Welcome to our Public Beta Site - What does this mean?
Dublin: 18 °C Wednesday 23 May, 2012

Half of German doctors prescribe placebos – and they work

Image: erix! via Flickr

A NEW STUDY in Germany has shown that over half of the country’s doctors prescribe placebos to their patients – and say such actions successfully treat problems like depression or stomach complaints.

The study, compiled for the German Medical Association and reported in the Guardian, said placebos – which could range from vitamin pills to homeopathic remedies, and even (in extreme cases) sham surgeries – were “highly effective” in most cases.

In the southern province of Bavaria, eight out of every nine GPs gave patients prescriptions for placebos.

The Guardian also quotes the study’s author, Robert Jutte, who said placebos – though unexplained – led to the reduction of “undesirable side-effects, and are a more efficient use of our healthcare budget.”

Such placebos had had the same effect as antidepressants in about a third of cases, and had help 59 per cent of patients who had complained about stomach problems.

The report further found that a placebo’s effectiveness depends on many factors including the size, colour and price of a pill.

Read more by Abby d’Arcy Hughes in the Guardian >

Read Next:

Comments (3 Comments)

  • Sean Armstrong 07/03/11 #
    Report this comment

    These guys are playing with fire when they administer placebos. You’re basically taking a gamble that the story the patient tells you isn’t serious, and that they’ll come back in time to solve any serious problems that arise. If the placebo works for that patient, great, but it’s a shockingly high and negligent number of doctors who abuse a patients trust by lying to them and giving them nothing – do they charge the patients full price?

    Reply
    • Nigel Kenny 08/03/11 #
      Report this comment

      There’s a gamble when people take actual medicines from pharmaceuticals aswell. The possible side effects on all drugs are more damaging to a patient than not taking a placebo. Besides, it appears to be working and it is excellent research that could make a positive impact on how people are being treated for minor conditions. I’m sure they don’t hand them out willy-nilly and it doesn’t boil down to whether they “believe the story” or not.

      From my own experience, i had awful stomach problems in my late teens that my GP couldn’t pin down so over a course of 3 months he prescribed a brutal regime of pills for me to take every day with the advice that “if they didn’t work then we’d rule out all the possible causes that those pills would successfully treat.” I would have taken a placebo first rather than go through the hellish side effects i had for 3 months as a result of pills that in the end gave no relief.

  • Martin Sinnott 07/03/11 #
    Report this comment

    This could save the health service a fortune

    Reply

Add New Comment