TheJournal.ie uses cookies. By continuing to browse this site you are agreeing to our use of cookies. Click here to find out more »
Dublin: 12 °C Wednesday 19 June, 2013

Not enough radiotherapy machines to meet Ireland’s cancer needs – study

The Lancet study showed that there is a 4 per cent unmet need in Ireland.

File
File
Image: Johnny Green/PA Archive/Press Association Images

A NEW STUDY shows that there are “wide disparities” in access to radiotherapy services around Europe.

The Lancet Oncology analysis shows the reality of radiotherapy services in 33 countries across Europe, and shows that in several western European countries there are too few radiotherapy machines to ensure that cancer patients in need of radiotherapy receive treatment.

In Ireland, there are 10 radiotherapy centres, with 26 machines, so 2.6 machines on average per centre. That makes 5.8 machines per million people. There are approximately 19,300 people with cancer and 12,063 radiotherapy treatments retreatments needed.

The researchers say the figures equate to a 4 per cent unmet need in Ireland.

In Italy around 16 per cent  of need is unmet, in Portugal 19 per cent, Austria 20 per cent, and the UK and Germany 21 per cent. However, the authors say that these apparent gaps in treatment supply may be compensated by more efficient organisation of radiotherapy provision.

Variation

Availability of radiotherapy services varies widely between countries and regions within Europe. For example, Nordic countries, Belgium, the Netherlands, and Switzerland are well-equipped with radiotherapy machines to meet the demand for treatment. In comparison, most countries in eastern and southeastern Europe are insufficiently equipped and have the greatest need to expand and modernise their equipment.

On average, the study found that countries have 5.3 teletherapy (the most common form of radiotherapy) machines per million people, but the number ranged from fewer than two per million (Macedonia and Romania) to more than eight per million(Denmark, Switzerland, Belgium). Overall, 10 countries were found to have an insufficient number of machines to meet estimated need, said the study, including Ireland.

Fragmentation of radiotherapy services exists in 28 of the 33 countries studied, the research shows, with Sweden, the UK, the Netherlands, Denmark, and Slovenia having a more centralised set-up, operating a high number (between four and ten) of machines in each centre.

The authors comment:

The fragmentation in radiotherapy services that prevails in many European countries might affect the economic burden of radiotherapy and its quality.

But they emphasised that although their results do not prove whether differences in equipment and organisation have an effect on cancer outcome, “they do warrant further investigation into how to optimise the efficiency of radiotherapy services”.

Currently, 3.2 million Europeans are diagnosed with cancer every year, with roughly half of those requiring radiotherapy at some point.

The researchers say that this new data should enable governments, European Union bodies, and international organisations to see at a glance how adequate the provision of radiotherapy is in each European country.

Read: Radiotherapy may increase diabetes risk for some childhood cancer survivors>

  • Share on Facebook
  • Email this article
  •  

Read next:

Comments (18 Comments)

  • Just an idea, but could the machines be used on a 24 hour basis?

    Reply
    • Mjhint 24/01/13 #

      Good idea if this is a solution. Getting the maximum productivity from the machines.

      Reply
    • I remember my GP being dumbfounded as to why they weren’t being used around the clock when I received by treatment a few years ago.
      His reasoning was if multi million euro machines were in a privately owned company there is no way they would be allowed to sit idle for half the day.
      I also remember having to go home or wait on occasion because a machine had broken down , was being serviced or was needed by another patient.
      Couldn’t fault the staff in the hospital though.

      Reply
    • Reality check : getting patients out of bed at two in the morning for radio? Would you travel at 3 in the morning from kilkenny or cavan for treatment. Higher risk of error in a treatment that requires precision. Would sleepless nights be best practice for already fatigued and immuno suppressed patients?

      Reply
    • If I believed I would receive treatment immediately when I got there, absolutely I would travel at any time , day or night.
      I’m sure that there are many precision machines being operated 24 hours a day which are privately owned.
      At the moment patients aren’t being given a choice.
      You wait and you get your treatment when it suits.

      Reply
    • Keith
      I think there’s only one machine currently in a private hospital and it doesn’t work different hours to the Public Hospitals.

      Reply
    • Yes… If my co-pay for treatment was €600 at 3pm or €300 at 3am I would get radiotherapy at 3am

      Reply
    • It’s a staff issue. To have the machines in use 24 hours, you would need full teams working 24 hours, not just consultants, but technicians, nurses, porters. The waiting lists for MRI machines in Public Hospitals are also staggering for the same reason. And the money to pay staff for this is not made available in the current system.

      Reply
  • Fools . . Why should we have cake sales . To prop up the health service . Don’t we pay enough in tax . Your idea is let the morons do what thy like . While we collect milk bottle tops and jam jars . To pay for services . And gilmore and wife take home about. 8k- a week . I hope you feel good when you get your average wage known that our leaders are ok while people in hospitals go with out

    Reply
  • Raise cash to pay for additional machines. Surely this is what one of the highest tax rates in Europe that we pay should be used for, rather than to pay the scandalously high salaries that our politicians are being paid.

    Reply
  • How many could have been bought instead of The Spire?

    Reply
  • I bet we’ve enough money set aside, to pay the obese wages/pensions and perks of politicians! While they give their friends and families comfy jobs, people go without!

    Reply
  • Try removing the fluoride from the water!!!

    Reply

Add New Comment