Welcome to our Public Beta Site - What does this mean?
Dublin: 18 °C Wednesday 23 May, 2012

Government may ‘take action’ against banks not passing on mortgage rate cut

Eamon Gilmore addresses the Dáil this morning
Eamon Gilmore addresses the Dáil this morning

THE GOVERNMENT IS looking at ways to force banks to pass on EU interest rate cuts to mortgage holders, after it emerged three of Ireland’s largest lenders would not be passing on the reductions.

Tánaiste Eamon Gilmore said the Government is “considering legislation” in the area, and could “take action” if the situation was not resolved.

“It is the intention of the Government that the interest rate reduction should be passed on,” he told the Dáil this morning.

Government ministers met with representatives of AIB, Bank of Ireland and Ulster Bank yesterday. AIB has announced that it will not be passing on the rate cut, and it is understood that Bank of Ireland and Ulster Bank are taking the same position.

Gilmore said the meeting was not a “polite conversation”. “We’ve told them [the banks] what our objective is,” he said. “If the banks do not reconsider the position they expressed yesterday, then on the basis of the assessment from the Financial Regulator we will take action as appropriate.”

The Financial Regulator is due to report to the Government on whether new powers are necessary to compel the banks to pass on the rate cuts.

Neither Bank of Ireland nor Ulster Bank have publicly confirmed that they will not be reducing their rates on variable mortgages. A spokesperson for Bank of Ireland told TheJournal.ie: “Our rates are constantly under review.”

In a statement, an Ulster Bank spokesperson said its mortgage rates are also under constant review, and relate to the cost of funding. “If the cost of funds goes down we would pass on those rates,” she said.

Read more: AIB will not pass ECB interest rate cut to customers>

Read more: AIB staff in line for promotions and salary rises>

Read Next:

Comments (40 Comments)

  • Arch Stanton 10/11/11 #
    Report this comment

    If you are with one of these banks, call em up and tell em you are moving your mortgage to a bank that is passing on the rate cut. They will soon change their tune.

    Reply
  • Silent P 10/11/11 #
    Report this comment

    Moving mortgages won’t be happening for anyone in negative equity and the banks know that. Try closing down your current accounts instead folks.

    Reply
  • Aine O'Connor 10/11/11 #
    Report this comment

    What are they gonna do, ring the b*stards endlessly on private number calls to ask them when they are getting their bailout money back? Or some nice letters maybe.
    Let’s all take a six month mortgage/car loan/ whatever holiday from December and we’ll chat afterwards.

    Reply
  • Heather Knowles 10/11/11 #
    Report this comment

    If banks won’t pass on the rate cuts then what on earth is the government doing using tax payers money to bail them out? Surely as there is so much state ownership like in any business the majority shareholders decision has to be adhered to? It should have been a legal stipulation of the bail out that any rate cuts must be passed on then this crap couldn’t happen. Disgraceful!

    Reply
  • Michael Hegarty 10/11/11 #
    Report this comment

    More flexing weak muscle from Gilmore.Eamonn Gilmore is a turncoat and a let down!!! He was great in opposition promising us all the sun, moon and stars. His main promise was to truly represent the man and woman on the ground. What did we get? A Yespp Man, doing as he is told by Enda and Phil, afraid to lift his head above the parapit. Super Eamonn is truly a weak weak man. I really feel let down by him!!!!!

    Reply
  • Oran Drumgoole 10/11/11 #
    Report this comment

    Government may take action?!

    Minister of finance (mof) – “please mr banker, do the right thing and pass on these interest rate cuts”
    Bankers – “•••• off ”
    MOF – I will publicly attack your character and threaten to bring in stiff penalties”
    Bankers – ” sure what do we care about what people think of us and sure charging us penalties is only charging the taxpayers as we will pass any penalty onto the customers”

    MOF issues public statement saying bankers are bad and he no likey them anymore! He is taking stern action against them and vows another public berating of our bankers in the future !

    Public like to hear bad things said about banks so they are satisfied that the bad bankers are been knocked into shape!!!!!

    Reply
  • Report this comment

    If we are going to bail them out more, then cut a certain amount of that bail out from the amount of money they would be making from not passing on the cut!

    They are a disgrace and CLEARLY give further reason why the public should not be bailing them out when they treat the same public like this!

    Shameful and disgraceful.

    Reply
  • hughsheehy 10/11/11 #
    Report this comment

    While mortgage holders deserve protection from abusive pricing, if the govt starts forcing banks to offer lower rates than sensible it’s the same as taxing non mortgage holders to give money to holders.

    Of course, Gilmore likes taxing people.

    Reply
  • Liam Byrne 10/11/11 #
    Report this comment

    We’ve heard these threats from the government before and nothing happened then either…

    Reply
  • Johnny Zillion 10/11/11 #
    Report this comment

    Why is the ESB still 1.5% higher than AIB?

    Reply
  • Garreth OMahony 10/11/11 #
    Report this comment

    It may make more sense in the long run to allow the bank to keep this rate decrease for themselves. If they are forced to give this decrease they will definitely rise the rate when the ecb does it the next time around.

    Reply
    • Kerry Blake 10/11/11 #
      Report this comment

      According to the European Commission today growth in the eurozone has nearly stalled. Forcast for next year is 0.5% growth. Think we can expect to see the ECB dropping it’s rates by a further 0.5% before the end of next March. There is no possibility that the ECB will increase rates in the short to medium turn unless some eurozone members are tossed out of the euro.

  • Ed Appleby 10/11/11 #
    Report this comment

    “The Government *is looking* at ways to force banks to pass on EU interest rate cuts to mortgage holders”. IS LOOKING are the two words that should alarm everybody here, in other words they have NO way of MAKING them pass on the rate cuts and will have to enact new legislation in order to do so. SO, don’t expect anything to happen and don’t expect the banks to back down because it is they who are running the country not the coalition who are morphing daily into the last FF/Green shambles, groundhog day is upon us and Kenny is turning into Cowen with Gilmore turning all Gormley like!

    Reply
  • John Murphy 10/11/11 #
    Report this comment

    Forget about the Government doing anything about Banks while the system of corporate donations to political parties (Labour included!) still goes on. How many backsides that have been fattened by bank donations sit in Leinster House?

    Reply
    • Report this comment

      Too many.

      They are trying to sound tough for the public and trying to appease the banks at the same time.
      Words from our governing politicians come cheap and fast sometimes – but end up costing the public a fortune!

      As the saying goes “The proof will be in the pudding”.
      If they are going to do anything about the banks – we WILL see.
      If they don’t – once again they expose their lies and uselessness.

    • John Murphy 10/11/11 #
      Report this comment

      @United The pudding is being eaten furiously as we speak. It has already being served to them with a nice dollop of cream by Brian Lenahan in Sept 2008. it’s getting a bit scarce now so they are giving themselves a pay rise at AIB. Christmas is coming and the poor dears want a bit of holly on it this time. Anyone….?

    • Rob Power 10/11/11 #
      Report this comment

      Lazy populist statement.

      If you know of a bank that has made a political donation to a party or party member why wouldn’t name names?

    • John Murphy 10/11/11 #
      Report this comment

      Well Fine Gael, for instance, has made no public declaration of donations for over a decade! So i guess I’m stumped….???

  • Adam Magari 10/11/11 #
    Report this comment

    Let me crystallise the tough official government response: we’ll get a committee of cronies together to write a report. Thank you all.

    Reply
  • Rob Power 10/11/11 #
    Report this comment

    This is the wrong step to take. We need confidence and investment in the banks. By controlling business decisions Government are preventing both. By all means bank customers should be protesting against this inaction and the media publicising it too.

    This type of government interference will only slow any possible rate of recovery.

    Reply
  • Tony Skillington 10/11/11 #
    Report this comment

    Seems to me the only people who have an even remote interest in standing up for the Irish people are the IMF…for Gilmore to even use the word ‘may’ says it all. Government ministers are whipped dogs who answer to their real masters voice..which should be us the people but are in fact banks..Irish, international and bondholders…if they’re this soft on the issue of rate cuts, what hope have we ever seeing the bankers who led us into this walking up the steps of a court house in handcuffs?
    I’m just happy I voted no to the politicians getting the powers they crave.

    Reply
  • Robert McDonnell 10/11/11 #
    Report this comment

    The state owns 92.8% of AIB. It shouldn’t be a situation whereby they ask AIB anything, AIB should just be told.

    The taxpayer is being unfairly treated by a bank that they own. It’s just nonsensical.

    Reply
    • Robert McDonnell 10/11/11 #
      Report this comment

      Unless of course there’s another agenda here. I think if the government weren’t benefiting somehow, that rate would be cut without question.

      Assuming that we have at least one pair of balls among the whole cabinet that is.

  • Jimmy Bolton Jnr 10/11/11 #
    Report this comment

    May take action? There should be no question that they will take action. It’s time to crack the whip with these banks. Shower of Bankers with a W!

    Reply
  • Anne-Marie Flynn 10/11/11 #
    Report this comment

    What about National Irish Bank, who are moving in the opposite direction and increasing its variable mortgage interest rates by almost 1%? Is the government going to “take action” on this?

    Reply
  • Siobhan 10/11/11 #
    Report this comment

    May take action? give me a flippin break. Grow a pair and talking crap

    Reply
  • Peter Carroll 10/11/11 #
    Report this comment

    This is manufactured indignation designed to take the spotlight off the Governments bad news on the upcoming tax increases and spending cuts.

    Consider the following:

    ECB discount rates have only a marginal effect on the Banks funding costs. The Irish owned Banks are in intensive care and NIB and Ulster Bank are outside the Eurozone.

    What is important to borrowers is the actual rate they have to pay, not whether or not it moves up or down in sync with ECB repo rates.

    Since The politicos started leaping up and down nobody has published comparative tables showing how mortgage rates charged by the different lenders compare.

    Less hysteria and more facts from Gilmore and Adams would be useful.

    Reply
  • Gis Bayertz 10/11/11 #
    Report this comment

    What banks are actually passing on the cut?

    Reply
  • Tony Skillington 10/11/11 #
    Report this comment

    Ebs are anyway…think Irish Permenant are

    Reply

Add New Comment