We need your help now

Support from readers like you keeps The Journal open.

You are visiting us because we have something you value. Independent, unbiased news that tells the truth. Advertising revenue goes some way to support our mission, but this year it has not been enough.

If you've seen value in our reporting, please contribute what you can, so we can continue to produce accurate and meaningful journalism. For everyone who needs it.

ISME chief executive Mark Fielding at the jobs committee today Oireachtas TV
Don't Bank on it

"They've replaced the tellers with plants" - are banks interested in lending to small business?

Domestic banks are failing to support a vital segment of the economy, lobby groups have said.

IRISH BANKS ARE understaffed, too risk-averse and ill-equipped to deal with the demands of the Small and Medium Enterprise sector, a Dail committee has been told.

The committee on jobs, enterprise and innovation heard from Mark Fielding of the Irish Small and Medium Enterprises association, who said that bank staff lack the expertise to make informed lending decisions for small businesses.

Citing the example of an ISME member who was seeking a lathe for metal working, Fielding said that the response from the banks relationship manager was:

‘We’re sorry, but we won’t be funding finance for your latte this year.’ That’s the type of experience we have.

He continued: “Even going into a bank now…you go up to your local branch in Carrick-on-Shannon and two of the tellers have been replaced with plants.”

Onerous demands

Fielding went on to detail cases of ISME members who had been refused loans under ‘unjustifiably hard’ conditions. They included:

  • A bank looking for guarantees of €800,000 for a €60,000 loan
  • A bank not accepting €550,000 security against a €100,000 loan

He said that surveys of ISME members had shown that using the family home of a small businessperson as collateral has been brought into discussions to 15 per cent of occasions, and the bank has asked for the family home as collateral 11 per cent of the time.

“Yellow pack relationship managers”

Fielding said that staff facing SME owners in branches are not up to scratch.

“It’s not so much the ability of the SME but the calibre of the yellow pack relationship managers in banks, who between them can’t read a set of figures, are frightened by the word risk, and scared of making a lending decision.”

AJ Noonan of the Small Firms Association agreed, saying that “banks have credit departments where risk is feared.”

Challenge to bank figures

He challenged official figures from Bank of Ireland, AIB and Ulster Bank which claimed approval rates of between 80 and 90 per cent for SME loan applications.

ISME’s bankwatch survey of its members found that 54 per cent of SMEs who had applied for lending from banks in the 3 months ending in February were refused credit from their banks.

SFA chairman AJ Noonan said that 31 per cent of SFA members felt their relationship with their bank had disimproved, while 29 per cent reported an increase in the cost of working capital.

He said: “The great majority feel that the relationship is missing from the relationship manager title. They want someone…who responds effectively.”

Fielding also criticised the practice of what he termed “effective refusal” of loans, whereby banks turn down or advise against an application without officially processing it, thereby artificially deflating their refusal rate.

Noonan said that many loans are approved “on the basis that approval levels remain high, but there really is no danger of the funds ever being drawn down”.

The ‘long no’, when banks constantly return with more questions and criteria to borrowers was also criticised by members of Ibec giving evidence to the committee.

Small business stranded by foreign bank exit>

‘SSIA for SMEs’ could unlock €90 billion funding pot>

Your Voice
Readers Comments
    Submit a report
    Please help us understand how this comment violates our community guidelines.
    Thank you for the feedback
    Your feedback has been sent to our team for review.