TheJournal.ie uses cookies. By continuing to browse this site you are agreeing to our use of cookies. Click here to find out more »
Dublin: 14 °C Monday 20 May, 2013

Reilly denies U-turn on personal assistant service cuts

The Minister for Health said he deplored the fact that people had to stay up all night protesting because of the fear of service cuts.

Image: Sam Boal/Photocall Ireland

MINISTER FOR HEALTH Dr James Reilly appeared on RTE’s Prime Time last night to answer his critics after the backlash that followed last week’s health cuts announcement.

Reilly said as far as he was concerned there was never a U-turn as there was “no decision to remove” personal assistance services for people with disabilities.

Despite comments from Taoiseach Enda Kenny yesterday commending the Health Minister for his reversal of cuts, Reilly said he had always made it clear that this would be an area of last resort.

The Minister said he “deplored the fact that people had to stay up all night in the cold because of the fear that they felt that their services were going to be withdrawn”.

Responding to comments that he had failed to respond to questions around cuts in a timely manner, Reilly said, “I tried my best and I didn’t succeed”.

Reilly said the government would do everything in their power to ensure services were maintained but would not guarantee that there would not be cuts in this area in the forthcoming  budget.

Read: People with disabilities continue their protest outside Leinster House despite U-turn>

Read next:

Comments (32 Comments)

  • Reilly looks like Father Jack at phase 4 of the hairy disease. And, of course, Brendan Grace

    Reply
  • Left hand, meet right hand.

    If they can’t sort out communication between Ministers then what hope have they?

    Reply
  • typical fine gael wasn’t a u turn was a complete roundabout. two faced gits don’t deserve to be our leaders.

    Reply
  • I Watched this last night in disgust. The man denied doing a U turn and denied what kenny publicly said. This man is more of a fool than he thinks we are. He could not answer one question out right and dance around answers that were not even being asked, just to waste air time.

    Reply
  • Goes to show what can be achieved by protesting against the government. The pensioners got what they wanted too.

    Reply
    • Mark – its not that we got what we wanted. We got what we need in order to survive living day to day – PAs do tasks for us that everyone else takes for granted. Think for a moment how, without the use of your arms or legs you would get up in the morning, shower, shave, dress, eat breakfast, get to work…how in work you would be able to shift papers and files, answer the phone…even though you are as intelligent as your work colleagues. Think for a moment how, without the use of your arms or legs you would get home from work. Some of us have families and need assistance preparing meals, etc. Some people have speech problems caused by their disabilities and need a PA to act as their interpreter for doctor visits or hospital visits. Imagine being worried about a medical problem but not being able to communicate symptoms to your doctor? All of these things are hurdles we, as PA users, have to face every day from the moment we wake up. So everyone, we did not get what we wanted – we took back what we need to survive on a somewhat level playing field to every other tax paying citizen in this country. Why should we be treated as sub-human or second class citizens?

      Reply
    • Wrong choice of word then. But you protested because you did not want the cuts to happen and the cuts didnt happen so you got what you wanted did you not? I know full well how people need personal assistance to get by in every day life, i was just making the point that if people who claim they want or need different things protested like the pensioners did instead of sitting back and letting it happen we might not have as much to complain about!

      Reply
  • I must have been dreaming then, or perhaps it’s his hypnotic stare…

    Reply
  • This is just more manufactured distraction from the overall important issues. A few million here, a few million there, when the real issue of 1000s of millions being ripped out of the country is never addressed.

    Reply
  • He looks very unhealthy for a gp don’t you think.

    Reply
  • louise 07/09/12 #

    Lies lies lies

    Reply
  • How about cutting the councillors wages ? That is the ones who live here. Sure they get enough from developers etc to survive with their council money, look at Olivia Mitchell in your own party for some hints on cost savings in that area. All greedy guts.

    Reply
    • Dont mind councillors , tear up that morally repugnant gravy charter that is “croke park” . I call on all the anti-house hold charge folks and “social activists”to examine real social unjustice in this country and it will take them directly to croke park stadium . We wouldn’t be discussing savage cuts to health services if this shower of cowards in goverment grew a pair !

      http://www.irishtimes.com/newspaper/opinion/2012/0907/1224323695579.html

      Reply
    • You got to love the red thumbing gravy train residents . Scurilous Hypocits . I won’t pay this , I wont pay that , blame the banks , blame the bondholders, which are all great points if they were the sole reason the county is in a hole . No , sadly ,The most pressing resaon that our health service is about to be decimated further is we spend way more than we take in , Simple so far ? and guess what, a hell of lot of it goes on high wages in public sector ( I know not all of you are on fat cats salaries , so spare me the stories of “ I earn 20 cent a month , rubbish , get your unions to break the link with the fact cat guys that use you as a shield) . Besides the CSO just published the facts about how much more Pub is paid than Private on average depsite tenure and all the other trimmings . So , bring on more red thumbs , let the old guy die ‘casue a ward must be closed or he couldn’t get the treatment he needed at home , lets cut back on mental health services , sure their mad who cares . No , your pay is important , you need to make a stand against the tryanical “man” lest we join the race to the bottom . And besides our Public adminstartors are worth a least 40% more than their european couterparts so what if country is broke , sure, not to worry we can stay borrowing away ,the ECB is going to start buying our bonds , we’ll get a great deal on the interest .

      Reply
  • “Reilly said the government would do everything in their power to ensure services were maintained”
    .
    I think it’s fairly obvious by now they have NO POWER,

    Reply
  • A liar as well as a spoofer!…go now James Reilly

    Reply
  • He really needs to go. He’s not up to the job and makes Biffo look like a communications maestro.

    Reply
  • He’s releasing a statement later denying he’s the minister for health

    Reply
  • And when they replace Reilly, everyone will whinge about his replacement until they in turn get replaced, whereupon people will whinge about that replacement and so on, until people realise that there are no easy solutions. We are broke…

    Reply
  • Anyone agree that the Minister for Health looks unhealthy? Overweight, spotty, florid, bilious, stuffed, ‘fat cattish’?

    Reply
  • “I tried my best and I didn’t succeed”. So there is worse to come?

    Reply
  • Two problems we have with politics in this country, an inability to say sorry for mistakes that are made. If I hear another politician regretting something or apologising for upsetting people I’ll go mad. Another problem is when politicians go back on something after taking on the concerns of the public, they’re accoused by the media and opposition of doing a u turn. I’m by no means defending our minister for health but it’s bad for politics.

    Reply
  • Stadler,
    The deception perpetrated is nothing to do with being broke financially. I think the civil servants set up these foolish politicians.

    Reply

Add New Comment