TheJournal.ie uses cookies. By continuing to browse this site you are agreeing to our use of cookies. Click here to find out more »
Dublin: 2 °C Saturday 25 May, 2013

Howlin defends progress in public sector reform despite allowances hurdle

Brendan Howlin says the results of the review on public sector allowances will lead to substantial savings over time.

Image: Niall Carson/PA Archive

PUBLIC EXPENDITURE MINISTER Brendan Howlin has defended his progress in reforming public sector pay and allowances, after facing criticism for last week’s review of public allowances which resulted in far less savings than had previously been forecast.

Speaking on RTÉ’s News at One, Howlin said the €75 million target for savings from allowances had been based on hopes that the €1.5 billion budget for such allowances could be trimmed by 5 per cent.

Last week’s review resulted in only one allowance being cut immediately, meaning an annual saving of €3 million – less than one twentieth of the amount Howlin had first indicated.

“I set out a target, as I said, of a 5 per cent reduction in allowances. We’ll get more than that over time, there’s no doubt about it,” Howlin insisted.

“We can’t solve all of the problems in 18 months, [but] we have gone a long way to address them all,” he added.

The minister added that there were many significant but separate issues within the public service that needed reform, such as leave entitlements, sick pay and procurement – a mesh of issues he described as “a complete patchwork quilt that I am now pulling together”.

Much of the criticism Howlin had faced was “based on a lack of understanding for what this job is about,” he said.

“One external commentator said we’ve done more in 18 months in terms of reform than in the last 20 years,” he asserted.

Howlin explained that most of the allowances had been discerned as part of “core pay” and therefore could not be cut – saying any moves to the contrary could mean Gardaí would lose up to 20 per cent of their wage, for example.

Kenny defends small savings from cuts to public allowances

Public Sector Allowances:

Read next:

Comments (26 Comments)

  • Start with Angela Kearns who earns in excess of € 450,000 per year from her jobs with the government. It’s more than double the world leaders wages. Her family members and relatives even outsourced jobs to their own factory in China while at the same time she is placing people from the rehab into our factories. Talk out being competitive as a country. She stopped that activity but still kept her job — Why? She is one of the highest paid in the world for running a rehab. Stop this immediately as we borrow 1 billion to pay this woman – and a few more like her insane.

    Reply
  • He accused all of us who disagree with his assessment of this as ‘simple’.
    Thats what he said.

    Well I have a simple message for him, the next time he or any member of his party come to my door there will be a simple message for them.

    Like the FFers who took the large pot of pension gold and Retired, he and his mates will probably do the same.
    They only have a few more months left to qualify.

    Maybe we are simple.

    Reply
  • Hilarious stuff, if he honestly believes that…… we are &@$@ed

    Reply
  • Perhaps they should begin with their own increments eg ‘turning up allowance’ and show themselves as statesmen as we expect them to be!

    Reply
  • Well listening to Howlin on the radio was worse than getting a tooth pulled without Novocain

    Reply
    • I am amazed that he went on radio. He should hide himself and wait until some other minister draws the flack by not doing what he said he would. He or she, of course. The cute FGers left the shit work to labour to do. Social welfare and reforming the public service are so messy to say the least. Note Gilmore is hiding in foreign affairs, ever wonder what he does all day.

      Reply
  • Sean 24/09/12 #

    SAVING IN TIME? WHOSE TIME? MY GRANDCHILDRENS. How can this so called minister be allowed stay in office is beyond me. To actually come out and make a press statement, that out of a 1000 plus allowances he can only MAKE ONE CUT! We must be the laughing stock of political circles around the world.
    When are we going to get politicians into to power we can at least respect?

    Reply
  • “We can’t solve all the problems in 18 months” … sure, but you could have done a lot better than this pathetic performance Howlin. You set the target, and you failed.

    Reply
  • Spin and yet more spin. It’s a pity we cannot put a tax on that. I know the reduction in PS numbers is held up as a good news story but can anyone put a figure on (a) what the pension cost is and (b) how many who left had to be re-hired on a temporary base and what that cost??

    Reply
    • How is it spin? When was the last PS reform?

      Reply
    • What reform David?

      Reply
    • Do you work for the PS? If no, you really are not in a position to say there has been no reform. If yes, I would like to know what department has not changed since the croke park agreement.

      Reply
    • David you and Howlin are the ones claiming there has been reform. Lets have some details. I’m sure departments have changed people have no doubt retired in the last 18 months and may well not have been replaced but that is natural wastage not reform. Everyone says there has been reform. Facts and figures please showing improved work practices and revenue saved.

      Reply
    • Tommy C 24/09/12 #

      Kerry, lab staff who have always worked 24/7, 365 days a year now have an extended work day also plus on top of that, most on-call payments are down by at least €1k a month. On-call hours arent mandatory so pretty soon, as we cannot hire more staff, our current staff can decide not to do these hours therefore many hospitals wont be able to provide this service anymore. So I reckon an extra 90 minutes per day while down €12k a year ontop of levies and USC etc is indeed, reform.

      Reply
    • kerry
      the re-hireing of staff was not confined to just the civil service did you know that C.I.E in its Dublin Bus form gave quite a few inspectors early retirment in order to save money only to re-hire them weeks later.
      its no bloody wonder we are in this position as a country.
      1 phrase come,s to mind
      ” the loons are running the madhouse”

      Reply
    • Tommy C thanks for the response. As I said I’m asking for facts and figures. Just one question are you saying someone on call was earning 1k a month extra for doing that?

      Reply
  • A snivelling little coward who was just as useless in Government first time round. Himself, Gilmore and Bruton have destroyed the Labour Party in the same way Gormley and co destroyed the Greens.

    Reply
  • Could it be that FG are orchestrating a fiendishly devious approach to slashing the public sector?
    Masquerading as not being too keen on making the cuts themselves, and sticking loyally to Croke Park, FG are apparently being urged by ‘everyone else’ to be more aggressive in slashing benefits and perks. Even the Unions are urging them to cut more than they are.
    Sheer brilliance.

    Reply
  • Howlin seems happy enough to continue borrowing 1 billion a month to finance a bloated public sector. His lack of urgency in not stopping the waste of our money on ludicrous allowances is incredible.
    Theres no hope for Ireland with cretins like him in power

    Reply
    • Could not have not put that better Fintan…This man should be sacked for complete and utter incompetence immediately

      Reply
    • “The most dangerous man to any government is the man who is able to think things out… without regard to the prevailing superstitions and taboos. Almost inevitably he comes to the conclusion that the government he lives under is dishonest, insane, intolerable.”
      H. L. Mencken

      Reply
  • Anyone notice the weight all these ministers have put on since getting into power. Their collective weight has doubled I’d say. Fat Cats Indeed.

    Reply
  • What is Howlin on jees they are not in the real world

    Reply
  • The private sector workers in Ireland have been sold into slavery to keep the public sector going.

    Reply
    • Tommy C 24/09/12 #

      Yeah those public sector bank chiefs and developers have been screwed over by all those nurses, teachers and gardai.
      I suggest you tell a PS worker this is how you feel to our faces. Maybe when youre next in hospital? Let us decide where we spend any disposable income we may have left.

      Reply
  • I know it may be political suicide… But why isn’t there a movement to reform: government, civil servant administrative structure and legal structure. I understand that it would be difficult, however a plan with reviews would keep the progress in order.

    For example:

    Government: Begin with seperating National and Local Politics and responsibilities. No Local Councilor should have any bearing on national politics except as an average citizen. A national politician should have no influence on weather his neighbourhood’s street is paved except as being a member of the community.

    Civil Servants vs Public Sector vs Private Sector: Each one of these categories are not the same and sould net be considered as such. Therefore, they should not be compared.

    Civil Servant’s based on pay grades. Each job would have several grades. Each grade should have particular responsiblities and requirements that need to be satisfied before a person is hired in at a grade and eventually promoted into another. Job performance, experience, and on-going job related education should determine movement of grades. Further, if a person has reached the cieling of their grade, then they can apply and interview for a different role provided that they have the skills to completeb the task. Their pay shouldn’t change provided that the movement is lateral and the job requires the same level of challenges.

    Public Sector: These jobs should only be supported by the governemnt through financial grants. Otherwise, this sector would run like a private sector.

    The Legal System: Using the same concept as stated above for Civil Servants…. Add a more pro-active garda force, that would require garda to use enforce the laws that already exist on the books. For example, tickets to J-Walkers, tickets to drinking in public, tickets to those who are driving cars that are not safe: headlights & taillights out, noise pollution, speeding, driving while using the mobile, arrest and fine parents for their children’s anti-social behavior. If the parent, can’t control the child then place the child in a detention centre.

    Yes difficult… But required.

    Reply

Add New Comment