Paul O’Connor from the Pat Finucane Centre called these documents “very significant”.

“Only this week, we’ve had the United Nations issuing a very strong statement on waterboarding that it was a crime… It’s a crime that can never, ever be excused by any government.”

“We found out of court settlement documents where they’re absolutely determined to make an out of court settlement because they do not want a claim that someone was waterboarded and electro shocked at the same time.”

Read: British MP says he was ‘kind of a torturer’ during the Troubles

Read: RTÉ documentary reveals evidence about torture methods used in Northern Ireland’s past

Your Voice
Readers Comments
    Submit a report
    Please help us understand how this comment violates our community guidelines.
    Thank you for the feedback
    Your feedback has been sent to our team for review.