TheJournal.ie uses cookies. By continuing to browse this site you are agreeing to our use of cookies. Click here to find out more »
: °C Sunday 26 May, 2013

Cork Medical Centre ‘effectively closed’ from today

The €90m medical centre has been closed down despite attempts by its operators Sheehan Medical to save it.

UPDATE 4.30PM

CORK MEDICAL CENTRE (CMC) has been closed today with staff contracts suspended for the next four weeks pending talks to save the hospital.

TheJournal.ie has learned that while there is a meeting of TDs in the Dáil this evening regarding the situation VHI will not be coming to meet with the group and that staff have been informed of the situation today.

The centre is now ‘effectively closed’ from today according to a source.

Earlier the VHI rejected a ‘price-match’ offer from the developers of Cork Medical Centre (CMC) fighting to save its closure.

The country’s newest was facing closure and the prospect of laying off 75 staff after its operator, Sheehan Medical, failed to strike a deal with VHI over services to offer to members.

VHI maintain it is not giving cover to new private hospitals in Ireland including CMC, the newest.

Sheehan Medical had offered to match terms and conditions agreed by the VHI with St Vincent’s private hospital in Dublin recently but the VHI said that this was “not relevant,” reports the Irish Examiner.

Read more of Eoin English’s story in today’s print edition of the Irish Examiner >

Read next:

Comments (12 Comments)

  • VHI need to get their act together asap. They have a swiftcare clinic next-door the the hospital so I can’t understand this refusal.

    Reply
    • I haven’t looked at the detail of this so I’m not clear how this is VHI’s fault and why they would need to get their act together. As I understand it they have indicated their is excess capacity and so they don’t need to strike a deal with the CMC. As CMC seem to be financially dependent on striking a deal with VHI that would imply some type of cost or liability to VHI. If there’s excess capacity then it would surely not make sense for the VHI (or its customers) to spend without justification?

      Reply
  • @James Vhi keep issuing these bland statements but never supply figures. They talk about over supply nationally but have never once said that there is an over supply of private health facilities in Munster or Cork because this is simply not the case. Cork has less private beds and less operating theatres than Leinster or Ireland as whole.

    Vhi seems content to treat its customer in the two private hospitals covered by them in Cork, which are over 90 years old. Contrast this with Blackrock Clinic which only opened in the 1980’s but they’ve already built an entirely new hospital on site.

    CMC estimates it can save Vhi €5m per annum on the seven main procedures, not to mention the benefit of added competition driving down prices quoted to Vhi by the existing hospitals.

    Cork is Ireland’s second city and deserves to have modern facilities for its population – they should not have to travel to Dublin, Galway or Waterford in order to be treated in modern facilities, or so their surgeons can get access to operating theatres.

    More importantly if Vhi were on -board this would confirm all the doctors needed to allow the hospital to treat public patients and reduce public sector waiting lists via the National Purchase Treatment Fund.

    Reply
    • Yes, cork would have less beds and operating theatres than Leinster, or Ireland. That seems a basic point of logic, does it not?

      Bottom line, if VHI don’t want to, VHI don’t have to. If the current private hospitals in Cork feel they are modern enough to continue, so be it. They clearly pass the HSE’s standards…

      Another point worth making is that if the VHI agreed this deal there would be people posting here about how disgraceful it was to waste money on another private hospital. Damned if they do…

      Reply
  • I commented but it was taken down. Are you only putting up those comments you deem appropriate?????

    Reply
  • @John, Sheehan Medical had started meetings with Vhi in 2007, before they commenced building and their CEO indicated Vhi needed a modern hospital in Cork for its customers and one that could compete with the two existing facilities in order to drive down prices. Vhi were negotiating on covering the facility until very recently and SM have released the minutes. The CEO even came down to view the facility less than a month ago.

    Vhi recently covered the new St Vincent’s Private that opened in November with 263 beds, yet they won’t cover CMC with only 73 beds in the city where their existing facilities are over 90 years old and crucially do not offer a fully room facility, which is now best practice in order to control infections.

    The development of CMC followed exactly the same pattern as every other private hospital in the country.There was certainly no railroading nor would the Sheehan’s ever participate in such practice.

    Reply
  • No there wouldn’t Sean. Don’t be ridiculous. My office is in the building next to this hospital. Sheehan medical behind it already run 4 very successful hospitals in the us. There are two vhi facilities in the same complex as this, which opened AFTER the plans for cmc. This is an amazing facility that two private insurance companies are willing to do business with yet somehow a state insurer whose last profit was in the stone age, somehow knows better than everyone else and now wants to jeopardise 100 jobs cause of some vested interest. Cork needs this facility, everyone in cork knows this, so we don’t need any state insurer or mis informed people telling us otherwise.

    Reply
  • Did you ever hear me complaining about that before? No! You have me mistaken for the 2nd time for some lefty.

    Reply
    • Sheesh and to think I got the guy who works in the same building as this. Some luck. And asking you about labour was an innocent question (to be honest I did have a knife behind my back if you had answered yes)

      Reply
  • Ha, some luck alright, start fresh tomorrow sher ;)

    Reply
    • Its important to bear in mind the history leading up to this fiasco. Sheehan Medical were informed before they even commenced building the hospital that they would not be covered by the VHI. They ploughed ahead regardless, thinking they could railroad their way through the system, forcing the VHI to provide cover as they felt the VHI would not have the backbone to stick to their initial decision due to the negative press they would receive. It’s like an insurance company telling you they won’t insure you if you buy a Lambourgini but you go ahead and buy it anyway and then act surprised when they don’t insure you!

      Reply

Add New Comment