Welcome to our Public Beta Site - What does this mean?
Dublin: 13 °C Thursday 24 May, 2012

Opposition TDs propose laws to ban hare coursing

Image: James Horan/Photocall Ireland

Updated, 12.35

TWO TDS from the Technical Group have confirmed their intention to introduce new laws later this year which would conclusively ban hare coursing in Ireland.

Dublin Central independent Maureen O’Sullivan, and Socialist Party TD for Dublin North Clare Daly, are to propose legislation which they say will protect animals from cruelty in sports, as well as addressing other animal rights problems.

The commitment to issue the legislation comes after the TDs accused the government of failing to indicate whether hare coursing would be included in an Animal Health Bill coming later this year.

“We wish to address this directly in the Bill we are pushing, as we are concerned that hare coursing will once again be exempted along with other animal rights abuses,” the TDs said in a statement.

Hare coursing is the pursuit of hares with hounds who chase the hares based on sight (rather than scent). The sport is a competitive one for dogs, which are tested on their ability to outsprint each other.

The winning hound is the one which is able to come so close to the hare as to divert it from the line it was already taking to try and escape.

Though it is not strictly intended for the hare to be captured at the conclusion, animal rights campaigners say the sport can regularly end with injuries to the hares – and to the dogs chasing them.

“The mistreatment to hares extends to the techniques used to collect hares from the wild, training them to run in straight lines on the track, use of weak hares and through the practice of ‘blooding’ which although illegal, still continues today,” the TDs said.

The Campaign for the Abolition of Cruel Sports has campaigned for the abolition of coursing or for it to be replaced with ‘drag coursing’, which involves a mechanical lure.

A permanent ban on the sport in Northern Ireland came into effect in August of last year.

Read Next:

Comments (79 Comments)

  • D F 30/01/12 #
    Report this comment

    Ireland is in a mess and these jokers are hopeless , most of us don’t care about this , why can’t these paid public reps work on something that more than a handful of people care about ! Like will we have an income next year , next month or next week !

    Reply
    • Michael Sullivan 30/01/12 #
      Report this comment

      If this saves any animal from a needless cruel and painful death, then I am in favour of it.

    • Barry 30/01/12 #
      Report this comment

      Most of us don’t care?
      How nice of you to speak for the majority of Ireland,

      Thankfully the people of Ireland do care about animals going through a pointless, cruel and painful death

  • Bernadette Dunne 30/01/12 #
    Report this comment

    Would it better to introduce a proper animal welfare bill for protection of ALL ANIMALS and introduce proper legislation

    Reply
  • Brian Ward 30/01/12 #
    Report this comment

    Townies versus Culchies. As a Culchie I say Feck Off!

    Reply
  • Report this comment

    Thank goodness. This “sport” is cruel and should be banned. Trouble is, it would go underground because the men who enjoy this and make money on it won’t want to see the end of their little enterprise. What’s the life of a hare compared to a few jars in the pub? Sickos

    Reply
  • Mola Rockstheweb 30/01/12 #
    Report this comment

    You may not care about the torture of animals for ‘sport’, but a lot of other people DO care, and have been campaigning to have it banned for a lot longer than the current economic circumstance.

    Reply
  • John 30/01/12 #
    Report this comment

    Minor point to the author – the dogs are not tested on their ability to outsprint the hare, they are tested on their ability to out sprint each other, the first dog to deviate the hare from the line in which it was running being deemed the winner and going through to the next round.

    Reply
  • john byrnes 30/01/12 #
    Report this comment

    look i have greyhounds i go coursing and i can guarantee people who protest against it have nevd

    Reply
    • john byrnes 30/01/12 #
      Report this comment

      never been coursing nd live in the city

    • Cecily J. Hoare 30/01/12 #
      Report this comment

      So, let’s see: if you have never been coursing and you live in the city, you should not have an opinion on a “sport” that involves the tearing asunder of an animal? Cop yourself on.

    • John 30/01/12 #
      Report this comment

      @Cecily, please can you explain how the sport involves ‘the tearing asunder of an animal’? Statements like that are proof positive of John’s point – you’re talking about something you have no knowledge of.

    • Cecily J. Hoare 30/01/12 #
      Report this comment

      Well, John, is it a bloodsport or not?

    • John 30/01/12 #
      Report this comment

      It’s a bloodsport in the same way as boxing, hunting, horse racing, dog racing (on a track), equine polo etc. etc. are. Now you answer my question.

    • Peter Carroll 30/01/12 #
      Report this comment

      Cecily, you will notice that the dogs in the picture are muzzled. After the course the hare will be captured and returned to it’s breeding grounds, probably an island off the west coast. If the sport is cruel, it is in frightening the hare, not in killing it. Having said that, the hare has evolved to outsmart and outrun foxes and wolves.

    • Barry 30/01/12 #
      Report this comment

      I don’t like dogs being stuck into bags and dumped into rivers to drawn them, I’ve never done it but I am against it.
      Just because I haven’t done something doesn’t mean I don’t have a view on it.

      I’ve seen people put animals into bags and throw them into rivers, infact one of my dogs when I was a kid was rescued from one of those bags by a family member. Only very sick people get a kick out of a animals death, your not even going to eat the hare so its completely pointless.

      Your logic of (not done it so can’t have a view on it) is massively flawed

  • john byrnes 30/01/12 #
    Report this comment

    how can u comment on something and have never been at it

    Reply
  • Anthony Ryan 30/01/12 #
    Report this comment

    You can go to the National Coursing Meeting in Clonmel which will attract over 20,000 people and I can almost guarantee you will not see a single hare “torn asunder”

    Reply
  • John 30/01/12 #
    Report this comment

    @Barbara, the sport is not male only. Have been to a few events. Its a great family day out. Try it sometime. Actually, don’t, you might enjoy it…..

    Reply
    • Barry 30/01/12 #
      Report this comment

      Bull fighting is also a great family day out for many a spanish family (and they will also claim this), however its a very barbaric event to watch. Needless death.

    • Ian Walsh 31/01/12 #
      Report this comment

      @ Barry You have zero experience of coursing. You may be entitled to an opinion, but at least be informed and make an informed opinion. The hare rarely dies. Fact.

  • Paul O'Keeffe 30/01/12 #
    Report this comment

    This ‘sport’ is barbaric. Its hard to believe it is still legal. I am from the countryside and I can assure you its not a city versus country thing. Not all of us ‘culchies’ relish in the torture of small defenceless animals. Coursing is completely abhorrent.

    Reply
  • Killian Maher 30/01/12 #
    Report this comment

    As a side issue indications are that areas where coursing happens tend to have significantly higher populations of hares, it is believed this is as the land is kept for the Hare’s specifically.

    Many hedgerow aimed EU incentives are actually bad for Hares as preserving hedgerows increases the predator and competition populations. Hares naturally like open spaces ie. mid fields. In coursing areas they dont harvest the fields during the Hare breeding season as the Hare’s reaction to unknown danger when in cover (ie long grass) is to be very still…. doesn’t work very well when the predator is in fact a combine harvestor.

    For anyone with a university IP have a read-

    Reid, N., Montgomery , W.I. & McDonald, R.A. (2007) Mammals and agri-environment schemes: hare haven or pest paradise? Journal of Applied Ecology, 44(6), 1200-1208

    Reid, N., Montgomery, W.I. & McDonald, R.A. (2007) Temporal trends in the Irish hare population . Report prepared by Quercus for the Environment and Heritage Service (DOE, N.I.).

    Reid, N., McDonald, R.A. & Montgomery, W.I. (2007) Factors associated with hare mortality during coursing. Animal Welfare, 16(4); 427-434.

    Reply
  • john byrnes 30/01/12 #
    Report this comment

    they can get tore to shreds they hav muzzles on just shows u dnt no about it

    Reply
  • john byrnes 30/01/12 #
    Report this comment

    look just go to 1 nd comeback and talk to me about ten cos u no nothing bot it only wat people tell u

    Reply
  • Tigerisinthezoo 30/01/12 #
    Report this comment

    In fairness the sport is a lot safer for the hares than it used to be. The dogs are muzzled. V few hares are killed or hurt. They still can be as the dogs will use their claws.
    Will we be banned from killing flies soon or what about the poor fish who gets a hook in his mouth?
    It would be a pity if it was banned.

    Reply
    • John Fitzgerald 04/02/12 #
      Report this comment

      To Tigerisinthezoo…

      The facts are against you on this: Hares are subjected to appalling injuries and many also die literally of fright. A “pity” if it were banned? Maybe for the hare-catching gangs, the gamblers, the “sporting” folk who train dogs by feeding them live hares with their back legs broken, and the high fliers who get massive salaries for keeping the coursing clubs on the road. For the hare it would be a great blessing.

  • john byrnes 30/01/12 #
    Report this comment

    yes it is but its like fox hunting tey dnt get caught tat often

    Reply
    • John Murphy 30/01/12 #
      Report this comment

      You have a point there John. In my local area the mounted fox hunt might kill an average of 10 – 20 rather unhealthy foxes in the season while the local gun club might ‘eradicate’ the same amount in two or three outings.
      The difference here though is the hare is not considered a marauding pest, the fox is.

  • Report this comment

    I nevee been hare coarsing i know little about but i would rather listen to the opinions of the people involved than those involved in the animal rights camp. Most of these people believe we shouldnt eat animals & some of them have been engaged in terrorising members of the farming community & live exporters both of these groups involved in legitimate trade. In my view hare coarsing maybe cruel in some respects but overall its a popular sport.

    Reply
  • Andrew Lyons 30/01/12 #
    Report this comment

    Ban intensive chicken farms before you ban this, I know I would rather have the life of one of these hares then a chicken that is harvested as if it never existed!

    Reply
  • Tom McDermott 30/01/12 #
    Report this comment
    Reply
  • John Murphy 30/01/12 #
    Report this comment

    I have never been to a hare coursing meeting either though I have found that most objectors to blood sports are generally misinformed. The objectors to these activities fall by and large into two camps – those who object on the grounds of cruelty, and those who are concerned about wildlife conservation.
    The cruelty issue is somewhat subjective in nature and is often driven more by perceptions rather than hard facts, whereas the conservation issue is more objective and can be born out by surveys and studys.
    It is well documented that the brown hare population has dramatically fallen nationwide in the last 50yrs and many factors have been blamed for this including coursing and changing agricultural practices.
    It is often argued that in areas where ‘country sports’, or ‘blood sports’ if you prefer, are prevalent the quarry species concerned are more numerous through management of the population and the natural environment.
    I attach a link to a report of a study carried out by Queen’s University Belfast that bears this out:
    http://www.irishexaminer.com/opinion/columnists/donal-hickey/hares-more-plentiful-in-coursing-areas-115103.html

    Reply
  • Adam Long 30/01/12 #
    Report this comment

    This is welcome. Ireland really needs to get serious about animal welfare issues across the board, including when it comes to blood “sports” which have no place in a civilised society.

    The organised opposition to even basic standards of animal welfare in this country is quite incredible, made all the worse by these self appointed guardians of the countryside claiming they represent rural people, which is completely disingenuous.

    So well done to these two TDs for putting animal welfare on the agenda, especially Maureen O’Sullivan who is carrying on the late Tony Gregory’s great work in this area.

    Reply
    • Report this comment

      Everyone on this article talking about animal welfare are suffering from lack of information. We cant take care of our citizens in this country alot of them are leaving. I think that hare is lucky hes making a living. All the quotes from the alf jesus these people are terrorists. Look after the welfare of our citizens & we’ll come back to this when its important.

  • Adam Long 30/01/12 #
    Report this comment

    Government is capable of dealing with more than one issue at a time. It’s not an “either” “or” situation. And animal welfare issues have already been neglected in this country for far too long.

    Reply
  • Iain Murray 30/01/12 #
    Report this comment

    So I can see that hare coursing is the “hot topic” with regards to this legislation, but does anyone know what effect it might have on other sports such as falconry, shooting, fishing etc? Attacking what’s left of these sports will destroy yet another rural industry.

    Reply
    • Niamh King 30/01/12 #
      Report this comment

      I wonder if people would argue as much over horse racing and show jumping?

    • John Murphy 30/01/12 #
      Report this comment

      Niamh.
      I don’t follow horse racing but I have competed in showjumping and have trained and schooled horses. One thing you will find is that horses actually enjoy racing and jumping much the same as a certain breed of hunting dog enjoys hunting and chasing other animals. Hundreds of years of selective breeding has ensured this.
      Animal welfare is not just a ‘feed me love me’ concept. These animals are bred for their roles and it is in fact cruel to keep these animals from the activities that their physiology and temperament through years of selective breeding has suited them to.
      For instance, try making a contented, well trained household pet of a prize greyhound, or try making a gentle all purpose riding horse of a champion racer.
      Laws being made or supported by uninformed people in the interest of animal welfare are in many cases misguided and real cases of negligence get ignored.

  • Aron Glynn 30/01/12 #
    Report this comment

    Seems anything that is enjoyable is stopped… Just because there are small minorities who are against it they make themselves heard and get it stopped.. It’s an animal that is been
    Killed.. So what! U eat Cow,pig,chicken, even ones that are young because it tastes better.. Double standards in society is an absolute joke.. Give it ten years ya will not be allowed do anything without been accused of some wrong doing…

    Reply
  • Sam Rhodes 30/01/12 #
    Report this comment

    The Irish hare is listed in the Irish Red Data Book as internationally important and in Apppendix 2 of the Bern Convention as a protected species.

    They are in decline and they are protected yet it’s okay to literally scare them to death for fun? Find something your own size to chase.

    Reply
    • A Ryan 30/01/12 #
      Report this comment

      Yet the hare population is far higher in areas where there are active coursing clubs due to the conservation measures under taken by the members of the coursing club. What conservation measures have the likes of ISCABs been undertaking? There will be 20,000 people in Clonmel on Wednesday, outside the gate there will about 15 people protesting. These animal rights nuts get far more airtime than their numbers deserve.

  • John Fitzgerald 30/01/12 #
    Report this comment

    The number of hares affected by coursing isn’t the issue…any more than dog fighting was banned on the basis of the percentage of Ireland’s dog population used, or cockfighting was banned because it posed any threat to the rooster population.

    It’s the completely unnnecessary cruelty involved. The dogs though muzzled can maul the hares, tossed them about like playthings. pin them to the ground, or otherwise injure them. The hare is a brittle-boned creature and internal injuries cannot heal. The there is Capture Myopathy,a stress-related condition that kills hares even AFTER coursing has concluded.

    Rangers from the NPWS attend some coursing events and their reports on last season’s events, obtained under FOI, reveal that hares were injured or made suffer horribly at most of these these.

    There’s a humane and perfectly reasonable alternative to the use of hares in coursing: Drag coursing has all the fun, action, excitement, and camaraderie the live hare coursing lobby so often talk about…but minus the cruelty. It took off well in Australia when live hare coursing was banned there. There is need or any justification for taking hares from their natural home in the countryside and setting them up to be terrorized and traumatised as live bait.

    Fair play to Clare Daly and Maureen O’ Sullivan for propelling this issue back onto the political aganda. I was at the protest today and was delighted to see also Eamon Ryan, the Green Party leader, and, perhaps most significantly, Labour’s Joe Costello. Other Labour TDs sent their good wishes.

    Reply
    • John Murphy 30/01/12 #
      Report this comment

      John.
      An interesting comment. If the matter is debated in the objective way you’ve set out I’m all for it. The welfare of both the hunter and quarry species has to be taken into account in this debate.

    • Adam Long 30/01/12 #
      Report this comment

      Great points John and well done on today’s protest.

  • Mola Rockstheweb 30/01/12 #
    Report this comment

    The greatness of a nation can be judged by the way its animals are treated. – Mahatma Gandhi. If you decide to treat animals like they aren’t sentient beings capable of feeling fear and other emotions then it becomes a quick hop to doing exactly the same to people you decide aren’t ‘worth’ as much. Which is exactly what we have been doing, we’ve never protected the weak and vulnerable hence 1in4 and the countless thousands consigned to a life (time) in asylums. We are starting to make a change but it won’t work if we become eliteist about whom we believe are the most vulnerabe.

    Reply
  • Kevin Maybury 30/01/12 #
    Report this comment

    if being chased by dogs stresses hares out to the point that the anxiety kills them how have they managed to survive in the wild its not as if wild dogs or wolves look at hares and think better not chase it incase i scare the poor thing is it

    Reply
  • Michael E Burke 31/01/12 #
    Report this comment

    “Non-violence leads to the highest ethics, which is the goal of all evolution. Until we stop harming all other living beings, we are still savages.”—Thomas A. Edison

    In my opinion those who find gratification from attending these ‘sports’, be they men, women or children are beneath contempt!

    Reply
    • Michael E Burke 31/01/12 #
      Report this comment

      To those giving the ‘thumbs down’,

      “’Thou shalt not kill’ does not apply to murder of one’s own kind only, but to all living beings; and this Commandment was inscribed in the human breast long before it was proclaimed from Sinai.”

      AND furthermore

      “Flesh eating is simply immoral, as it involves the performance of an act, which is contrary to moral feeling: killing. By killing, man suppresses in himself, unnecessarily, the highest spiritual capacity, that of sympathy and pity towards living creatures like himself and by violating his own feelings becomes cruel.”

      both quotes from Count Leo Tolstoy

  • Report this comment

    Michael i would love you to get in the water with a great white & explain that to it. Eating meat is no less immoral than eating fruit or veg. Our bodies are designed for such activities. Eating other humans is definately questionable but it has happened. Contrary to popular held views we are just another species of animal. We kill other people for worse things than eating them so im not
    convinced by your argument.

    Reply
  • Patrick Donnelly 15/03/12 #
    Report this comment

    The point is : coursing dogs are muzzled, cant see how they tear a hare apart. Are not Hares more plentiful in places where Coursing takes place?.

    Reply
  • Patrick Donnelly 15/03/12 #
    Report this comment

    Now the Fox is a hunter of hares, day and night, im thinking he kills hares, or maybe he just kills rabbits. What about the transport on our roads, do they kill hares?.
    But would some one tell me why is it that coursing men/women and children go out and stop the poaching of hares?.
    Some of ye would want to open your eyes, go to a Coursing Meeting and don’t be listening to old stories.

    Reply

Add New Comment