TheJournal.ie uses cookies. By continuing to browse this site you are agreeing to our use of cookies. Click here to find out more »
Dublin: 8 °C Wednesday 22 May, 2013

Research says Ireland has second highest rejection rate for SME loans

Research released by the Central Bank today says that Ireland has the second lowest level of lending to small businesses in the euro area, behind Greece.

Image: zingbot via Flickr

NEW RESEARCH PUBLISHED by the Central Bank today says that Ireland has one of the highest rejection rates for loans and credit to small businesses in the euro area.

Ireland is second only to Greece when it comes to the level of rejections for loans and overdrafts to small and medium-sized businesses.

Changes in the terms and conditions of bank credit in Ireland are among the least favourable in the euro area, the research says.

“The data report that the Irish rejection rate for credit applications is the second highest in the euro area, while Irish SMEs are among the most likely to have faced increased collateral requirements, increased interest rates, or lower loan quantities,” the report says.

The research, entitled Irish SME credit supply and demand: comparisons across surveys and countries, was carried out by two Central Bank economists, Sarah Holton and Fergal McCann.

It also found that credit demand in Ireland is above the euro area average but that actual application rates for credit are below the euro area average among small and medium-sized businesses.

It also says that Ireland has the second highest share of discouraged borrowers, i.e. firms who do not apply for a loan despite requiring credit, in the euro area.

The Central Bank says that its report varies “only negligably” from some of the main research in the area between September of last year and March of this year.

This research comes from the European Central Bank and European Commission’s Survey of Access to Finance of Small and Medium Enterprises (SAFE) and the Mazars SME Lending Demand Survey (Mazars).

However, the economists note in their report that their research is based on survey data and they state that they cannot analyse the volume of credit demanded or available to firms in Ireland as balance sheet data on small and medium enterprises is not available.

Earlier, the Irish Banking Federation chief executive Pat Farrell rejected the findings of the report despite having not seen it.

He questioned the methodology and said that its findings appear to differ from that of the Mazars survey.

Read: The research in full from the Central Bank >

Read: Banking Federation rejects report on lending to small businesses

Read next:

Comments (23 Comments)

  • How do they expect the economy to grow if the banks won’t lend, something has to be done about this.
    Disgraceful

    Reply
  • As a small builder, (not developer), i do once off houses, renovations, extensions. I still have plenty of interest from people who want to build, extend, renovate but they can’t access credit. most of them are pre-approved for a mortgage but are turned down eventually after making them jump through hoops of fire in paperwork. Most of the people i come across in this situation 2 income couples. What seems to be happening is they are able to show figures for pre approved lending to the media, but not finally approve the loans. Just barely surviving with odd client using inheritance / savings / sale of asset. Emigration with a broken heart beckons soon if the banks can’t be brought to heel, hard to see that happening though..

    Reply
  • When I turn on my state sponsored tv station and see our government sponsored banks telling us to call in as they have bucket loads of money they want to lend us it makes my blood boil. Just a complete crock of shit. Time for a revolution.

    Reply
  • According to last month’s Sunday Business Post banks in 2011 advanced ?1.6b in credit to small business, however they also withdrew ?2.4b in credit during same period so regrettably Govt has utterly failed as small business credit is down ?800m.

    Reply
  • The banks, even though the people own them, are still LYING to the people. To my mind, the rooting out of the bad apples has not deep enough. These banks are rotten to the core

    Reply
  • Why we did we bail out the banks?

    Reply
  • elaine 22/08/12 #

    I am a participant in this Croke park agreement, and because the bank won’t even look at me for a mortgage I instead pay 950 a month for rent in a house which will never be mine. Yes I can see where that theory comes from

    Reply
  • No! We bailed out the Banks because the Bankers told lies and the gullible Politicians and their lackeys believed them. Now the Bankers are solving the problems they created with Tax payers money and anything they (Banks) say should be taken with a large dose of salts.

    Reply
  • listened to pat farrell this morning talking horse shite.

    Reply
  • Brilliant news! More small/medium businesses going to the wall. It’s common sense & I fail to believe that most of the applications refused were taking the piss.
    Generally a business needs to borrow if it wants to expand or become competitive in the market.
    Bankers (so hard to type that without a W) are pissing themselves laughing. They went to the wall, cried, held us ransom, got the money & now they’re still holding us ransom! How on earth did this happen? We’re the laughing stock of the world.
    NOBODY knows why & how we allowed ourselves to be bent over a barrel except all the fat cat bond holders that held a gun to our heads & said “Pay up or else”
    Stop dreaming about a recovery guys. It’s not happening anytime soon & you’ve got to go out there & grab opportunities by the balls & squeeze ’cause if you don’t, someone else will step on you for that opportunity.
    Ireland sickens me sometimes. Great place to live! Yeah right. We’re mugged every day as far as I’m concerned.

    Reply
  • You say this is bad and they should be lending more but you haven’t seen the applications.

    For all we know they could be applying with the most god awful business plans. They’ve stopped lending to every Tom, Dick and Harry with a stupid idea, which is good because that’s what got us in this mess.

    Reply
  • Only people like the participants in the Croke Park agreement can borrow. The problem is that these loans would be for imported BMWs etc. not employment giving /sustaining machinery or materials. Banks need certainty regarding repayment.

    Reply
  • It is worth re-reading this article imho http://bit.ly/O0HkcF /KathleenBarrington

    Reply
  • I think there is to much regulation in the banking sector. Loans should be given out to all business plans. Then we can experience the boom again…. What short memories we have.

    Reply
    • A very facetious comment. We have a situation where there has been a 360 degree turn in the banks credit policy. From lashing out 100% mortgages to people to had no chance of paying them back, to not giving out mortgages to people who are almost guaranteed to pay them back..An example..i had agreed a price (to build) and detail on a modest bungalow in rural Laois with a couple. She’s a full time employed nurse, he has a steady supervisor job in the civil service. The site they were going to build on was given to them by his father, thus costing them nothing. They had savings of 20,000 that they had put aside over the course of a few years with building their new home in mind. A more steady, rock solid,sensible couple you couldn’t meet. They were pre approved by the bank. When the agreement was made with me to build their house and they informed the bank of a start time and request to have a stage payment ready for a certain time, the bank came bank looking for further information, then more, then more still, 6 months later I’m still waiting to start this job(not earning a cent in between). Then the bank informs the couple that their criteria has changed and they no longer meet said criteria so they won’t make good on their approval for the mortgage. That was 18 months ago. This is one example of 3 that i can specifically tell you about, that have impacted on me, my former employees, and sub contractors and suppliers, not to mention the fact that this poor couple are spending money now on rent what they could be spending on a mortgage. This is the reality in this country. This is what the banks are doing. Nobody is suggesting we de regulate everything and give the banks free reign to do what they will and start carelessly lending again. Just normal, cautious lending would be good, i thought that’s why us taxpayers bailed them out….My memory’s just fine, Liam.

      Reply
    • Damocles 22/08/12 #

      “there has been a 360 degree turn in the banks credit policy.”

      That’d take them back to where they started.

      I think you mean a 180 degree turn.

      Reply
    • yes democles, that’s what i mean.

      Reply

Add New Comment