TheJournal.ie uses cookies. By continuing to browse this site you are agreeing to our use of cookies. Click here to find out more »
Dublin: 13 °C Sunday 19 May, 2013

Instructors slam new rules for mandatory driving lessons

New rules will require drivers to have at least 12 hours of lessons before applying for a learner permit – costing around €400.

Image: chuckoutrearseats via Flickr

DRIVING INSTRUCTORS HAVE attacked new rules that require learner drivers to sit at least 12 driving lessons before they are allowed to sit their full driving test – saying the rules offer no flexibility for faster or slower learners.

The new Essential Driver Training (EDT) regime, being introduced by the Road Safety Authority from April 4, and will require all drivers on a learner permit (formerly a provisional licence) to sit the mandatory number of lessons before they can sit a test.

Learners will also have to wait two weeks between each lesson for practice, and are told to sit at complete at least 36 hours of ‘homework’ with a licenced driver.

With driving lessons costing between €30 and €35 per hour in different parts of the country, the regime will mean that new learners will have to pay out as much as €420 in driving lessons simply to be allowed to sit a driving test.

This price would come on top of the cost of sitting the Driver Theory Test – currently €40.60 – and other associated costs such as having an eyesight exam.

Driving instructors have lashed out at the new rules, however, claiming that they do not allow for flexibility for drivers who are quicker or slower at picking up their driving skills.

“Training has always been tailored to individual drivers with people progressing at different rates,” Cathy Bacon, chairwoman of the Irish Driving Instructors Association, told the Irish Times. “The new mandatory lessons provide no flexibility for this.”

Others have complained that the new system – which will require instructors to sign a log book of lessons – may give learner drivers a false sense of competency, and said they would feel uneasy about signing the log book if they didn’t feel a driver was competent enough.

Padraig McHale of the Leinster Driving Campus in Kildare told the Irish Independent that the 12 lessons outlined were often not enough “to get someone up to driving test standard. You would need to double or treble that.”

Having to take three times the prescribed 12 lessons would mean drivers could spend over €1200 on tuition alone, as well as the other costs associated with learning to drive.

Another concern raised by instructors is the fact that the licenced driver with whom the ‘homework’ is completed cannot be audited – meaning they may pass on their bad habits to the new driver.

RTÉ News said the GMB union had criticised the RSA for not consulting driving instructors about the new scheme, and also complained that there was no requirement for the lessons to be passed – but merely completed instead.

This is in contrast to a new system of motorcycle tuition introduced at the end of last year, which requires new motorcyclists to reach a certain level of proficiency at the end of their lessons.

Read next:

Comments (11 Comments)

  • Yes clearly this is nonsense! The idea that people would actually learn to drive properly before being allows sit a test, and be in control of a car in a public place is crazy !

    Lets go back to the old system where people drove round for years on provisional licences and foreigners who moved here had no checks done on their driving comperency at all !

    I sense the true motivation is driving instructors seeing a revenue opportunity slipping away.

    Reply
  • Absolutely correct move. Too many people with no clue on the road putting everybody else in danger

    Reply
    • And most of them have full licences. This is another money making exercise, at the expense of younger drivers. Just because you have a full licence, doesn’t give you the right to drive on a road, in a manner that you think fit. Most of the young drivers that bought cars, taxed and insured them, are up to their neck repaying car loans.

      Reply
    • Perhaps that’s the reason we have a shortage of Bus Drivers due to this tortuous regulation and enormous cost. Consequently, the government has to contend with higher unemployment and less road tax. The RSA should be completely abolished and the government downsized. The Department of Transport should take over the simplified test applications like before. The problem was the lack of ENFORCEMENT by the Traffic Cops – NOT the licensing system.

      The RSA was created out of a political knee-jerk reaction before the 2007 election. It was one of the biggest mistakes ever made by the Fianna Fail government. As a result, we took on 100′s of extra government workers. Now we have another Huge government department that requires extra taxes and bureaucracy to justify its existence.

      Reply
  • Daft! Made damn sure i got my permit before this came in. If they want to create better drivers in this country then they need to look to Finland on how to do it right. This new rule will take learning to drive out of the reach of so many people. Not being able to drive without a licensed driver was bad enough.

    Reply
    • “This new rule will take learning to drive out of the reach of so many people.”

      I’m sorry but I don’t see your point. Surely if people have already purchased a car (and taxed and insured it) then they will also be able to afford the €420 to get these driving lessons. Secondly even if they have just been insured on their parents car then this will have still been a significant cost given the high premiums for first time drivers.

      Being allowed on the road isn’t a right.

      Reply
    • I would think that if they have bought a car, taxed and insured it, they would have even less money to spend on driving lessons, not more?! Also, people are deterred from buying a car until they have their full license with the changes in the law now so i would imagine owning a car with a provisional license wont be too prevalent.

      Taking myself as an example, i don’t have access to a car so getting to a stage where i can have a full license is hard enough. I also am not very flush with cash either so having to pay for driving lessons when i can be taught by a competent driver for free seems ridiculous. If people have to pass a driving test in order to get the license then they are deemed fit to drive on the road unattended. Why should they have to pay 420 euros for driving lessons aswell?

      I’m not opposed to spending money where it’s needed if it’s needed. But i can be taught to pass a driving test for free so why should i pay for that? I would gladly pay for classes on cornering, handling cars in dangerous situations etcetc. This seems like it would be worthwhile and ACTUALLY create better drivers as opposed to punishing people through their pockets. Maybe they should change the driving test or start teaching kids to drive at an early age like they do in Finland?

      There are more ways to create safer, competent drivers without going down the route of more money all the time.This is just another example of people in charge not thinking this problem out carefully enough and sounds like the result of a pretty bad brainstorming session. Lazy legislating!

      Reply
  • In fairness, who’s going to need 36 lessons to learn how to drive?! This is a money making scam, just the same as the myriad of other money making scams we operate in this country. Whoever thought this up should actually be ashamed of themselves, this is about revenue, not safety…

    Reply
  • I think this is a great move, but should be more reasonable at six mandatory lesson with instructor recommendation.
    But it shouldn’t stop here, rural schools need look at road safety, possibly introducing drivers ed programs.

    I almost forgot, a motorway/dual-carrigeway driving lesson to validate when they pass their test. One that explains the dangers of sticking to the middle lane of a three lane road!

    Reply
  • Steve Q 29/03/11 #

    The lessons should be free, sure, people teaching you to drive for free.

    Maybe we should stay the way it is and let anyone get into a car after passing a test without any formal training at all.

    And then the instructors argue that 12 lessons isn’t enough, as if people are even taking that many lessons in the first place.

    And if you even needed 12 lessons to learn how to drive, you shouldn’t be driving a car. It’s not the Krypton Factor.

    Reply

Add New Comment