Welcome to our Public Beta Site - What does this mean?
Dublin: 12 °C Wednesday 23 May, 2012

Egyptian ruler defends use of force as video emerges of woman being attacked by soldiers

Egyptian protesters line up on cement blocks being used as a road barrier by the military in Cairo.
Egyptian protesters line up on cement blocks being used as a road barrier by the military in Cairo.
Image: AP Photo/Nasser Nasser/PA Images

EGYPT’S ARMY has come under heavy criticism after footage emerged at the weekend of soldiers dragging and kicking a woman whose clothing was torn and pulled over her head to reveal her underwear.

In the video posted online, the woman is beaten by several soldiers and kicked in the head before two drag her away by her hands. Another soldier stamps on her chest before one of the troops attempts to cover her bare torso with her torn clothing.

Further footage and photos have also been released of soldiers beating protesters around the head and kicking them while prostrate on the ground or with their hands bound.

(Warning: Video contains violent images some viewers may find disturbing)



(Video via RussiaToday)

As least 14  people have died since the latest clashes broke out on Friday between protesters demonstrating against ongoing military rule and security forces. Parliamentary elections are still underway in the country.

Defending force

Yesterday, a member of the ruling military council defended the soldiers’ use of force and accused the media of attempting to “sabotage the state”.

Major General Adel Emara questioned protesters’ motives and morals. He said the army had a duty to protect the state, saying: “What are we supposed to do when protesters break the law? Should we invite people from abroad to govern our nation?”

“There is a methodical and premeditated plot to topple the state, but Egypt will not fall,” he added.

Emara described the aforementioned attack on the unarmed woman as an isolated incident that would be investigated.

This morning, police raided Cairo’s Tahrir Square – the focal point of the popular uprising which forced former leader Hosni Mubarak from power in February – in the latest effort to clear the area of protesters. According to a field hospital doctor, a 15-year-old boy is seriously injured after being shot in the chest.

The UN’s human rights chief Navi Pillay has condemned the violent suppression of protests in Egypt and said that some of those filmed abusing demonstrators at the weekend should be easily identified and prosecuted.

“The graphic images of protesters, including women, being brutally clubbed and assaulted, long after the point when they are showing any resistance, are utterly shocking,” Pillay said.

“People lying motionless on the ground are shown on film being smashed on the head and body with sticks. These are life-threatening and inhuman acts that cannot possibly be justified under the guise of restoration of security or crowd control.”

Reporters Without Borders has criticised what it describes as the military’s “systematic use of violence” against media workers, saying that several have come forward to say they were beaten by soldiers and had equipment destroyed or stolen.

- Additional reporting by the AP

Read more: More than 440 wounded during clashes in Egypt >

Read Next:

Comments (9 Comments)

  • Will Hourihan 20/12/11 #
    Report this comment

    Savages! It’s absolutely horrific to see the ‘protectors ‘ of the people turning against them and seemingly enjoying it.

    Reply
  • Brian Ward 20/12/11 #
    Report this comment

    What a seriously f**ked society. No doubt the guy who was beating her on the ground went on to cover her up because her exposed torso was “un-Islamic” . It wouldn’t surprise me if the arrested her for this and sentenced her to 50 lashes. Those cops might want to remember that the wheel turns. Pictures like this will only further inflame the protesters. I’m furious after looking at this coverage so you can imagine how your average Egyptian protester feels.

    Reply
  • Joe Sixtwo 20/12/11 #
    Report this comment

    The Arab Spring.

    Reply
  • Auntie Dote 20/12/11 #
    Report this comment

    Armies have a duty to protect the people. Turning the ‘State’ into a fetish, subverts the army into the opposite of what it should be – a weapon against the people.

    What has happened to the soldiers with a conscience, who would not fire on their fellow citizens?

    Reply
  • Damhsa Dmf 20/12/11 #
    Report this comment

    I don’t believe this can be excused or justified in any way shape or form. No soldier should treat his own people whom he is meant to protect in this manner. I understand soldiers are called to protect the state internally but usually from foreign invaders. Soldiers should protect unarmed civilians not military rule or corrupt governments.
    During the time of Rome, no soldiers were allowed within the city’s walls.

    Sort out elections quickly, and step aside and let the civilians get in and run things.

    Reply
  • Gerard Murphy 20/12/11 #
    Report this comment

    The EU should suspend diplomatic relations with Egypt and it’s ruling military regime.

    Reply
  • Derek Durkin 20/12/11 #
    Report this comment

    US endorsed democracy at work.

    Reply
  • Rocky Dennis 20/12/11 #
    Report this comment

    Bet they are sorry Mubarek is gone now…..devil u know and all that. Watch Libya go the same way….

    Reply
  • Eileen Gabbett 20/12/11 #
    Report this comment

    Soldiers are modern day warriors and , ” Common virtues in warrior codes are mercy, courage and loyalty.” There was no courage Loyalty or mercy shown here. This is a disgrace.

    Reply

Add New Comment