#Open journalism No news is bad news

Your contributions will help us continue to deliver the stories that are important to you

Support The Journal
Dublin: 16°C Saturday 18 September 2021

US, China forge tentative deal on Chinese activist

The US and China outlined a tentative deal today to send a blind legal activist to America for study – which could potentially bring an end to a delicate diplomatic crisis.

In this photo released by the US Embassy Beijing Press Office, blind lawyer Chen Guangcheng, left, talks with U.S. ambassador to China, Gary Locke
In this photo released by the US Embassy Beijing Press Office, blind lawyer Chen Guangcheng, left, talks with U.S. ambassador to China, Gary Locke
Image: AP Photo/U.S. Embassy Beijing Press Office, HO

WITH A SERIES of quickly choreographed steps, the US and China outlined a tentative deal Friday to send a blind legal activist to America for study and potentially bring a face-saving end to a delicate diplomatic crisis.

The arrangements, if kept, promise to give Chen Guangcheng much of what he wanted: a chance to live with his family in safety and to get a formal legal education. It would also allow Washington and Beijing to put aside a rancorous human rights dispute to focus on managing their rivalry for global influence.

As part of the deal, China’s Foreign Ministry said Chen can apply for travel permits to study abroad. The State Department said an American university — later identified as New York University — has offered a fellowship for Chen with provisions for his family. Spokeswoman Victoria Nuland said the US expects Beijing to process the travel permits quickly, and once done, visas would be issued.

“I don’t think this is empty talk here. I think they mean this is a way out, and it’s a dignified way out. It’s a good way out for the Chinese government and our government and for Chen and his family,” said Jerome Cohen, an NYU law professor who met Chen nearly a decade ago, advised him during the negotiations and arranged the fellowship.

‘Progress has been made’

In a sign that not all was settled, Secretary of State Hillary Rodham Clinton offered a guarded assessment.

“Over the course of the day, progress has been made to help him have the future that he wants, and we will be staying in touch with him as this process moves forward,” said Clinton, who was in Beijing for annual strategic talks.

The progress, however, seemed significant after a bizarre, rocky crisis triggered when Chen, an inspirational figure in China’s human rights movement, escaped from house arrest in his rural home and reached the US Embassy in Beijing last Friday. First saying he wanted to stay in China, a smiling Chen emerged from the fortress-like embassy to a hospital reunion with his wife and two children only to say hours later that he changed his mind.

In cell phone calls from his hospital room with friends and foreign media, he said he and his family felt unsafe and he wanted to go abroad, undoing a deal US and Chinese officials worked out to guarantee their safe relocation to a city in China where he could study law.

“My situation right now is very dangerous,” Chen told The Associated Press early Friday. On Thursday, he dialed into a congressional hearing to make a direct appeal for Clinton’s help.

The drama unfolded but did not derail the two days of talks by Clinton, Treasury Secretary Timothy Geithner and their Chinese counterparts on irritants that bedevil US-China relations: trade, Iran’s and North Korea’s nuclear programs, conflict in Syria and cyber-spying.

“This week has shown again that we cannot wall off human rights from our bilateral relationship or relegate it to the margins of our engagement,” Clinton said at the end of the talks.

Much could still upend the agreement. A key problem is where Chen and his family would pick up their passports. Returning to their home town, the usual route, would expose them to possible retribution from the same local officials who illegally put Chen and his family under house arrest to punish him for exposing forced abortions and other misdeeds carried out as part of China’s one-child policy. Applying directly to the police ministry, which issues passports, is allowed in some cases.

‘Undermine national security’

Authorities could still deny Chen by law if it’s determined that he “will undermine national security or cause major losses to the interests of the state.”

“This has been used to deny passports to people who will hurt China’s image,” said John Kamm, a veteran human rights campaigner. Among those denied passports is Tibetan writer Tsering Woeser.

Chen could not be reached for comment. The cell phone he had used for days was switched off.

Still there were signs that his treatment was improving. After being unable to meet with US officials for the better part of two days, Chen was allowed to meet with embassy staff and an American doctor.

#Open journalism No news is bad news Support The Journal

Your contributions will help us continue to deliver the stories that are important to you

Support us now

Medical checkups showed his health is good except for three broken bones in his foot suffered when he was escaping from his rural village, a senior State Department official said.

Hospital staff brought his children new clothes, cut their hair and gave his son, Kerui, a present for his birthday, the official said. The son, who lived with relatives during the family’s recent house arrest, is believed to be around 10, family friends said, a vagueness that is typical in rural China where birthdays are traditionally celebrated at the Lunar New Year.

Chinese officials have also begun talking to Chen about his mistreatment by officials in his home province, Shandong, the US Embassy said. As part of the agreement that originally brought Chen out of the embassy, US officials said China had agreed to look into his complaints.

Chen spent nearly all of the past seven years in prison or under house arrest. During the past 20 months of home confinement with his wife, mother and 6-year-old daughter Kesi, Chen has said local officials and people they hired beat the adults, followed and searched the girl and humiliated them.

Chen faces no criminal charges

At a briefing shortly after the Foreign Ministry said Chen could apply to go abroad, spokesman Liu Weimin also confirmed that Chen faces no pending criminal charges, indirectly acknowledging that the house arrest he and his family endured in their rural home was illegal.

“According to Chinese laws, he is a regular citizen. He can absolutely go through regular formalities by normal means,” Liu said.

Should China permit the Chens to travel, it’s unclear when they would go. Authorities have up to 30 days to consider a passport application, and Cohen, the NYU professor, said he hopes to see them by summer. Also left unresolved if they go is whether Beijing will refuse to allow them back, as it has done with some dissidents.

Senior State Department officials, briefing reporters about the arrangements, said the question of Chen’s return to China did not come up in negotiations with Chinese officials.

Read: Fearing for his family’s safety, escaped activist wants to leave China – US

About the author:

Associated Press

Read next: