#Open journalism No news is bad news

Your contributions will help us continue to deliver the stories that are important to you

Support The Journal
Dublin: 14°C Saturday 19 June 2021

Irish playwright embroiled in controversy over play about death of black teen

Actors have walked off Phelim McAleer’s “Ferguson”, a staged reading of testimony surrounding the police shooting of Michael Brown.

police-shooting-missouri-91-630x416 Source: PA

CO TYRONE FILMMAKER and writer Phelim McAleer is battling a revolt by cast-members, just days before the Los Angeles debut of “Ferguson”, a controversial staged reading of events surrounding the death of Michael Brown.

Brown, an unarmed 18-year-old black man, was shot dead by Officer Darren Wilson in August, in Ferguson, a suburb of St Louis, Missouri.

His death sparked intense protests across America, especially after a grand jury failed to indict Wilson.

That’s where McAleer’s project focuses. It is billed as “using only Grand Jury testimony”, and will invite audience members to vote as if they were on the jury.

The “verbatim theatre” project is scheduled to start in Los Angeles tomorrow, and run until Wednesday, but has already prompted a walk-out by eight of the 13 cast members, and caught the attention of the US media.

‘Wrong and imbalanced’

grandjury Source: NYT/St Louis prosecutor's office

Golden Globe-nominated veteran actor Phil Casnoff, who was due to play prosecuting lawyer Bob McCullough, left the production after reading the script.

“It felt like something was very wrong and imbalanced about the piece at the end of the reading,” he said.

“Several others are expressing misgivings…but I won’t be changing the script,” McAleer told TheJournal.ie by phone from Marina del Rey.

Regardless of how many people have left, the play will go ahead.

McAleer says he has replacement actors in mind who have already agreed to fill any gaps left in the cast.

Five actors left the production after reading the script earlier this week, but following a meeting between McAleer and the cast on Thursday night, three more walked away.

Dylan John Seaton, who was due to portray Officer Darren Wilson, told TheJournal.ie he had decided to leave on Friday morning, calling McAleer’s approach “simplistic and misguided” and saying the play was “an incredible missed opportunity.”

Virtually everyone else involved, the director included, believed that he/she was going to be part of a meaningful piece of theatre that would shed light on a significant societal ill in this country and encourage a broader discussion about it.
That’s what this country needs right now… What it does not need is a play that, as another actress put it, “rubs salt in the wound.”
I’m afraid that’s exactly what Mr. McAleer’s work does and I cannot in good conscience be a part of it.

Phelim McAleer Phelim McAleer Source: Peter Duke, courtesy of LucyPR

McAleer has a record of making provocative documentary films that rail against pervasive narratives – like FrackNation, a direct response to the popular, anti-fracking documentary Gasland, and Not Evil Just Wrong, which challenges Al Gore’s An Inconvenient Truth.

In 2005,  he and his partner Ann McElhinney made “The Search for Tristan’s Mum”, about an illegally adopted and abandoned Indonesian child, which was shown on RTÉ.

McAleer is currently working on a TV movie telling the story of Kermit Gosnell, a Philadelphia abortion doctor convicted of multiple murders.

And “Ferguson” the play, represents for him another chapter in his mission, which he calls “correcting the record and telling the truth.”

It’s the perfect story for verbatim theatre. All the evidence is there, 5,000 pages of it. It’s a stunning, important, historical story.

McAleer is a former journalist at the Irish News, Sunday Times, Financial Times and The Economist.

What’s the point in being an artist or journalist if you’re not going to tell the truth and correct the record?
If you’re just going to repeat what everyone thinks is the truth, then you’re a stenographer for liars.

ferguson_graphic_hi-res Source: Courtesy of LucyPR

When it comes to the shooting of Michael Brown by Darren Wilson, McAleer claims some major untruths have been propagated and accepted.

There is no evidence at all that he ever had his hands up and said ‘Don’t shoot’…and that comes from forensics, DNA, and also very powerful African-American witnesses, many of whom said ‘I hate the police, but I’m here to tell the truth.’
And they told it, and it did not fit the narrative of ‘Hands up, don’t shoot.’

So when some of the “Ferguson” actors objected to the script, and asked him to change it, he dismissed their protests, telling conservative TV network The Blaze:

The truth is the truth. If your beliefs don’t coincide with the truth, then you need to change your beliefs.

Veralynn Jones, however, who has had roles in Seinfeld and ER, and is black, told the LA Times: “He claims that he wrote this to try to get to the truth of it, but everybody’s truth is totally subjective.”

When you come to the matter of what really happened, nobody really knows for sure, because everybody has a different take on it.

Jones is one of the five who left the project after the first script read-through, along with Carlease Burke, Phil Casnoff, and one other.

‘Messy-haired white boy’

Most of the criticism of McAleer on social media has focused on his political views, but some have also highlighted his race and Irish nationality, with one labelling him a “messy-haired white boy.”

McAleer rejects this, and called it “racist nonsense” when one Twitter user said the Michael Brown story should be told by a black writer.

I grew up a Catholic in Northern Ireland, with a completely paramilitarised police force that went around in armoured cars and tanks, that actually had a bona fide ‘shoot-to-kill’ policy.
So people need to back off the allegation that I don’t understand what it’s like to be in a minority situation with a police force that’s made up of the majority. I know exactly what it’s like.

At time of publication, “Ferguson” was still scheduled to begin its stage run in Los Angeles on Sunday.

Eight actors had left the project, after a meeting on Thursday evening.

You can read the Ferguson grand jury transcripts in full here.

Read: Cop who killed unarmed black teen ‘would not do anything different’>

Read: The police killings that have sparked racial tensions in the US this year>

About the author:

Dan MacGuill

Read next: