TheJournal.ie uses cookies. By continuing to browse this site you are agreeing to our use of cookies. Click here to find out more »
Dublin: 9 °C Saturday 18 May, 2013

Banking Federation rejects report on lending to small businesses

IBF chief executive Pat Farrell says he had not seen the report but rejected the findings which are reported this morning.

The Central Bank of Ireland in Dublin
The Central Bank of Ireland in Dublin
Image: Wikimedia Commons via Wikipedia

THE IRISH BANKING Federation has strongly rejected the findings of a report by the Central Bank which says that Irish banks have the second lowest approval level for loans to small businesses in the euro area.

Despite having not seen the report, which is featured in a number of today’s broadsheet newspapers, the chief executive of the IBF, Pat Farrell, said that he rejected its findings.

According to today’s Irish Times, the report says that more than one in four Irish businesses seeking a loan or overdraft were rejected in the six months to March which is more than double the euro area average and second only to Greece.

Farrell told RTÉ’s Morning Ireland that data from the Mazars SME lending demand survey, which was commissioned by the Department of Finance, indicated that banks were lending to small business.

“I would have expected something more than a populist line from the Central Bank because quite frankly the way in which the report has been handled and been released falls fairly far below the standards you’d expect from a professional body like the Central Bank,” he said.

“I would reject the findings of the report because the definitive report on this year is the Mazars report and they make reference, I understand, to the Mazars report.”

He said that the survey from Mazars had a much bigger sample than the Central Bank report, entitled Irish SME Credit Supply and Demand, Comparisons Across Surveys and Countries, which comes from two economists in the bank.

Farrell said that the report, which he has not seen, was spinning the findings of the Mazars report.

He continued: “We now have a situation where the Department of Finance and the government is definitively standing behind the Mazars report.

“Now we have this report out of the blue sky coming from the Central Bank which on the face of it seems to be saying completely different.”

He said the analysis of data from other EU nations would have been different to what appears in the Mazars report and therefore it was “comparing apples with oranges”.

Earlier, Mark Fielding, chief executive of the the Irish Small & Medium Enterprises Association (ISME), said that there was a refusal rate somewhere in the region of 50 per cent of all applications for loans according to his organisation’s own research.

“It’s not new news and it doesn’t make me any happier to find out that the Central Bank is now agreeing with us but it is bad out there at the moment,” he told the programme.

The Central Bank said it would not comment on the IBF’s rejection of the report’s findings.

Read: More than 1 in 10 business properties are lying empty

Read next:

Comments (28 Comments)

  • Why are people surprised? We’ve been set on this path ever since Lenihan opted to try and put a false floor on their losses and keep the zombie banks in their undead state.

    Reply
  • Surprise, surprise, the commercial bankers (who got us into the trouble in the first place), don’t agree with the Central Bankers, that they are not helping small businesses and by extension the economy recover. A bit like doctors disagreeing and patients dying me thinks.

    Reply
  • Hmmm who to believe? The IBF or the CB? What a choice…..

    Must admit had a bit of a laugh this morning when I heard Pat going on about ‘professional standards’.

    Reply
  • How can one reject the findings of a report one hasn’t even read?

    Reply
  • I’m hearing quite often in cases where loans are “approved” ridiculous conditions are attached. Eg after a lengthy process the bank approves loan of €50k to a new business on condition that the business come up with another €60k itself and lodges that into their account prior to granting the loan. The bank knows the business obviously can’t do this and the business will never take the loan. End result is the banks can now claim they are approving loans to beat the band. The stats they make public show how many loans they “approve” not how many are actually granted.

    All banks are happy to loan you money you just need to show them that you don’t need it first.

    Reply
  • Will the government please wake up and DO SOMETHING ABOUT THIS! The Irish banks or should i say our ‘pretend banks’ are strangling good business with their charges and rack rates of 6% – 7 % even if you do get approved. Business and consumers are paying on the double, taxes to bail them out and rack rates to fatten their balance sheet.

    Reply
  • 22/08/12 #

    But I thought we bailed out the banks to allow credit to flow back into businesses ?

    Reply
  • Is anybody really surprised by this? Had FF acted in the best interests of our nation instead of their golden circle friends we could have prevented a lot of the chaos that has ensued, and saved most of the jobs lost as well. The funding and infrastructure was there to set up a national bank which culd have loaned money to SMEs, but instead billions are given to bankers, the worst type of people, with an expectation that they would act like the best type of people. They didnt, and a lot of innocent people have paid the price for thir treasonous greed.

    Reply
  • They should have been let go to the wall. The money that has been put in ‘to save them’ could have been used to fund a new bank run by Irish people for the national interest outside of political appointment – perhaps elected directly.
    It would have been messy for a while but it would have rid us of an element of society which uses that society for ill-gotten gain. With little or no accountability. With recent resource discoveries we’d have been in a pretty good position looking forward instead of the mire we are currently in. We know the cost of what happened (roughly) in terms of money. The true impact of it on the country will only be measured over the coming few decades.
    A social structure which has a ‘too big to fail’ mentality when it comes to people in privileged positions can’t last and has little or no inherent worth beyond the very short term. If you snooze you lose – if you drive your business to the edge and it goes bust, well, that’s the nature of business. The disparity here is small and medium business are going to the wall here in Ireland at an astonishing rate while wholly bankrupted business and people who got in to big and failed are paid for that privilege. And you can bet your life when ‘cheap’ money becomes available again it will be them that benefit the most.

    Reply
  • Banking federation states, “I reject your reality and insert my own.”

    Reply
  • And why we’re we paying for this lot again?

    Reply
  • And why we’re we paying for this lot again?

    Reply
  • The “Irish” banks are owned or have the Irish Government as their major shareholder, yet still after all these years, they have or refuse to exert any influence.

    Is there any politician in this country with a proper set of balls ?

    Reply
  • Ah the beauty of nationalisation!

    Reply
  • And why are we paying for this again???

    Reply
  • I think we all know it, the banks know it even the dogs in the street know that the banks aren’t really lending, still the banks lie and try and pull the wool over our eyes, like so so many during this current climate economic downturn recession they haven’t learned a thing.

    Reply
  • .

    Reply
  • dem lads never give moneys neway lik?? hav asked for 5 loans n da last yaer and avent got one said ye lik, usualy cause i have no work sur but how we ment to have jobs withot money lik?????? spass

    Reply

Add New Comment