TheJournal.ie uses cookies. By continuing to browse this site you are agreeing to our use of cookies. Click here to find out more »
Dublin: 3 °C Saturday 25 May, 2013

Final report on Magdalene Laundries delayed to year-end

The committee chairperson Martin McAleese said that extra information has to be examined which could add “in a meaningful way” to the overall outcome.

Martin McAleese
Martin McAleese
Image: Photocall Ireland!

THE FINAL REPORT into the State’s involvement with the Magdalene Laundries is to be completed by the end of this year.

Senator Martin McAleese, who chairs the Inter-Departmental Committee set up to probe what happened in the infamous institutions between the 1920s and 1990s, has told the Minister for Justice that “excellent progress” had been made despite “considerable challenges”.

The committee was established to establish the facts of State involvement with the Magdalene Laundries, to clarify any State interaction and to produce a narrative detailing such interaction.

An initial report, released on 25 October last year, set out a schedule for the final report and it was hoped it would be completed by mid-2012. However, relevant records and a significant level of information and documentation continues to be identified, according to McAleese. Submissions from representative and advocacy groups are also still being received.

McAleese said that such information “has the capacity to add in a meaningful way to the overall outcome of the committee’s work” and that it would be “improper to conclude its work without examining the additional material”.

The Committee has said it intends to present a substantial Final Report as soon as possible and before the end of this year, at the latest.

Ten institutions are covered by the inquiry, a number of which are said to be cooperating fully with the process.

It is now over a year since the United Nations Committee Against Torture (UNCAT) recommended an independent inquiry and redress for former residents of the Magdalene Laundries.

The inter-departmental committee was set up on foot of this recommendation. UNCAT stated it was “gravely concerned” at the failure of the State to protect girls and women who were involuntarily confined between 1922 and 1996.

An independent inquiry will be considered after the publication of the inter-departmental committee’s final report. The Government has committed to making the final report public.

Justice for Magdelenes (JFM), the survivor advocacy group, said it is “shocked and disappointed” by today’s announcement and has called on the Government to act immediately, stating that further delay is unacceptable.

The organisation said that survivors, who are mostly ageing and vulnerable, have already waited “too long” for an apology, redress and restorative justice in the form of a reparation scheme for women incarcerated.

JFM said the survivors cooperated with the committee trusting that it would deliver “in a timely fashion”. The group said its submission alone constitutes “overwhelming and irrefutable evidence” of State complicity in the abuses that were experienced at the institutions. Redacted copies of this submission will be made available to TDs and Senators.

In a statement issued this afternoon, JFM said, “Survivors’ entitlements can no longer be held hostage to the vagaries of the political system’s inability to deliver on its promises.”
Australia and the UK have both recently moved forward with official apologies to victims of forced, illegal adoptions and the migrant child scheme. Will Ireland ever do the same?  Will the all too familiar policy of ‘deny til they die’, become ‘delay til they die’?

“Three years into this campaign, 22 months after the IHRC recommendation, 15 months after the United Nation’s Committee Against Torture recommendation, by refusing to apologise and provide redress, Ireland’s government is failing some of the most vulnerable in our society. For this we should all feel shame.”

June: Senator McAleese meets with Magdalene survivors>

July: Archbishop suggests investigation into Magdalene Laundries>

Read next:

Comments (14 Comments)

  • This report will yet again expose Official Ireland for what it is. The Catholic Church and the State colluding to establish a modern day slave labour force that got consistently abused and beaten, all under the protection of the Gardai and the ignorance of RTE who utterly failed in their duty to report this despite no lack of evidence coming from the victims of these heinous crimes.

    Will we see any arrests ? I somehow doubt we are going to see the Gardai arresting bishops, priests, nuns or former politicians all of whom are guilty as sin. The usual Official Ireland response of ‘wasn’t it terrible, terrible it was’ will soon be forthcoming in place of justice for the the lives they have ruined.

    One bit of solace I do take is that Martin McAlesse is writing the report- I expect a man of his stature to hold back on nothing.

    Reply
    • Michelle 11/09/12 #

      Can’t wait to see all the politicians, legal heads etc wringing their hands and stating ” nobody knew what was going on”!
      All hidden behind their backs, terrible really. Pity nobody spoke up!

      Reply
    • Don’t understand your criticism of RTE. remember if it hadn’t been for the “States of Fear” documentary by the late Mary Raftery on RTE, we wouldn’t have seen the the Church and the State being finally forced to face up to the abuse of children in their care! This was public service broadcasting at its best.

      Reply
  • What are the circumstances of the modern day equivalent of the residents of the Magdalen Homes and are these girls safe and protected.

    Reply
  • When are people going to get angry in country? State and RCC collusion. The rap sheet grows longer . These crimes are classified as crimes against humanity. Innocent young girls incarcerated against their will , forced into slave labour their children stolen and sold ( human trafficking) . Beatings and sexual abuse was also prolific. Anyone who supports the RCC supports an organisation which has committed the most heinous crimes against the citizens and children of this state. They must pay. There must be retribution , justice must be served . How long must we remain like sheep?

    Reply
  • Justice delayed is justice denied.

    Reply
  • Let’s hope this report is fully open and transparent . Those who new about this horrendous crime must be made to feel the full weight of the law. Comments please.

    Reply
  • How dare anybody criticise this great nation of ours. we stood alone to defeat the evils of the empire. We can enslave whoever we like whenever we like. We stand alone – Sinn Féin. The others can and will apologise to us we apologise to nobody; we are the land of saints and scholars. The Aryan race cannot and will not compete with us.

    Reply
    • Just in response to people criticising this great nation,I’m confused by your comments. While there are many great things about Ireland,the actions of the various groups such as the church,politicians and Gardai are completely open to criticism and we would be far from a great nation if they aren’t held responsible for their action. don’t know the the aryan race has to do with it

      Reply
  • The initial letter of the first ‘we’ should, of course, be in the upper case.

    Reply
    • ‘We can enslave whoever we want whenever we want’- Are you condoning the laundries with this comment?! It requires explanation because it seems to be an inconsiderate statement negating the suffering that occurred. It’s a small person who feels like they have to own another

      Reply

Add New Comment