Welcome to our Public Beta Site - What does this mean?
Dublin: 12 °C Wednesday 23 May, 2012

Banking crisis: Central Bank paid out €30m in consultancy fees in 2011

The big winner?
The big winner?
Image: Leon Farrell/Photocall Ireland

THE CENTRAL BANK saw its bill for consultants’ services relating to the banking crisis shoot up to €29.9 million last year.

In 2010, the same bill was just €1.3 million.

However, the Central Bank could not explain the jump in fees. It advised that it could not provide details of payments to individual consultants due to “commercial confidentiality reasons”.

In a statement to TheJournal.ie, the Central Bank said that the costs include “work done for the Financial Measures Programme”.

Since 2008, the Central Bank has spent €38.4 million on consultancy fees relating to the banking crisis.

A further €49 million has been spent by other State agencies in the past four years in respect of advice received about the banking sector.

In response to a parliamentary question from Michael McGrath, the Minister for Finance revealed the consultancy costs accrued by the National Treasury Management Agency, the National Pension Reserve Fund and the Department of Finance, as well as the Central Bank.

A breakdown of who-was-paid-what was given in relation to the NTMA, the NPRF and the Department of Finance.

Law firm Arthur Cox was a winner across the board as it was the go-to for legal advice in relation to the banking crisis. Since 2008, consultancy services provided to the Department of Finance in relation to the Bank Guarantee Scheme, the recapitalisation and restructuring of the banks and other general advice amounted to €13.6 million.

The NTMA paid Arthur Cox €7.74 million over the past four years, while it hired Goldman Sachs last year following the announcement of stress test results in March. About €6.29 million was paid to the investment banking firm about capital raising exercises at the four main institutions.

A further €2.61 million was billed by McKinsey & Co for advice given about the AIB/EBS merger and the restructuring of Anglo Irish Bank and Irish Nationwide.

Consultancy services worth €7.33 million and €6.96 were obtained by the NTMA from Merill Lynch and Rothschild respectively for banking advisory services over the past four years.

The NPRF’s consultancy costs were substantially lower than the other agencies but Arthur Cox still topped the list with a bill of €2.18 million for “legal due diligence on banks prior to recapitalisation in 2009″ and “legal advice in respect of directed investments in 2010″.

A further €1.58 million was paid out to PricewaterhouseCooper – also in relation to “due diligence on Bank of Ireland and AIB prior to recapitalisation”.

Last week it was revealed that NAMA racked up a €27 million legal bill in two years for expenses accrued for advise pertaining to loans acquired from participating institutions.

Arthur Cox received over €3 million, the highest amount of any one firm.

Read Next:

Comments (12 Comments)

  • Billygoatmuff 13/02/12 #
    Report this comment

    €30,000000 to flip a coin. Where do I send my CV to?

    Reply
  • Paul Ryan 13/02/12 #
    Report this comment

    If half these clowns could do the job they’re paid ridiculous money to do there would be no need for ‘consultancy fees’!!

    Reply
  • HELLO SPRUIKER 13/02/12 #
    Report this comment

    €30 Million
    Great.
    That only leaves the
    NAMA
    IBRC
    BOI
    AIB
    Irish Nationwide
    PTSB
    EBS
    Dept Of Finance
    etc
    etc
    etc……
    Consultancy fees to pay.

    Reply
  • Peter 66 13/02/12 #
    Report this comment

    I imagine a phone call going like this,

    Noonan.. Hello is that the cox lads

    Cox… Yeah wha ?

    Noonan… What do ya think ?

    Cox…. About wha ?

    Noonan…. The economy & tha ?

    Cox…. Its bolloxed mick

    Noonan… Good man coxy tks, how much is tha ?

    Reply
  • Sean O'Keeffe 13/02/12 #
    Report this comment

    “The money power preys upon the nation in times of peace and conspires against it in times of adversity. It is more despotic than monarchy, more insolent than autocracy, more selfish than bureaucracy.”

    - Abraham Lincoln

    Reply
  • connman 13/02/12 #
    Report this comment

    Now which bit of millions of euro advice told ye to not appoint a receiver to take control of insolvent private businesses but instead hand over billions, be told you are now the majority shareholder but you will have no say or control in the said business. Genius

    Reply
  • Kerry Blake 13/02/12 #
    Report this comment

    2 words come to mind. Pigs & troughs….

    Reply
  • Simon Kennedy 13/02/12 #
    Report this comment

    so why are we paying huge salaries to people in the centeral bank only to out sourse the work

    Reply
  • Adam Magari 13/02/12 #
    Report this comment

    Gravy, gravy all the way for the elite. 30 million works out at 600k per week, 120k per day. Allowing for an eight hour day, that breaks down to FIFTEEN THOUSAND EUROS PER HOUR. If the Central Bank cannot reveal how it justifies spending FIFTEEN THOUSAND EUROS PER HOUR of taxpayers’ money on legal advice for one year, there is really something very very wrong with Ireland. Now that the tribunals are drying up, it seems the government is only too willing to find alternatives for the legal elite to access the public purse. Shocking and shameful. Will any TD on the government benches call demand a breakdown of these costs? No. After a period of public hand wringing. Nothing will change and the taxpayer will still be paying through both nostrils.

    Reply
  • Jamie O Sullivan 13/02/12 #
    Report this comment

    Criminal waste of money, no surprises there really. If nothing changes, nothing changes.

    Reply
  • Karl O Flynn 13/02/12 #
    Report this comment

    Unbelievable !!!! Why am I not surprised anymore by this B.S. It just goes on and on. Who the hell is making these decisions?

    Reply

Add New Comment