We need your help now

Support from readers like you keeps The Journal open.

You are visiting us because we have something you value. Independent, unbiased news that tells the truth. Advertising revenue goes some way to support our mission, but this year it has not been enough.

If you've seen value in our reporting, please contribute what you can, so we can continue to produce accurate and meaningful journalism. For everyone who needs it.

emergency cash

The ECB is threatening Greece the same way it did Ireland before the bailout

It’s threatening to end emergency funding if the Greeks don’t play ball.

Irelands Presidency Of The European Union ECB President Mario Draghi in Dubin, 2013. Mark Stedman / Photocall Ireland Mark Stedman / Photocall Ireland / Photocall Ireland

THE EUROPEAN CENTRAL Bank is threatening to withdraw emergency funding from Greek banks if the Greek government doesn’t do what it wants.

The central bank’s actions toward Greece occur less than two months after secret letters revealed that the ECB threatened to pull emergency funding from Irish banks if the State did not apply for a bailout, in what many saw as an overreach into the sovereign affairs of the country.

The ECB later pretended that Ireland had applied for its bailout voluntarily. The letters revealed that in fact the ECB had required the Irish government to apply.

It is one thing for the ECB to require individual banks to follow certain technical rules to maintain their liquidity. It is quite another for the ECB to pressure a government by threatening an entire nation’s banks with a sudden default by yanking their liquidity en masse.

That’s what is going on now with Greece.

Troika Arrive in ireland IMF official Ajai Chopra arriving at the Department of Finance in 2012. Sasko Lazarov / Photocall Ireland Sasko Lazarov / Photocall Ireland / Photocall Ireland

The new Greek government, led by the left-wing Syriza party, is attempting to renegotiate the terms of its bailout deal with the Troika.

Syriza wants a shift in the focus of “structural reforms” toward increasing tax collection and government efficiency and away from crude budget cuts; a “European debt conference” to renegotiate the repayment terms on the country’s debt (including linking interest payments to growth and writing down some of the debt); and a reduction in the government budget surplus the country is required to run.

The Troika wants to keep the current deal, which requires the Greek to run a budget surplus and implement a programme of reforms to bring government debt down. The country’s access to the funding from the central bank that supports its banking system may be cut off at the end of the month unless a compromise is struck.

This, at least, is the message coming from members of the ECB’s governing board.

Currently Greece enjoys special dispensation that allows its banks to use Greek government debt and government-guaranteed bank debt as collateral in exchange for funding from the central bank, despite being rated as “junk.”

This waiver was granted as part of a deal under which the country committed to undertake a package of structural reforms insisted upon by the Troika in exchange for bailout money.

Yet, as Bloomberg reports, ECB Vice President Vitor Constancio told an audience at a conference in Cambridge, England, last week that renegotiation of that deal could put the country’s banks at risk. ”There will be no surprises if we find out that a country is below that rating and there’s no longer a program that that waiver disappears,” he said.

Cyprus Greece Greek Prime Minister Alexis Tsipras AP / Press Association Images AP / Press Association Images / Press Association Images

If the waiver is withdrawn, then Greek banks will no longer be able to exchange the bonds on their balance sheet for ECB loans. Without that support, the sector could face widespread bankruptcies and could in turn push the country closer to collapse.

Constancio may make it sound as if this is simply a technocratic decision — that the ECB is bound to cut off Greek banks if the country fails to agree a terms with the EC and IMF over its bailout programme — just as it said when it threatened to cut Cyprus off in March 2013.

But that simply isn’t the case, according to UCD’s Professor Karl Whelan. Instead, he says, this is purely a discretionary decision designed to pressure Greece into making a deal.

He writes (emphasis added):

[Don't] believe for a minute that this is a technocratic thing to do with “the ECB having to follow its rules.” And it has almost nothing to do with Greek government bonds being junk-rated. All of the issues discussed above come down to discretionary decisions by the ECB Governing Council (restrictions on T-bills, waivers on junk-rated government bonds, arbitrary lines-in-the-sand on government guaranteed bonds and the mysterious rules of ELA) and there is plenty of wiggle room for them to allow Greek banks to continue receiving various sources of funding next month in the absence of an EU-IMF program agreement.

But while the threat is discretionary, the results are very real. In the lead-up to the Greece election, nervous clients of the country’s banks began to pull their money out of their accounts at a record rate. In December, depositors pulled €4.6 billion out of Greek banks, taking total deposits to its lowest point since November 2012, and the Greek press is reporting that January saw similar levels of outflows.

As a demonstration of the fears surrounding the banking sector, Greek bank stocks tumbled after Syriza’s electoral victory. Investors were clearly worried about the response of the Troika to the new government’s pledge to seek a better deal for Greece.

But these fears are forcing Greek banks to be all the more reliant on ECB funding as local sources of capital dry up.

https___www_moodys_com_researchdocumentcontentpage_aspx_docid_pbc_178867 2 Moodys Moodys

These signs suggests that a number of Greek banks, including the country’s largest lenders Eurobank Ergasias and Alpha Bank, may make use of the precautionary lines of credit that they set up with the ECB under its Emergency Liquidity Assistance (ELA). Further doubts surrounding the sustainability of emergency funding are only likely to increase the pace of deposit flight from Greek banks. That is, the ECB may be engineering the very crisis that it claims it wants to avoid.

Why would it seek to do this?

Well, although promoting this type of financial-market volatility may not be an effective way of helping the Greek economy back onto its feet, it has nevertheless proved useful in keeping countries compliant and appears now to be the model of choice rather than of last resort. The longer-term cost, however, may be that these institutions remain more reliant on ECB emergency funding than they would otherwise and much more difficult to rebuild confidence in.

Critics will argue that the central bank is wilfully overstepping its mandate of price stability in the eurozone to meddle in the affairs of sovereign nations. At present, it is hard to find a good argument that they are wrong.

- Tomas Hirst

Read: ‘Greek people have a very unhealthy relationship when it comes to paying tax’ >

Readers like you are keeping these stories free for everyone...
A mix of advertising and supporting contributions helps keep paywalls away from valuable information like this article. Over 5,000 readers like you have already stepped up and support us with a monthly payment or a once-off donation.

Published with permission from
Business Insider
Your Voice
Readers Comments
    Submit a report
    Please help us understand how this comment violates our community guidelines.
    Thank you for the feedback
    Your feedback has been sent to our team for review.