TheJournal.ie uses cookies. By continuing to browse this site you are agreeing to our use of cookies. Click here to find out more »
Dublin: 8 °C Friday 24 May, 2013

White-tailed eagles killed in Mayo and Donegal

Minister Jimmy Deenihan has condemned the killings of the eagles, who are believed to have been poisoned. One bird was also shot.

The eagle found at Lough Beltra
The eagle found at Lough Beltra

THE DEATHS OF two White-tailed eagles in Mayo and Donegal have been condemned by Minister Jimmy Deenihan.

One eagle was found dead in Mayo. It had been released in Killarney National Park in 2010 and was equipped with a satellite tag.

When the tag showed that the bird was not moving around, National Parks and Wildlife Service staff and the Golden Eagle Trust carried out a search, only find the dead bird on the shores of Lough Beltra in County Mayo.

Post mortem results showed that the eagle had high concentrations of poison in its body – and also that it had been shot as there were shotgun pellets in its body. It is not known however if the shooting and poisoning are related.

Another eagle was found dead recently in the Blue Stack mountains in Donegal. A post mortem showed it had also been poisoned.

Minister Deenihan condemned the killings, saying:

The satellite tracking shows that these birds had been wandering over hundreds of coastal, hill and lowland farms in recent months unmolested and without concern.  I understand that landowners in Mayo were actively sending in regular sightings to the project manager/team.
I am, therefore, very disappointed that some unknown individuals would wantonly try to kill these magnificent birds.

The National Parks and Wildlife Service are investigating the killings and Minister Deenihan urged anyone with information to contact their local Garda Siochána or the National Parks and Wildlife Service on 095 41054.

Dr Allan Mee of the Golden Eagle Trust, who is project manager of the White-tailed Eagle project, said that the recent incident was “saddening”.

After releasing this male eagle in Killarney National Park in 2010 we have been following its movement with great interest. Last year it spent over five months in north Mayo where it had been undoubtedly fishing on some of the rivers and lakes there before returning to Kerry for the winter.

Dr Mee added that the eagle returned to the same areas in Mayo in late March and would probably have spent the summer there again.

It’s tragic to think someone for some unknown reason would kill it. We would like to acknowledge the cooperation and goodwill shown to the reintroduction project by local communities throughout Ireland especially farming and fishing communities. It is ironic to think that at the same time as the reintroduction project is now bearing the fruit of this cooperation with birds nesting and generating huge interest in Co Clare, one of our birds has been needlessly attacked.

The Minister also said he finds these incidents “all the more disappointing” given that it was only last month that a pair of White-tailed eagles were confirmed nesting near Mountshannon in County Clare.

I am well aware that the presence of the White-tailed eagles in Kerry has proved a wonderful asset to tourism in my home county, and their establishment in other counties has great potential for tourism.
Not only are they a tourist asset, but they can be beneficial in other ways. In other countries they have been shown to control the numbers of other fish-eating birds in freshwaters, such as cormorants.

Read: White-tailed Eagles make Clare their new nest after 100-year wait>

Read next:

Comments (56 Comments)

  • Why the hell would some fool wanna kill them ?

    Reply
  • they were big enough targets for whatever ignorant fools decided to kill them, i dont know which is worse 1. that the birds were killed or 2. if the morons responsible are caught, they will get a small fine, probably less than it cost them to kill the eagles

    Reply
  • Disgusting carry on.

    Reply
  • Hope they catch the bastards and poison them!

    Reply
  • How very sad that in this day and age there are people out there who have no morals and even less common sense. I hope that whoever did this, will be found and punished to the full extent of the law. Harsher penalties need to be made in order to stop this from happening again and again.

    Reply
  • Will this persecution only end when these magnificent birds are driven from our shores for a second time?
    If this happens it would be a tragedy not just for the birds but for the country as a whole, and would be a sad indictment of us as a community.

    Reply
  • Absolutely sickening behaviour! The person or persons who did this deserve a lengthy prison sentence!!! The Norwegians won’t give us any more and deservedly so!!! These birds are great in every aspect, tourism education to name but a few. But sadly a minority of bastards are determined to see them extinct again!!!

    Reply
  • I remember seeing about 6 or 7 blackbirds on my street, dying on the ground from poison. Crows and cats were trying to get at them, I was scaring them away. Only 3 were still breathing, so I took them down to the local vet – but he couldn’t do anything for them, and put them down peacefully for free. It was all quite sad. It’s farmers who are doing this.. I get very sentimental when it comes to suffering of animals. Seeing those poor little birds laying on the ground helpless was terrible.

    Anyone shooting or poisoning anything as great as an Eagle should be locked up. It’s bang out of order.

    Reply
  • The vast majority of farmers in Ireland are law abiding citizens but there is a minority who – and I dare say we have all met the type – think they can act against the wishes of the majority without recourse. It is sad because it sullies the good name of the law abiding farmer and collectively gives them a bad name when that isn’t the truth of the matter.

    I’d call on the Parks and Wildlife service to carry out forensics on the bullets used. If the firearm is legally held they may be able to trace it’s owner and take action.

    But this alone won’t solve the bigger problem. The Parks and Wildlife service need to set up a scheme to compensate farmers for any lambs killed by eagles. That way farmers might think twice about laying poison and do the right thing. The GPS tags on the eagle mean it could be verified if the it was on their land so as to ensure the scheme wouldn’t be abused.

    The spate of murders of these fine birds is embarrassing to Ireland as a nation and if it continues the Norwegians will stop donating them.

    Reply
    • mattoid 17/05/12 #

      There is already a compensation scheme in place for farmers, but the uptake to date has been very low as White-tailed Eagles are predominantly scavengers, not predators. Sadly this is also what puts them at high risk from poisoned meat.

      Unfortunately the ‘bullets’ are shotgun pellets so it wouldn’t be possible to link them to an individual firearm. I’m not sure whether or not they would have a chemical signature which could link the pellets to a particular batch of ammunition if the Gardai had a suspect in mind though – any forensic scientists out there know the answer?

      Reply
    • The poison was most likely intended for foxes not the eagles, it is lambing season. The farmer may have come across the poinsoned bird and put it down. Neverthless we just can’t have farmers arbitrarily killing wildlife like this, if foxes are taking lambs there must be another way of dealing with the problem that poison.

      Reply
    • The redneck comments are not waranted, all you vegans out there who don’t eat meat nor dairy products.

      Reply
    • All poison meat baits have been banned since 2010 – foxes can be controlled by shooting and trapping which is much more effective and humane

      Reply
    • Obviously not that effictive Stephen or they wouldn’t continue to use poison.

      Reply
    • I’ve never read anywhere about lambs being killed by eagles in Ireland.

      Reply
    • The small minority of lazy , lawbreakers still engaging in this activity have no idea what they are killing – and don’t care eitheir. If they can’t be arsed doing it right and acting inside the law then someone from the local gun club can do it for them. We can’t let a small minority of tossers drive protected wildlife to extinction and harm Irelands green image on which so much of our Tourism and food industry depends.

      Reply
  • Do certain people just hate wildlife I hope they catch whoever did this

    Reply
  • It makes my blood boil this shit,redneck tossers without a brain cell in there heads

    Reply
  • Welcome to rural Ireland where rules do not matter if they interfere with your wishes.

    Last year, for example, my neighbour (rightly) could not get his hedge cut because it was the breeding time for birds: meanwhile across the road the landowners (builders, not farmers) cut and slashed hedges, trees etc. And the reaction of The National Parks and Wildlife Service? “I’ll have a word with them”!
    The NPWS – and local authorities – do not want to take action against offenders.

    Reply
  • There’s no way to justify killing such magnificent birds

    Reply
  • Another example of people with small brains and big guns thinking they can do what they want. If an IQ test was mandatory for gun owners I think gun licences would be halved. Granted there may be some intelligent people owning guns but there as rare as white-tailed eagles.

    Reply
    • i think an emotional intelligence test would be more appropriate, people with high iq’s are every bit as likely to have extreme views as anyone else, and just as likely to take pleasure from needles slaughter

      Reply
  • it really is deplorable. morons killing a majestic creature like that. so disappointed. I love birds.

    Reply
  • Very sad ! A disgrace really . There is no argument ‘ for ‘ killing these birds .! People who approve of this are ignorant morons .!

    Reply
  • I’m guessing Tom from Father Ted is the kinda redneck that would shoot an eagle. I hope they get caught and pay dearly.

    Reply
  • There is a chance the eagle ate another poisoned animal – for example a poisoned dying rat would be easier for the eagle to catch. However, that doesn’t explain the gunshot wounds of course. A very sad story.

    Reply
  • For gods sake these are majestic animals it takes one hell of an ignorant person to do this. Clearly the act of a farmer.

    Reply
    • Clearly the act of a farmer?????! Chip on your shoulder against farmers have you? No evidence to suggest a farmer was responsible for this terrible act. Hopefully whoever is responsible is punished, & those with ignorant attitudes learn to not judge so quickly.

      Reply
    • Why? Do you have evidence? Plenty of ignorant Dubs etc with shotguns. Farmers aren’t the people who are generally involved in Badger Baiting & dog fighting. Why blame farmers for this cruelty?

      Reply
  • This is clearly the work of some thick inbred

    Reply
  • Riiiight so someone woke up and said to themselves, I’m off to kill me some eagles today. Beggars belief really.

    Reply
  • blah! 17/05/12 #

    Can some of the people who are disliking the comments expressing disgust at the killing of these birds on this news story please explain why so? Do you think it is a good thing that the eagles were poisoned? Please explain.

    Reply
    • blah! 17/05/12 #

      Now I’m really confused, any chance the person who disliked the fact that I asked a question could explain why they dislike questions being asked?

      Reply
    • I guess it proves one of two things:
      1) There are trolls who will red thumb any comment just for the hell of it, without even reading the comment,
      or
      2) The kind of people who red thumbed your comment (and many others on here) are too stupid to be able to articulate their own views

      Reply
    • or 3. use an iPhone or other smart phone and accidently press the red thumb. its a common problem here on the journal and it is being looked at

      Reply
  • Any unnecessary killing of any animal is sick. This makes me sad.

    Reply
  • Now don’t shoot me for this, or poison me. I’m explaining, not excusing.

    There is a different mentality in rural Ireland, especially on the western seaboard, than in Wales and Norway and other parts of Europe.
    There is little concept of the ‘countryside’ as an entity in it’s own right.

    Farmers don’t generally allow anything on their land which does not financially profit themselves personally. Field monuments like ráths, eagles, walkers may all profit the tourist industry but the traditional western smallholder doesn’t care for that, just himself.

    Only a tiny minority you say?

    Hmm. well I didn’t hear Lorcán from the Eagle Trust get any sympathy on Raidíó na Gaeltachta this morning.

    And have any local politicians condemned it?

    The only real deterrent is detection and gaol/ large fines for those who injure the many for personal benefit. But we don’t do that in Ireland.

    Reply
  • How are these birds a threat to farmers??

    Reply
  • Moggs999 17/05/12 #

    These b……s must be the same type that mutilate animals, cutting ears off donkeys etc. They all must be missing a gene through interbreeding,one that allows you to have a basic sense of morals and consciousness !

    Reply
  • It is disgraceful to think that these beautiful creatures were murdered. Just bloody disgraceful.

    Reply
  • They have stopped!!! Fact! By the way they don’t eat lambs as suspected by backward hillbilly hick farmers.

    Reply
    • blah! 17/05/12 #

      Ah so it might be down to farmers who think that there is an off chance the eagles might kill some lambs? I might get run over by a bus. Think I’ll go out and kill me some bus drivers. Just to be on the safe side.

      Reply
  • It is sad that these birds have been killed. unless your a vegetarian yourself, you can’t sit all high & mighty, saying killing is wrong. A calf, lamb, chicken, piglet etc & their adult counterparts are just as entitled to life as an eagle. If beauty or rarity meant a superior entitlement to life, then imagine that rule applied to our Ambulances & Hospitals.

    Reply
  • On problem for raptors is the poisoning of rats and other rodents by people. The rats are often picked up an eaten by raptors who then die from the poison the rat consumed.

    Reply
  • Hello

    Reply

Add New Comment