#Open journalism No news is bad news

Your contributions will help us continue to deliver the stories that are important to you

Support The Journal
Dublin: 4°C Sunday 29 May 2022

Mother found guilty of child cruelty for allowing her son to be locked in a box

Her husband was convicted last week on nine counts of rape.

Image: PA Archive/Press Association Images

Updated at 2.50pm

A MOTHER OF five has been convicted of child cruelty following a seven week trial which heard dozens of allegations of horrific sexual abuse against her youngest son.

The 38 year old woman, who is from the UK, has already been found not guilty of sex assault relating to allegations she had sex or simulated sex with her child when he was between six and seven.

On Friday the jury convicted the woman’s 64 year old partner, who is also from the UK, of nine counts of raping his son from the age of six years old and child cruelty. They acquitted him of raping the child with a poker.

The child gave evidence that it was his father who raped and beat him and locked him in a box for six hours. The charge of cruelty which the woman was convicted of was a general charge of allowing the abuse to happen at the hands of her partner.

The boy’s father faced nine counts of raping the boy, nine counts of raping the boy with a poker and one count of cruelty. The mother faced two counts of sexual assault relating to allegations she had sex with the boy and one count of cruelty.

Both parents had pleaded not guilty to the allegations which are alleged to have occurred between 2009 and 2011 in their Waterford home.

The parents had originally faced a total of 82 charges but 60 of these were withdraw last week following legal argument.

Final verdict

After the jury delivered its final verdict Mr Justice Robert Eagar indicated he intended to grant the woman bail until sentencing. However gardaí “strongly” objected, saying the woman was a flight risk.

Her partner was remanded in custody on Friday after his conviction. He will be sentenced on 11 July, next.

Prosecuting counsel Pauline Walley SC said the woman’s partner was her only tie to Ireland and now that he has been jailed gardaí believe she may flee.

A Waterford garda told the court the woman has four other children who are in care and who she has no contact with. Most of the rest of her family, including her mother, live in the UK.

The family home where the abuse occurred has since been sold and the woman lives in rented accommodation in another county. The garda said she has no means to support herself in Ireland.

Her partner had been receiving social welfare but payments stopped before the trial.

In support of bail, the woman’s defence counsel said she has surrendered her passport to gardaí and her partner is willing to keep paying her rent from custody.

Mr Justice Eagar said in light of the garda objections he would remand the woman in custody. She will be sentenced separately from her partner on 4 July.

The child had told gardaí that his mother willingly “had sex” with him while his father watched and filmed it.

However during evidence at trial he said his mother had been forced to have sex with him by the father and she complied because he threatened to kick her out of the house if she didn’t.

The boy told the jury he loved his mother and that she was a nice woman. He said that when he told her he had been raped by his father she gave out to the man.

After the child was taken into care just before his eighth birthday his mother continued to have access visits with him. These visits ceased when the child was sent to the UK to receive specialised residential care because of his sexualised behaviour.

#Open journalism No news is bad news Support The Journal

Your contributions will help us continue to deliver the stories that are important to you

Support us now

Harrowing evidence 

The seven week trial heard often harrowing evidence including allegations that the child’s father filmed the child having sex with the mother and showed the footage to people who visited the house.

Other allegations heard by the jury included that the father defecated on the child and threatened to kill him while holding a gun to his head.

The child was taken into care just before his eighth birthday after telling his teacher his father had been beating him and he “couldn’t take it anymore.”

He was sent to a foster home where widespread sexual abuse occurred. The boy was sexually abused by another boy while in foster care. A third child is awaiting sentence for sexual abuse he carried out in the house.

The boy was sent to another foster home after about a year. He trusted his new foster parents and said he felt safe enough there to begin disclosing the abuse he suffered. His foster mother recorded the allegations in detailed daily logs which she handed over to gardaí.

While in the second foster home the boy began displaying highly disturbing and sexualised behaviour. He made sexual threats to the mother when he got upset, was found interfering with animals and seemed to have an obsession with faeces.

His foster mother told the trial she loved the boy dearly but couldn’t handle his behaviour.

The HSE was forced to send him to the UK for specialised residential treatment as no such treatment was available in Ireland. The last thing he said to his foster mother before leaving was “I feel like a dog that nobody wants.”

The now 12 year old remains in the care unit. He gave evidence via video-link from a room in the Old Bailey in London. Several concessions were made for the child witness under the new EU directive on victims rights.

Read: Waterford father found guilty of rape of his son

About the author:

Declan Brennan and Conor Gallagher

Read next: