Readers like you keep news free for everyone.

More than 5,000 readers have already pitched in to keep free access to The Journal.

For the price of one cup of coffee each week you can help keep paywalls away.

Support us today
Not now
Tuesday 21 March 2023 Dublin: 10°C
LARRY W. SMITH/AP Jim Lovell takes a tour of a space centre in Kansas. Lovell and NASA are in dispute over whether Lovell had the right to auction a checklist from the Apollo 13 mission.
NASA and Apollo 13 astronaut in dispute over €300,000 auction
Jim Lovell sold a mission checklist at an auction last year for over €300,000 – but NASA reckons Lovell had no right to do so.

NASA HAS QUESTIONED whether the commander on the ill-fated Apollo 13 mission, James Lovell, has the right to sell a 70-page checklist from the flight – which includes his handwritten calculations crucial in guiding the damaged spacecraft back to Earth.

The document was sold by Heritage Auctions in November for more than €305,000, some 15 times its initial list price.

The checklist gained great fame as part of a key dramatic scene in the 1995 film ‘Apollo 13′, in which actor Tom Hanks plays Lovell making the calculations.

After the sale, NASA contacted Lovell and Heritage to ask whether Lovell had title to the checklist.

Greg Rohan, president of Dallas-based Heritage, told AP yesterday the sale has been suspended pending the outcome of the inquiry. The checklist, he said, is being stored for now in the company’s vault.

Rohan said Lovell provided a signed affidavit that he had clear title to the ring-bound checklist, which is standard procedure. Heritage does robust business in space memorabilia and has worked with many former astronauts, he added.

It’s one that is near and dear to our hearts… We, like a lot of people, consider these astronauts to be national heroes.

‘We’ve had a problem’

The Apollo 13 moon mission was aborted about 200,000 miles from Earth when an oxygen tank exploded on April 13, 1970, causing another tank to fail and seriously jeopardising the three-man crew’s ability to return home.

Astronaut Jack Swigert said the famous line “Houston, we’ve had a problem here” to report the explosion, according to a NASA history of the flight.

The crew was forced to move into the lunar landing module for the return flight. Lovell’s calculations on the checklist were key in transferring navigation data from the command craft to the lunar module.

In an email to Heritage, NASA deputy chief counsel Donna M Shafer said there appeared to be “nothing to indicate” that the agency had ever transferred ownership of the checklist to Lovell.

“Only NASA has the authority to clear NASA property for sale,” Shafer said in the email, which NASA provided to AP.

She said the matter has been turned over to NASA’s Office of Inspector General, adding that “there is potential risk of the items being seized by the government until title issues have been resolved.”

Lovell, 83, who lives near Chicago and owns a restaurant bearing his name in Lake Forest, Illinois, did not immediately respond to a telephone message left with his assistant.


NASA has also raised questions about title rights for two items Heritage had sold from Apollo 9 astronaut Rusty Schweikart: a lunar module identification plate that brought more than €10,000 and a hand controller bid at €17,850.

The space agency also targeted a fourth item, a hand glove worn by Alan Shepard during training for Apollo 14 that brought €15,000.

The letters follow a federal lawsuit NASA filed last year in Miami against Apollo 14 astronaut Edgar Mitchell seeking return of a camera he brought back from his 1971 moon mission.

That lawsuit was settled in October when Mitchell agreed to give the camera to NASA, which in turn is donating it to the National Air and Space Museum in Washington.

Mitchell’s attorney had argued prior to the settlement that NASA officials told astronauts long ago they could keep certain equipment from the missions, and many such items wind up on auction house lists. A 1972 NASA memo seems to back up that claim, requiring only that the astronauts provide the agency with lists of items in their possession.

Apollo 15 astronauts were reprimanded after they took unauthorised, special envelopes – labelled with stamps that were cancelled shortly after their return – to the moon with them in 1971.

They had a deal with a German stamp dealer who later sold them for $1,500 each.

- Curt Anderson

Your Voice
Readers Comments
This is YOUR comments community. Stay civil, stay constructive, stay on topic. Please familiarise yourself with our comments policy here before taking part.
Leave a Comment

    Leave a commentcancel