TheJournal.ie uses cookies. By continuing to browse this site you are agreeing to our use of cookies. Click here to find out more »
Dublin: 13 °C Monday 20 May, 2013

Cardinal Brady expresses ‘deep shame’ over Church abuse

However, he stopped short of offering a specific apology for his own actions in the investigation of child abuse.

Cardinal Brady at the Eucharistic Congress this week
Cardinal Brady at the Eucharistic Congress this week
Image: Laura Hutton/Photocall Ireland

CARDINAL SEÁN BRADY has expressed “deep shame” in an apology to victims of clerical child abuse, on behalf of the Catholic Church in Ireland.

However, the Primate of All-Ireland stopped short of offering a specific apology for his own controversial role in the investigation of abuse by Fr Brendan Smyth.

Speaking yesterday at the International Eucharistic Congress in Dublin’s RDS, Brady asked forgiveness, saying that the suffering of abuse victims continues. He said:

May God forgive us for the times when we as individuals and as a Church failed to seek out and care for those little ones who were frightened, alone and in pain because someone was abusing them. That we did not always respond to your cries with the concern of the Good Shepherd is a matter of deep shame.

He added:

I want to take this opportunity of the 50th International Eucharistic Congress to apologise for the times when some of us were blind to your fear, deaf to your cries and silent in response to your pain.

Brady did not refer specifically to his own actions in the investigation of Fr Brendan Smyth’s abuse. He faced widespread calls for his resignation after reports that he was given the names and addresses of some of Smyth’s victims, but did not protect them.

Two of the victims continued to be abused by Smyth after the inquiry in which Brady – then a junior priest – was involved had concluded, it was reported.

Tánaiste Eamon Gilmore was among those who suggested that Brady “should not hold a position of authority” after the revelations.

Read: Brendan Boland – My healing won’t begin until Brady resigns>

Read next:

Comments (45 Comments)

  • Way too little, way too late!n

    Reply
  • Brady if you know the meaning of the word (Decent) Stand the hell down at once!

    Reply
  • Too little too late….. Resign

    Reply
  • Makes me sick.. Whats the point in him saying sorry now???

    Reply
  • Just resign and go brady you’re a disgrace

    Reply
  • ah, wasn’t that nice of him to say sorry… all’s forgiven and forgotten so…..

    Reply
  • Snake

    Reply
  • Looks like there’s 5 or 6 cardinal Brady’s on here not too pleased with the comments!

    Reply
  • “I want to take this opportunity of the 50th International Eucharistic Congress to apologise for the times when some of us were blind to your fear, deaf to your cries and silent in response to your pain.“
    The thing is Brady wasn’t any of the above. He was aware of the fear,cries and pain and he consciously chose to put the reputation of the church above all else and allow more children to be abused.
    He and others in the church were not unaware of what was going on but they chose not to stop it and are therefore complicit and he again hasn’t addressed this.
    Half talking the talk and not walking the walk is not good enough.
    Pathetic excuse of a man!

    Reply
  • “May God forgive us….”

    Eh, didn’t “god” stand by while it happened? Or did he not have the power to stop it?

    Reply
  • am i missing something here. if a guy has explicitly pictures of children on his computer he is jailed . and rightly so… and another guy who has aided pedophiles and silenced abused victims … gets away with giving a half hearted apology … and is never question ed by the gardai ….. i think the second bishop sorry i ment to say guy .. he is a bigger criminal than the first guy has

    Reply
  • It is the victims forgiveness these guys should be begging for- sad how these old men cling to power propped up by the naive laity deluded by years of supression

    Reply
  • One thing is certain; They could’nt have got away with it for so long without the help of the SPINELESS governments we had down the years

    Reply
  • When I was 6 weeks old they poured water over my head and without asking my permission told me that I was now a member of their church. unfortunately they had previously brainwashed my parents into bringing me along to the font of all knowledge. When I was a little older I realised that this was a meaningless charade so I freed myself from their conditioning. I am now a reasonably normal human being.

    Reply
  • Your God stands by while every atrocity caused by man happens, because he does’nt Exist you are being taken for a ride, anyone like to buy a tin of checkered paint!

    Reply
  • I do not wish to soil the name of Lennon/McCartney but, They must be singing “We all live in a yellow submarine” down at the Euphemistic Congress whilst clapping hands in unison. Ah! the little dears

    Reply
  • The catholic church is not based on equality: Woman is treated as a second class member. Why is there a hierarchy if all are equal. Fat cats in silk robes and pointed hats dining with the rich, living in palaces with art collections worth enough to make one cringe.

    Reply
  • Then resign you cowardly piece of crap! Asking some sky fairy for ‘forgiveness’ may get you off the hook with your imaginary deity and the rest of the cult you all follow but in the real world you stand accused of not only protecting a vile pedophile but remaining silent about it whilst he went on committing sexual abuses against even more children as you climbed the greasy pole to become a cardinal, the way you helped silence the children had all the hallmarks of a pedophiles behaviour all over it, blame the victims, threaten them and then keep them silent through fear. Brady is a disgrace to humanity and devoid of any moral authority, watching him strut around at the circus this week only shows what a pathetic hypocrite he is and anyone with a shred of decency would have resigned a long time ago.

    Reply
    • Well said Appleby
      agree with every thing you said, why do the people allow this to happy??? stop going to church, stop going to confession, take away all support from the bastards and allow the present decline to speed up!!
      without the ‘sheep’ the church won’t last long.
      enjoyed your posting.

      Reply
  • Hand wringing and trotting out the old ‘deeply ashamed’ line. Too little, too late and too unconvincing, but never mind Minister Quinn has no intention of forcing a church-state separation in education. That’s socialism, Irish style.

    Reply
  • RESIGN BRADY AND TAKE THE CHURCH WITH YOU

    Reply
  • As father Ted would say “Down with that sort of thing”

    Reply
  • Sorry I have to rush off, there is a magician up the road turning biscuits into flesh; don’t want to miss that, bye! for now.

    Reply
  • Jonno 15/06/12 #

    Pity that all these monsters have ruined the good work and good intentions of the few who joined organized religious cults to do some good. Hope they die in agony

    Reply
  • Have to ponder and stare vacantly into space: the angelus is ringing

    Reply
  • Joseph McGranag; I hope you are joking; or you seem to miss the point that everyone else has copped. The Cardigans is a derogatory.

    Reply
  • Hi Mark; They know that there is no god they want us to believe in order that they can keep us under control. You do not hear about the thousands of priests worldwide who are in care in mental instutions because they realised during training, that this is a set up and they don’t know what they are doing when they hold the wafer in their hand and lift it up and down, because Nothing happens. They know there is no god because their predecessors invented him. There is however the church of jesus who may have been a wandering do-gooder and small time magician, but not a miracle worker.

    Reply
  • I believe he gave an extensive, sincere, comprehensive apology; in the most prominent platform available to him. Attacks on his effort do not reflect on him, but on the willingness of the beholder to listen to, or hear him. But of course to err is human, to forgive Divine.

    Reply
    • Barry 15/06/12 #

      Both himself and the church knew the errors of their ways but they didn’t practice what the preached to the sheep they tried to control for years, only when they were forced to the wall did they even consider they should apologise and when they first did it it was half arsed.

      Not to mention the religious groups still own victims alot of money,

      Frankly its insulting for somebody like yourself to some how suggest that we should forgive this snake of a man and organization, they were forced into admitting they made mistakes and they have lied to the people of Ireland and the world for decades, this corruption goes to the very top of that organization.

      You clearly fail to understand the continued abuse these people caused to their victims, these people will never properly recover

      Reply
    • He gave nothing. Him and his ilk have poisoned this country. I hope he burns.

      Reply
    • Philosopher Luc Bovens wrote recently on apologies and argued that the apologiser must recognize that what they did was morally wrong and that they are culpable for their actions meaning that the apologiser must do more than merely regret that what happened turned out badly and take appropriate action.

      Can we say that for the Cardinal? Did he do the morally right thing, even if it turned out that this had negative consequences? It does not take a Cannonical Lawyer to make a judgement call on that one.

      Well may Cardinal Brady apologise and ask for forgivness for nothing will save the Cardinal and all those who aided, abetted and were involved with abuse. Yet they ‘apologise’ and do nothing and we fume and do nothing.

      Reply
    • Silent Bob: ‘Can we say that for the Cardinal?’ No.

      They (the Church) have ignored morals and ethics… and human decency for generations. Brady has not apologised for his (non)actions and furthermore:

      …’I want to take this opportunity of the 50th International Eucharistic Congress to apologise for the times when some of us were blind to your fear, deaf to your cries and silent in response to your pain.’

      They were not blind and deaf to this. They knew what was going on and they covered it up to save the face of their organisation. This was not an apology. This was Vatican Spin.

      Reply
    • One can only hope that the unrestrained venom poured out here will not be his final judgement. But of course it may contribute to the judgement of its authors!

      Reply
    • Ah, I see the Journal are censoring comments again.

      Ok…. I’ll just laugh at this thread on my own then.

      Reply
    • The Prochnow Principle
      “To err may be human, but to admit it isn’t.”
      Herbert V. Prochnow (1897-1998)

      Reply
    • BULL!!! S*****T Scully !!

      Reply

Add New Comment