#Open journalism No news is bad news

Your contributions will help us continue to deliver the stories that are important to you

Support The Journal
Dublin: 10°C Tuesday 28 September 2021

Alcohol companies may have learned some lessons from the fight against Big Tobacco

A health committee was looking at the government’s proposed new alcohol laws today.

Image: Flickr

ALCOHOL COMPANIES’ SUPPORT for responsible drinking campaigns is little more than a “clever exercise in corporate branding”, one advertising expert has claimed.

Dublin Institute of Technology’s Dr Patrick Kenny said recent moves by the industry to join the public-health fight were “possible to interpret … as a genuine attempt to tackle Ireland’s problematic drinking culture”.

But he said it was also possible alcohol companies had learned the lesson of Big Tobacco’s “defensive and reactive stance” when that industry was put under scrutiny, a period which ended in tight regulation.

(The alcohol industry) has adopted a more proactive stance, especially whenever new statutory regulations are on the horizon.”

Kenny was speaking at an Oireachtas Health Committee meeting examining the government’s proposed new alcohol regulations.

Kenny Dr Patrick Kenny at the committee today Source: Oireachtas.ie

New rules, new anti-drinking campaign

The draft rules, first unveiled in early February, include a minimum unit pricing for alcohol, warning labels on products and a watershed rule for alcohol advertising in broadcast media.

However the restrictions stopped short of answering calls to ban alcohol companies from sponsoring sporting events after sporting bodies warned their futures would be under threat with the loss of funding.

A Diageo-backed “Stop Out-Of-Control Drinking” group has since been assembled with the stated aim of making problem drinking unacceptable.

However two of its board members have already stood down, although the group has said the brewer, which owns Guinness among other brands, only provided the funding for the campaign and had no control over its decisions.

Kenny said previous proposals to control alcohol marketing were shelved after the alcohol industry agreed a new code of practice and now a “new, high-profile campaign” had been launched while the latest restrictions were being considered.

Perhaps the timing of all of these initiatives is coincidental. But an alternative explanation is also possible, namely that they are timed and designed to placate policy makers and to brand the alcohol industry as responsible stakeholders who should not be too tightly regulated.”

#Open journalism No news is bad news Support The Journal

Your contributions will help us continue to deliver the stories that are important to you

Support us now

Source: Irish Role Models/YouTube

‘Fundamental flaw’

Fianna Fáil health spokesman Billy Kelleher said it was a “fundamental flaw” of the new rules that no-one had “bit the bullet” on alcohol advertising in sport as it was aimed at a primarily young audience.

There is no doubt that the target audience isn’t a 75-year-old man drinking two pints of Murphys in a pub in Cork … it’s the younger audience that has been the target the whole time for alcohol companies,” he said.

Kelleher said he was also “very concerned” that alcohol producers backing anti-drinking campaigns would send the wrong signals the companies were “doing it for society’s good” – rather than trying to ward off tighter regulations.

READ: Is Guinness good for you? Look at the label >

READ: Powdered alcohol is legal in the US… again >

About the author:

Peter Bodkin  / Editor, Fora

Read next: