We need your help now

Support from readers like you keeps The Journal open.

You are visiting us because we have something you value. Independent, unbiased news that tells the truth. Advertising revenue goes some way to support our mission, but this year it has not been enough.

If you've seen value in our reporting, please contribute what you can, so we can continue to produce accurate and meaningful journalism. For everyone who needs it.

The crashed Manx2 aircraft at Cork Airport on 10 February PA Images/Niall Carson
Cork air crash

Aviation company behind Cork air crash 'in danger of losing its licence to fly'

Concerns over Barcelona-based Flightline outlined as BBC radio programme hears how survivor’s recollection of the horror crash.

THE OPERATOR BEHIND the Manx2 flight which crashed at Cork airport on 10 February, killing six people on board, is “in danger of losing its licence”.

Barcelona-based aviation company Flightline, which subcontracted the Belfast-Cork route to Manx2 staff, has been warned that it will lose its operator certificate if it doesn’t come up with “a corrective plan to address several immediate safety concerns”.

A BBC Radio4 programme in the Face the Facts series, due to be aired today at 12.30pm, is to reveal that Flightline was hauled in front of the European Commissions’ Safety Committee last month, following which it has had to promise to revise its procedures over pilot selection and change its company manual on the use of alternative aerodromes (The preliminary report into the Cork air crash found that the inexperienced pilots on board attempted to land the plane in heavy fog of Cork, instead of diverting to an alternative airport).

John Waite, presenter of the Face the Facts programme, told

It also has to come up with a corrective action plan to address several immediate safety concerns.

Waite said that Flightline is “in danger of losing its licence to fly” aircraft following some inspections by the Spanish Civil Air Authority which discovered what it described as “discrepancies”. Waite added:

The British Airline Pilots’ Association (BALPA) is calling for tighter rules on these ‘virtual’ airlines, such as Manx2, which sells seats but where all these other things, the craft, the pilots, are subcontracted in.

Jim McAuslan, the General Secretary of BALPA warned:

Pilots are seriously concerned about these virtual airlines. The day is going to come, and the public should realise it, that whether when you get onto an aircraft, you should ask yourself some serious questions.

How is this airline operated, who is in the front of the aircraft, how is this aircraft maintained. The (British) government and regulator need to step in to stop this drift into a virtual world of aviation.

One of the survivors of the Cork air crash, Mark Dickens, a father-of-three from Kent in England, told Face the Facts that he thought he was going to die as the plane landed and flipped over. He was conscious throughout the whole incident and said:

As we came through the cloud I realised it was fog because we were only about 30 feet off the runway, still travelling very fast and we seemed to be to the right hand side of the runway.

I did shout out that I thought that we were going to crash. Immediately I thought we were never going to land this safely. I shouted out, “We’re going to crash, we’re going to crash”. A few people screamed and then the plane lurched fairly violently to the left, fairly violently to the right and I was looking out the window, at this point we were still descending.

The wing tip, where I was sitting next to, just hit the runway, we flipped over onto the back and then slid off the runway into this mud and there was screaming and shouting, the sound of glass breaking, all the windows smashed. And then we came to rest.

The ex-policeman said that he thought several times that he was going to die.

We ended up sitting upside down and I started to get very wet and for one awful moment I thought we had landed in a lake or river or something and we were all going to drown. I couldn’t move, I was trapped underneath seats that had come loose, people still in those seats, bags and things and I was wedged in underneath. My feet were trapped under the seat in front and I was wedged in between my seat and the ceiling of the plane, which was now the floor.

He described the scene of carnage inside the plane:

As I looked around, all I could see was a lot of dark mass, because the plane had flipped over and the windows had smashed it had filled with mud. The seats in the plane were dark blue leather, the plane was fairly dark. As it had been a cold morning, everyone had been wearing big overcoats and things, so all I could see around me were big dark shapes. There were people in chairs on top of me, and I could hear screaming, moaning, shouting and then I heard another passenger shout, ‘We’re on fire, we’re on fire’.

Going through my head, having gone from thinking I was going to drown in the plane, I now thought I was going to die in flames in a plane. I could then smell smoke and fuel and again, sitting next to the wing, and knowing that a lot of fuel is carried in the wings…

It was only when he heard emergency crews trying to get into the plane that he realised he would be saved. Even so, the ordeal was not yet over. In his former career, he had dealt with fatal road accidents and fed into that experience to keep calm. But that experience also brought him to a horrendous realisation:

Unfortunately, experience has told me that people make a certain noise when they’re taking their final breaths and I had heard those sort of death rattles. I had heard those noises in the plane.

Once the emergency services got in and they started to move people around, I started getting into more pain because by its nature, they were moving people off me, which was causing seats to crush down on me. I started getting more and more pain then and I closed my eyes to try and focus on things and shut things out so I wasn’t really thinking of anybody else at that point, if I’m honest.

Mark Dickens was seriously injured in the crash but John Waite points out that even though he is entitled to his medical expenses under EU aviation legislation, the complications of who was responsible for passengers of this plane made getting that compensation difficult. Manx2 told him it had nothing to do with them. It illustrates, said presenter and reporter John Waite, the lack of transparency behind flying with ‘virtual airlines’:

Mark Dickens went through check-in, saw staff with the Manx logo on their shirts, got on a flight with the Manx logo but it wasn’t the company responsible behind it at all.

Listen to Face The Facts at 12.30pm on BBC Radio4 today for John Waite’s full investigation>

No faults in Cork Airport crash plane: Preliminary report>

Six confirmed dead after plane flips over on landing in Cork>

Former pilot of Cork airport crash plane takes his own life>