TheJournal.ie uses cookies. By continuing to browse this site you are agreeing to our use of cookies. Click here to find out more »
Dublin: 12 °C Sunday 19 May, 2013

Lower death rates for those taking cholesterol medication and exercise – study

New research also shows that the benefits of physical fitness outweigh those of cholesterol lowering medication.

Image: Tyler Olson via Shutterstock

TAKING CHOLESTEROL MEDICATION or being even modestly physically fit significantly improves survival in people with dyslipidaemia - abnormal levels of harmful blood fats or cholesterol, according to new research.

The research, published online first in The Lancet also shows that combining statin (cholesterol lowering drugs) treatment with better fitness may do more to ward off death than either intervention alone.

Most strikingly, the study found that even people with dyslipidaemia not taking statins, but who were highly fit, were roughly half as likely to die from any cause during the median 10-year follow up than those taking statins, but who were unfit.

Peter Kokkinos from the Veterans Affairs Medical Center, Washington DC, who led the research explained:

The fitness necessary to attain protection that is much the same or greater than that achieved by statin treatment in unfit individuals is moderate and feasible for many middle-aged and older adults through moderate intensity physical activity such as walking, gardening, and gym classes.

In the USA, approximately 71 million adults have elevated LDL-cholesterol according to Center for Disease Control. Dyslipidaemia is a key contributor to the incidence of coronary heart disease.

Kokkinos and colleagues assessed the records of over 10,000 veterans with dyslipidaemia from Veterans Affairs hospitals in Washington DC and Palo Alto, California, USA.

All participants were given a standard exercise tolerance test between the years 1986 and 2011 to determine their exercise capacity. Using a measure of the peak metabolic rate (MET) achieved while exercising, the researchers classified fitness level as least, moderate, fit, or high.

Patients were then divided into two groups (those treated with statins and not treated with statins) within each fitness category.

Death rates

The researchers found that death rates were lowest for those who were taking statins and were physically fit. The higher the level of fitness the lower the risk of dying during the median follow-up period of 10 years. The fittest participants, regardless of whether they were taking statins, had a significantly (60–70 per cent) lower risk of death.

The difference in death risk could not be explained by factors such as age, body mass, ethnicity, sex, history of cardiovascular disease, risk factors for cardiovascular disease, and medications.

In light of the findings Kokkinos recommends, “Individuals with dyslipidaemia should improve their fitness to at least a moderate level.”

“Treatment with statins is important, but better fitness improves survival significantly and is a valuable additional treatment or an alternative when statins cannot be taken,” he said.

Read: Global traumatic brain injury rates could be six times higher than thought – study>

Read: US suicide rates have risen sharply since economic crisis>

Read next:

Comments (16 Comments)

  • Breaking: you live longer if you look after yourself.

    Reply
  • Some people inherit cholesterol and no amount of diet and exercise will help.These people HAVE to take medication and it would be dangerous to advice them differently.

    Reply
  • Big Pharma promoting drugs again. Don’t eat crap and exercise should be the message here not take medication and exercise.

    Reply
    • Sometimes medication is necessary. The big pharmas are keeping half of +50′s fairly healthy. Would you prefer they didn’t?

      Reply
    • I’d agree James. The new drugs are doing great work for many people. But I think the essence of the article is the importance of exercise. Also, I suspect some rely simply on the tablets without changing their lifestyle.

      Reply
    • How do the group not taking statins get selected? Do they know, when given the choice, that they are more likely to die? “Patient number 1 – no exercise or statins for you. Good luck, and remember you will always be a statistic.”

      Reply
  • Statin CD cause muscel pain in many cases. So why not eat your porridge every morning, get out for a walk on a regular basis. Cut out the fatty cheese ect, drink more water ……sport and less stress in life could help too.

    Reply
  • Dublin Cyclists, not everyone who works in the city lives in the city. Some people have to travel an hour or more by car or train to get to work. Shops in Ireland are full of unhealthy convenience food, full of sugar, salt and fat. Many people don’t have the time and energy to seek alternatives which is frightening. The result is obesity, lethargy and worse.

    Reply
  • To clarify, what I meant by moderation was the proportionate eating of all natural whole foods in order to maintain a healthy balance of vitamins, minerals, carbohydrates, proteins, and fats within the body. Regardless of being natural or healthy, you can over consume any food to the point that it becomes unhealthy. This especially includes fruit due to fructose, but also to vegetables. If you think you can eat lots of corn, peas, potatoes and other starchy vegetables in particular and not gain weight your mistaken. I agree with you on some issues, particularly that meat CAN be processed, but simply saying that meat is ‘rubbish’ I find ridiculous. You can get free-range meats and eggs that have minimal processing involved, nitrate free meats, grass fed non-injected cattle, and so on. Also, I don’t consume milk or dairy, as it is processed, I agree with you there. And just because a turkey is plucked and cut up and frozen doesn’t mean that it is ‘processed’ in the terms that I mean them in, i.e. unhealthy additives such as chemicals are introduced during processing. Do you think that your vegetables and fruits come neatly packed and washed in small bags straight out of the ground? You said “It is a fact of life that people who consume the products you mentioned are far more likely to clog their veins”. Hmm, a fact of life, or bro science? Cholesterol doesn’t cause cardio-vascular diseases, inflammation of the arteries does, which then leads to trapping the cholesterol, forming plaque which clogs the arteries. The cholesterol is only there in the first place due to the inflammation as it used to repair inflamed cells, otherwise it would flow freely through the body and not cause problems. Inflammation is caused by eating processed foods. Also, if you would like to re-read what I wrote above where I wrote ” a massive growing body of medical research”. I did not cite a single source, dodgy or otherwise as you falsely claim, and I think it’s very short sighted of you to dismiss research as such when you haven’t sat down and read it. There are NUMEROUS studies that show that saturated fat consumption from natural sources do not lead to an increase in cardio-vascular disorders, in fact, a recent study in Sweden showed that eating eggs massively reduced inflammation of the arteries and led to a better cholesterol ratio in overweight men. If I may though, and if you care to educate yourself on the subject, I suggest you start with the following article. http://www.charlespoliquin.com/ArticlesMultimedia/Articles/Article/783/The_Truth_About_Heart_Disease_and_Cholesterol.aspx
    I don’t have a problem with what you say with regards to extra sport and eating healthy, I have a problem that you claim meats and other sources of natural cholesterol are rubbish and that one should be vegetarian or vegan to live longer. The real danger is processed foods, particularly grains and sugars. Being vegetarian you can still eat a lot of processed foods, and have high cholesterol levels coupled with high inflammation. The answer is natural, unprocessed foods, meats and eggs included

    Reply
  • The solution to most health problems is simple and consists of two things:

    1. Get more active. Walk or cycle to work or elsewhere instead of taking the car or bus. It’s far simpler and cheaper than going to the gym.
    2. Switch to a vegetarian/vegan diet or at least reduce meat, milk, butter, eggs etc consumption significantly. No cholesterol, no need to take silly pills to lower the cholesterol level. It’s as simple as that.

    Good luck!

    Reply
    • A balanced diet is perhaps the phrase you’re looking for? Having a vegan or vegetarian diet doesn’t mean healthier lifestyle, it means you don’t eat meat, or fish, or drink milk, or eat cheese. These are all critical components of a balanced diet, eat them – with moderation!

      Reply
    • Thanks for the response James. Needless to say that a balanced diet is better than supersize yourself to death.

      Nonetheless, I did mean vegetarian/vegan, as cholesterol occurs only in meat and other products originated from animals. The human body produces all the cholesterol it needs (in the right LDL/HDL ratio) and there’s no need to add more from other sources.
      There is nothing good in the products you mentioned that cannot be obtained from other natural sources.

      True, vegetarian and vegan diets don’t necessarily mean a healthier lifestyle by themselves (well, they do in regard to reduction of cholesterol consumption and in making people aware of what they put into their mouth). It comes in conjunction with the first paragraph.

      Reply
    • Sorry Dublin Cyclists I have to strongly disagree with you there. There is a massive growing body of evidence and research which all conclude that dietary cholesterol and saturated fat consumption from natural sources such as lean red meat, eggs, pork, bacon etc. contribute minimally to a higher incidence of blood cholesterol levels, and where they do increase the cholesterol levels, they only do so by a maximum of about 4%. These studies have taken place in America, Europe, Africa, the Middle East, Asia, lots of different cultures and eating habits. Your body is designed to process natural sources of foods such as eggs and animal fats. What are lethal are processed foods; cereals, pastas, certain breads, white rice etc. These will contribute far quicker to an unhealthy cardiovascular system and cholesterol ratio than will eating natural, whole foods. Interestingly, vegans tend to have the same life spans as overweight (not obese) meat eaters. The key as James said is moderation. Your body is designed to eat these foods. A paleo diet lifestyle, or a diet in that direction, will contribute more to a healthy body than will vegetarianism or veganism, and a massive growing body of medical research backs that up

      Reply
    • Thanks for your insight Darragh. But there are two things I fail to understand.

      1. You wrote that “dietary cholesterol and saturated fat consumption from natural sources such as lean red meat, eggs, pork, bacon etc. contribute minimally to a higher incidence of blood cholesterol levels, and where they do increase the cholesterol levels, they only do so by a maximum of about 4%”, but then you said the the key is moderation.

      Why is that then? If the body is adapted to such nutritious food sources, why go easy on them? The more the merrier. Or is it?
      It is a fact of life that people who consume the products you mentioned are far more likely to clog their veins. Vegetarians are far less likely to suffer from cardiovascular diseases. So why do you cite one dodgy study while hundred of others show the contrary?

      2. I totally agree about your words about processed food. That’s said, can you explain how food produced in the meat, dairy and egg industry isn’t processed? Your supposedly healthy chicken wasn’t born featherless in a Tesco freezer. The “welfare” of cattle is maintained by doses of antibiotics. Do you like your milk pasteurised or not? And we could continue with this topsy turvy line of thinking on and on, but I think the point is clear by now.

      In conclusion, sport more (cycling and walking are great as one needs to get from one place to another anyway), eat less rubbish (this include meat, but as we all agreed certainly not limited to that) and die later. C’est tout.

      Reply

Add New Comment