TheJournal.ie uses cookies. By continuing to browse this site you are agreeing to our use of cookies. Click here to find out more »
Dublin: 11 °C Tuesday 21 May, 2013

Guantanamo 10 years on: hopes for closure fade, detainees remain in limbo

The notorious detention centre has now been open for ten years and, with indefinite military detention now enshrined in US law, hope is fading that it will be closed down as pledged.

A flag waves behind the barbed and razor-wire at the detention compound on Guantanamo Bay US Naval Base in Cuba
A flag waves behind the barbed and razor-wire at the detention compound on Guantanamo Bay US Naval Base in Cuba
Image: Brennan Linsley/AP/Press Association Images

DESPITE A PLEDGE by US President Barack Obama to close Guantanamo Bay by 1 January 2010, today about 171 men remain at the notorious detention centre – which has been the subject of intense international criticism for almost ten years.

Amnesty International has described the legacy of the Guantanamo Bay as a “decade of damage to human rights” not only in the United States, but across the world.

“Guantanamo has politicised justice internationally by portraying detainees as having no human rights,” the organisation stated on the ten-year anniversary of the opening of the prison.

In ten years of Guantanamo’s existence, only one of the 779 detainees held at the base has been transferred to the USA for prosecution in an ordinary federal court. Amnesty International says that others have faced “unfair trials by military commission”, and that the Obama administration is currently intending to seek the death penalty against six of the detainees at such trials.

The administration blamed Congress for its failure to close the facility, saying that it has made closing the detention centre more difficult. However, the recent signing of the National Defence Authorisation Act (NDAA) by President Obama, amid claims he has enshrined indefinite military detention into US law, has raised doubts about plans to shut the prison down.



Uploaded by 

Although recognising that there are individuals being held at the prison that have played roles in terrorist attacks, Amnesty International points out that there is “an entire law enforcement system in the United States that has essentially been ready and waiting since September 2001to bring those individuals to justice”.

Executive Director of Amnesty International Ireland, Colm O’Gorman, said: “The US cannot hide behind domestic political differences to excuse the unlawful detention of dozens of prisoners, including some who have been the victims of torture. The Obama administration – indeed large parts of all three branches of the federal government – have simply adopted President Bush’s approach.”

Ireland ‘not an innocent bystander’

Amnesty International also highlighted Ireland’s role in the renditions programme. “Ireland is not an innocent bystander. We have been complicit in kidnapping and torture by allowing Shannon airport to be used as a stop-over for rendition flights,” said O’Gorman.

“Our Government must investigate why, when it was clear what was happening at Shannon, it was allowed to continue. They must also close the loopholes in the civil aviation laws so that we cannot be hoodwinked by the US again.”

Read: September 11 suspects likely to be tried at Guantanamo>

Read: Obama approves resumption of Guantanamo military trials>

Read: US ‘rendition flight’ aircraft flew to Shannon airport>

Read: Guantanamo detainee acquitted of most charges>

Read next:

Comments (6 Comments)

  • What do people expect from the Goldman Sachs employee.. Obomber… They can’t close it as they will need it to disappear citizens under the NDAA which allows the president to intern anyone he wants for any reason.. Clocks a ticking America.. Please wake up..

    Reply
    • On the plus side its good to see the Author acknowledge the NDAA which some people are still denying allows the new fuhrer the power of Caesar… But most people still thinks he’s the cool Guy who drinks Guinness in ballygobackwards… Some people are so gullible..they actually believe the president with the fake birthcert is part Irish…

      Reply
  • Simon 11/01/12 #

    It is shameful that the Irish government seeks a seat on the UN Human Rights Council, while still allowing these planes to pass through Shannon airport.
    I presume when the inevitable begins with Iran, Shannon airport will have even more ‘rendition flights’ allowed to pass through it.

    Reply
  • Muc Beag 11/01/12 #

    It always makes me sick to the stomach that this kind of stuff is going on under the direction of the US, I can’t even bear to think about the fact we were complicit in it. So ashamed at ourselves.

    Reply
  • Oaklane1 11/01/12 #

    @journal, why did you have to include the very biased video. Makes your reporting look a little lopsided.

    Reply
    • Hi Oaklane1,

      Thanks for your comment. The video featured was made by Amnesty International and explores the human rights issues surrounding the treatment of detainees at Guantanamo Bay. As always, please feel free to discuss any other issues on the topic in the comments section.

      Cheers,
      Jennifer

      Reply

Add New Comment