TheJournal.ie uses cookies. By continuing to browse this site you are agreeing to our use of cookies. Click here to find out more »
Dublin: 7 °C Wednesday 22 May, 2013

Cloyne clerical abuse report to be published this month

Lengthy saga of legalese to come to an end after Cabinet sees report on 12 July says Justice Minister Alan Shatter.

Children's shoes hung as a protest against clerical sexual abuse of children
Children's shoes hung as a protest against clerical sexual abuse of children
Image: Eamonn Farrell/Photocall Ireland

THE MURPHY REPORT into the handling of child sexual abuse claims in the diocese of Cloyne will be published this month.

Justice Minister Alan Shatter told RTE today that the Government would receive the report on 12 July, Tuesday week, and it should be “published very shortly” after that. The minister also said the publication of the report had been more “drawn out” than he had expected.

Bishop of Cloyne John Magee resigned from his position in March last year after two investigations into child abuse allegations in his diocese criticised his inaction on claims.

The Murphy Report into the situation in Cloyne has been long delayed:

  • A preliminary report into the handling of two child abuse claims in the diocese was published in December 2008. It was compiled by Ian Elliott of the National Board for Safeguarding Children and found the actions taken by John Magee and other Church officials was “significantly deficient in a number of respects”.
  • The publication of Elliott’s report itself was delayed, and both Alan Shatter and then Sunday Tribune journalist Justine McCarthy had criticised then Children’s Minister Barry Andrews for not ordering the publication immediately when it was received in July.
  • A more extensive inquiry headed up by Judge Yvonne Murphy was ordered in January 2009. It was given a deadline of December 2010 for completion.
  • The Irish Catholic reported in January 2011, shortly after the Murphy inquiry concluded, that the findings of the judge would be delayed by legal concerns over reference to one person in the report.
  • It was then reported in March that the Murphy report into Cloyne would be published by early May. The Sunday Business Post reported that Justice Minister Alan Shatter had to ask the High Court if he could publish the report in full, or with some omissions in the case of ongoing investigations or court proceedings.
  • At the beginning of April, the President of the High Court Mr Justice Nicholas Kearns said it would be mid-July at the earliest before the report could be published in full because of pending criminal proceedings against one priest named in the report. It was first reported that most of the report could be published apart from Chapter 9 which contained references to that priest but then it emerged that other references in the report may have identified him.
  • On 21 April, Shatter said that the legal issues meant the report would not be published until the second week in May at the earliest.
  • Today, Shatter said that the report will be presented to the Cabinet on 12 July and published as soon as possible afterwards.

Read next:

Comments (6 Comments)

  • The Cloyne report is at this stage a smaller part of what is a much larger story.

    Ian Elliott, who did the initial survey, has at this stage completed up to three additional audits (working for the church, not state mandated) none of which have been published, though I understand they have been delivered to the relevant bishops, and as I understand it his group was asked by the church to do similar audits countrywide.

    But see Patsy McGarry’s article in the Irish Times on Thursday, and his report from the Safeguarding Children annual report launch, for evidence of a continuing lack of church cooperation on child safety issues.

    Reply
  • So, the news is there may be news in at least 10 days in which case it will be reported as news… Come on guys, if there’s no news, just go home and sit outside with a nice glass of wine.

    Reply
  • Consider the words of one Roman Catholic priest and a former Irish Central Blogger who went by the moniker ‘Fr. Tim’ who spoke the TRUTH when he wrote : “Terrible, unspeakable crimes have been committed, with God’s most-innocent the helpless victims. They were abused, beaten or raped by a clergy entrusted with their care. Almost as bad, their crimes were routinely covered up by the Church hierarchy — perhaps even by Benedict — and the perpetrators were left to prey on others. Church officials swore victims to secrecy and blamed them for their own abuse in acts of psychological torture. The Church used its self-made throne in society to hold police and political leaders at bay.Until now, thank God.The day of reckoning has arrived at last, and Our Heavenly Father has opened the dark skies to let His Light pour in. No one can escape God’s Final Judgment, and let us pray that those who abused His Dear Children by vile act or vile cover-up, will not escape earthly judgment as well. God bless you all! — Father Tim” ”*** Not surprisingly “Fr. Tim” is no longer blogging at Irish Central and it would not surprise me to learn if he was now banished by the Roman Catholic hierarchy to a monastery where he spends his time in seclusion for the unforgiveable crime of TELLING the TRUTH! You can read his entire article: GOOGLE: ‘Nobody buying what Catholic Church defenders selling’ / Irish Central

    Reply

Add New Comment