TheJournal.ie uses cookies. By continuing to browse this site you are agreeing to our use of cookies. Click here to find out more »
Dublin: 10 °C Sunday 26 May, 2013

450,000 home help hours could go as HSE plans €8 million cut

The changes would equate to about 450,000 hours being lost – but the HSE says direct patient care services will stay.

Image: Eamonn Farrell/Photocall Ireland

THE HEALTH SERVICE EXECUTIVE has said it proposed to cut about €8 million of spending on home help hours between now and the end of the year – a cut equivalent to about 450,000 hours of service in the next three months.

The HSE has told TDs that it intends to make the cuts between now and December, having originally announced cuts of €10.8 million as part of the HSE’s quest to balance its books before the end of the year.

“It is the HSE’s intention that the impact of these reductions will be minimised by ensuring that services are provided, in the first instance, for direct patient care,” the HSE said in response to parliamentary questions from Fianna Fáil’s health spokesman Billy Kelleher.

“Decisions in relation to the provision of home help hours will continue to be based on a review of individual needs, and no current recipient of this service and who has an assessed need for the service, will be without a service.”

The HSE said it provided about 11 million hours of home help services with an annual budget of €195 million – equating to 2.75 million hours every three months at a cost of €48.75 million. On that basis, if applied proportionally, an €8 million cut would mean about 450,000 hours lost.

Kelleher said the cuts would have to be implemented in a “chaotic and ham-fisted way” simply because James Reilly had not be able to implement the cuts to the health budget that he had promised.

“This is on top of 500,000 home-help hours being cut earlier in the year,” Kelleher said.

“It betrays the meaningless of Minister Reilly’s promise of minimising the impact of these cuts on the most vulnerable.”

SIPTU also criticised the decision as “morally unacceptable and illogical”.

Health division organiser Paul Bell said the cuts would “not only reduce the provision of care to the most vulnerable in our society, but will also result in more people having to avail of full-time care in a hospital setting”.

“These outcomes go directly against the stated aim of the Government to develop community based health services and reduce spending,” he said.

The HSE’s response to Kelleher indicated that the service had “a statutory responsibility to live within the Budget voted to it by the Oireachtas”.

Read next:

Comments (41 Comments)

  • Reducing ex and current TD’s inflated salaries/pensions and expenses would easily cover the 8m figure every year.

    Reply
    • If that were to happen, other peoples pay would have to be cut across the public sector for it to be fair. Hogan had the law changed to suit the implementation of the Household Tax so the excuse of the Public Sector Pay Agreement (Croke Park) doesn’t hold resonance as much as it did when the Cowen brigade et all signed off on it! Its time this government started communicating properly with each other in the Dail and stopped feckin arguing! The solution lies with the resources available to them within their own balance sheets not with the resources available to the everyday people! That barrel was scraped a long time ago and the nails of up ordinary folk are worn down to the nub, so to speak :-|

      Reply
    • 05/10/12 #

      Hear hear

      Reply
    • how right u are. what about the vote to get rid of the Senate as Enda saib b4 the election

      Reply
  • Guys guys guys, give the lowlifes SOME credit. They waited a full 4 days after handing a billion to bondholders before telling us about the latest cuts necessary because theres apparently no money available.

    Reply
  • I am really disgusted at this. My mother availed of home help hours when she was in chemotherapy and none of us could take time out of work to be with her every day. She had company, help with the housework so that she could just concentrate on letting the treatment do its work, and when we all got home we could do what we really wanted to do, which was spend as much time with her as possible. She also got out and about doing the shopping during the day, which was invaluable for her confidence and quality of life. If we hadn’t had those home help hours, my mother would have had a much much lower quality of life when she was ill. I hope minister Reilly never has to watch someone he loves be in that position. But sure with his pension and salary he could hire a private nurse. Not all of us have that luxury.

    Reply
    • Exactly. I live in Canada now and my mother, who is diabetic, has a visit from home help each morning. They ensure she hasn’t slipped into a coma, because she struggles to control her blood sugars overnight, and make her a good breakfast which is critical for a diabetic.

      Reply
  • What an absolute disgrace, home help gives elderly people peace of mind knowing they can continue living at home with a bit of dignity. O Reilly and his fellow idiots in the HSE should resign for the sake of the country.

    Reply
  • shame on the irish goverment, shame on you.

    Reply
  • cut tds salarys ,expensives ect… and you would get 8 million back very easy

    Reply
  • Typical Irish government. Cut money and services for the people who need it most!

    Reply
    • The only thing that Our government, and I use that term loosely, can do that’s worse than this is to switch off people on life support machines to save on electricity.
      I know there are serious issues with flouride in the water but somebody may test the water in government buildings for lead as everyone who goes to work in them ends up MAD.

      Reply
  • cut it and see those home patients flood into A&E. do these guys not think with any form of logic?

    Reply
  • so carers get over 16 euro an hour that’s bullshit my mother does this and she’s just over minimum wage those maths are wrong it will be more like 7 r 8 hundred thousand hours be cut I reckon

    Reply
  • Cuts cuts cuts cuts cuts… “Enda Scissorhands” coming to to a cinema near you this Halloween.

    Reply
  • There’s a disabled child in hospital since she was born in crumlin because the hse have no money to pay for the kind of home care she needs 7 days a week. All they are offering the parents is one day a week. The parents have to work to pay the mortgage so they are no choice but for the child to remain in limbo. Ridiculous.
    Also the Hse are going to be relying on the likes of crosscare a care charity that supply volunteers to go into the elderly homes to feed and do some housework. For free; usually by people recently made redundant and in need of wages and doing this in order to be a useful part of society. So the hse are making cuts and getting care for nothing.

    Reply
  • Most vulnerable affected again. Bad enough being in the situation to need home help as a result of chronic illness. If I could afford to emigrate I would be gone. It’s now a struggle living in this incredible mess of a country. Very sad that this is the situation and there’s lots more cuts on the way.

    Reply
  • Most vulnerable hit again. Wasters in government. Useless people looking to line their own pockets while the people suffer on.

    Reply
  • Some agencies ae paid by the HSE 27euro an hour, and then the agency pays the “carer” between 8euro-12euro an hour depending on location of care recipient. The HSE also has a direct care service – called Personal Care Package by where the care recipient gets paid directly 13.88euro an hour and can employ their own carer for up to 10 hours a week . This is normally for less acute, more mobile applicant for long and short term care. If ALL home help was moved away from Agency staff and towards direct payments for care recipents, there would be EXTRA hours available from the current budget. There is NO WILL on the part of the government to deliver care, just keep their well paid agency buddies in plum positions. Many agencies are owned and run by firneds/families and supporters of TDs and Senators from FF FG Lab etc.

    Reply
  • Shame on the government,and I bet my house that none of their sick family members are going to be affected.

    Reply
  • March from GPO 17th Oct. We who are disabled, sick or elderly are being made the scapegoats of the financial gangsters who bankrupted this country. we cannot be squeezed any more. Personal Assistants are being frozen, cut and not given to those disabled people who desperately need them. now home helps and home care packages. many will have to go into nursing homes which will cost the state FAR MORE. it is ludicrous. please inform everyone of the socialist workers party march for home helps. lets expand it to cover all support services being cut for disabled, sick and elderly. stand up and shout “enough is enough”

    Reply
  • Here we go again.

    Reply
  • Makes me do mad when they talk s out taking hours from the home help and personal care
    What about cutting the senators like Edna said and cutting Tds wages and his own doesn’t he get paid more than Obama for gods sake start from the top up instead of the bottom up all this government do is take away from the needy

    Reply
  • Makes me so mad the hospitals will be out the door what are they thinking assh%les :(

    Reply
  • it is horrendous. there is no reason for this, i just believe it cannot go ahead and people have to stand by all of us who need these home helps and need them BADLY, not just one hour can be taken in cuts, not one. i was at the pre-budget disability groups launch and Kathleen Lynch was there, i just knew she knew she was keeping her distance, a hint that she couldnt guaruntee more cuts ahead but i never dreamt on this scale, a march is planned so all who actually feel strongly about this, do join us on wednes 17th. its despicable.

    Reply
  • i am cutting and pasting this from the SWP website. I am not a party member…I am just disabled and frightened. Please join the walk.

    The home helps themselves are protesting again on Weds Oct 17th at 3pm in O Connell St and will hopefully join the Nov 24th pre budget march with a massive contingent of workers and supporters. SIPTU need to roll in behind these demonstations and throw their full weight into resisting this cutbacks and the privatisation of our essential services.

    Let’s keep the pressure on!

    Can you poster your area for the protests? Or if you can take some leaflets and posters:
    John Lyons PBP 0877729292

    If you want to get organised and join the socialists. Text JOIN to 0863074060

    Reply
  • But the boys will still be propping up the Dail bar, oh well only another €12.5 billion more cuts to come.

    Reply
  • Yet again the vulnerable and hard working suffer. We are all aware of the term “Let’s bite the hand of those that feed us” Why not just got full hog and feed them to the sharks.!!

    Reply
  • Please join the Home Help / home Care Action group on Facebook (see link above) & join this protest, Many Thanks folks! :-)

    Reply
  • Oops! Sorry for double post!!

    Reply
  • Are home help paid nearly €18 per
    hour ?

    Reply

Add New Comment