TheJournal.ie uses cookies. By continuing to browse this site you are agreeing to our use of cookies. Click here to find out more »
Dublin: 18 °C Wednesday 19 June, 2013

17 terminations of pregnancy as a result of rape in 2011

Rape Crisis Network Ireland said that two out of 90 survivors became pregnant more than once as a result in rape and had different outcomes each time.

Image: Shutte/MitarArt

NINETY GIRLS AND women became pregnant as a result of rape in 2011, the Rape Crisis Network has revealed.

It has released new findings on survivors who became pregnant as a result of rape. The figures show that 90 girls and women became pregnant as a result of rape, and that 17 of these women terminated the pregnancy.

Two survivors became pregnant more than once as a result of rape and had different outcomes in each pregnancy.

Rape Crisis Centres

Fiona Neary, RCNI Executive Director said:

In the abortion debate there has been some talk about the case of women who have been raped and are pregnant as a result. It is important this discussion is informed by the best available facts and a compassionate understanding of the realities facing these girls and women in Ireland.

The 90 girls and women were supported in Rape Crisis Centres (RCC) across Ireland in 2011. “These numbers represent one part of the picture as not all rape survivors seek or can access RCC support,” said Neary.

She said that these numbers “cannot tell us how, why and under what circumstances those outcomes came about”.

“When drawing on the example of rape survivors an assumption can sometimes be made that the decisions are somehow simplified, feelings are straightforward and that moral and ethical complexities are largely nullified by the fact of conception through rape,” continued Neary. “This is not the rape crisis experience.”

For many women and teenagers pregnancy resulting from rape can cause additional trauma and certainly complexities; these demand our greatest compassion. RCNI would urge commentators to remember this when they reach for the example of rape victims in the abortion debate.

Yesterday saw the final of three hearings by the Oireachtas Joint Committee on Health and Children on the issue of abortion legislation in Ireland.

The Rape Crisis Network 24 hour helpline is 1800 77 88 88.

Read: Rape Crisis Centre draws comparison between Dublin and New Delhi>

  • Share on Facebook
  • Email this article
  •  

Read next:

Comments (46 Comments)

  • Bad enough to go through a rape only to find out you are pregnant as a result and have to deal with the trauma of not being able to access abortion in your own country. Surely from a mental health point of view the victims should be entitled to have an abortion here? These women have been through one of the most brutal and invasive attacks, and thanks to our laws their mental recovery is delayed. It just seems beyond cruel to add to their distress at such a vulnerable time.

    Reply
  • Jesus this is shocking. I wouldn’t have thought there were even 90 reported rapes in a year. What is the total if thus 90 are the ones who got pregnant.

    Reply
    • Eleen 11/01/13 #

      There are thousands a year, more go unreported. The stat is something like 1 in 4 or 5 women will be raped at least once in their lifetime – women generally wonder when it’s going to happen to them rather than if it’s going to happen to them.

      This is why rape jokes aren’t funny :/

      Reply
    • @ Eleen – that figure sounds very high. 1 in 4 or 5. So you are saying 25% of the female population gets raped (and that there are more unreported ones)? If that is the case I would have thought there would be more noise around it. Are you sure?

      Reply
    • It wouldn’t surprise me Simon if it is that high, I often deal with rape victims in the course of my work and less than 10% of them ever go to the gardai.

      Reply
    • Figures released from the UK a few years ago had reported cases of rape coming in at 230 a day, which ultimately meant that 1 in every 200 women in the UK had reported themselves as raped during that year alone. (2006 or 07, can’t remember which one)

      Reply
    • Eleen 11/01/13 #

      I think world-wide the stats are 1-3 and in Ireland it’s 1-5 but I haven’t the time to google it.

      The problem is that when you grow up in this culture, as a girl you learn to just take it as the reality. From an early age you’re told not to wear certain things so you won’t get into trouble, and so you think it’s kind of up to you if you end up getting raped or not. You blame yourself and you’re deeply ashamed. No woman wants to think about it or talk about it – so we just put our heads down and hope for the best.

      Women are often the harshest on survivors of rape: they’re quicker to blame the victim, because deep down they’re terrified that it could happen to them too, and at least if there was a reason (“well she shouldn’t have worn that slutty dress, that’s the reason she was raped, and I would never do that so I’m safe!”) then they won’t feel terrified. It’s easier to think you can control it than to realise the truth: that we’re all at high risk and many of us will have it happen to us.

      I personally know quite a few who have gone thought it – and they’re just the ones who feel they can confide in me. I’ve been lucky so far but I think about it all the time as does every other woman.

      Reply
    • I never reported mine to the Gardaí because it was my partner at the time who did it, and I didn’t realise that it counted as rape until I spoke to my counsellor about it a year or so later.

      I was always under the impression that it wasn’t really rape unless you were kicking and screaming to fight some strange guy off you in an alleyway. That was the impression I was given with the “watch what you wear / go, don’t walk alone in alleys, watch your drink in nightclubs” advice..

      But when you say you don’t want to, and your partner does anyway – even though you said no – even if you gave in to the pressure just to make it stop because you couldn’t take it anymore – that is rape. As is having sex with someone who is unconscious or asleep.
      Sadly, in my experience, there are some guys who don’t seem to understand this.. Thankfully they are in the minority, but they do exist.

      Reply
  • At least they’re being treated with compassion by the state. Oh, hang on a second..

    Reply
    • Well, actually it doesn’t say how they killed their babies, could have been the state for all we know. My taxes slaughtering infants, for shame on them all….

      Reply
    • Shut up Michael.

      Reply
    • I’m just saying what the silent majority (as evidenced by lack of green arrows) are thinking.

      Reply
    • Michael Hayes, have some compassion, how would you feel if you were raped and part of the rapist was still in you?

      Reply
    • @Michael,
      The silent majority can click a green thumb whilst remaining silent.
      Maybe it’s the computer illiterate majority you’re thinking of?

      Reply
    • @Michael
      Terribly insensitive comment to infer that a woman pregnant as a result of rape that chooses abortion is ‘killing an infant’.

      All women deserve access to safe, accessible abortion services in Ireland. Not just those who are raped, carrying a non-viable fetus or facing imminent death (likely outcome legislation/ regulation). All women. One does not have to agree with abortion but acknowledge the current system is forcing thousands of vulnerable women in the midst of a crisis pregnancy abroad, with resultant negative social, psychological and physical health effects on women.

      Reply
    • MVM 11/01/13 #

      @michael, don’t you mean minority(that’s the smaller group) we have had 2 abortion related referendums one in 1992 for the right to travel and seek advice on abortion(like they could stop anyone traveling..
      Again in
      2002 for the right to abortion
      On both occasions the yes vote won by clear majority

      Reply
  • Heartbreaking

    Reply
  • I cannot believe this is even up for a debate ie whether a woman who has become pregnant from rape should be allowed to have an abortion in ireland. The rest of our European neighbours must be looking at us with disbelief and rightly so. What kind of country is this? There must be no question- revoke the ridiculous bigoted amendment made to our constitution in 1983, end of.

    I am not religious but i am not against people practicing a religion either. However, religious personnel have no right to inflict their belief system on state law. The refusal of an individual to end their life with dignity and end their suffering is another example of how imposition of rigid beliefs can cause greater suffering.

    This country treats women and vulnerable in society as second class citizens. If you are a white, Irish male in full health, living in this country, congratulations! Many men posting on journal.ie are understanding of women’s rights regarding abortion, which is heartening to see. However, isnt it interesting to note that the majority of commentators on journal.ie who oppose abortion are white Irishmen.

    Reply
    • Well I think it’s interesting that you complain about “bigotry” while in the same post you seek to limit the input of people whose colour, sex or nationality you don’t approve of

      Reply
    • @chuck. I don’t think that’s what she’s saying at all…

      Reply
    • @chuck

      Chuck – i am not talking about restricting the imput of anyone. far from it. Women and vulnerable in irish society are restricted by certain aspects of our law. Regarding men commenting on abortion i never said they should or should not. You have twisted my words. I made an observation and commented on same.

      law.

      Reply
    • Editorial comment

      * that’s input not imput and ignore the free floating ‘law’ at the end!!

      Not used to the keypad on my husband’s iPhone ( who by the way chuck, as a white Irish male, has plenty to say on abortion and he and I share the same beliefs regarding same).

      Reply
    • Well how generous of you to let him speak, but why comment on race and sex at all? Lots of women’s groups had their say on the matter of anonymity for those accused of rape, even though they’ll never be in that position

      Which leads me on to my next point; how on earth are “women and vulnerable” restricted by our laws? Our laws state that only men can be convicted of rape and underage boys who have sex with their girlfriends are de facto raping them. Our courts give men harsher sentences for the same crimes and routinely deny men access to their children. Our state pays child support to the mother no matter who has custody and unmarried fathers depend 100% on the word of the mother to even have their existence acknowledged. We also don’t provide a single bed anywhere in the country for a man fleeing an abusive woman, which is one of the reasons why 85% of the homeless are men

      So tell me again who’s vulnerable

      Reply
  • God almighty. And all those suits in Dáil Éireann can do is shrug their shoulders and let some other group, some other task force, some other “experts”, talk about it. The only real experts are those women who have been raped and became pregnant. Let Enda Kenny and James Reilly sit down with THEM, let the Bishops sit down with THEM and say, “Sorry, no can do. You see, it’s a bit of a grey area, morally speaking.”

    Reply
    • @ b Collins

      So true. Today, as a society, we collectively look on with horror re clerical child abuse, magdalene laundries etc where once Irish society turned a blind eye. Perhaps one day we will collectively look with horror how Irish society ( as reflected in our law) currently treats women who become pregnant from rape. I hope that day won’t be long coming and that we don’t have to wait another 20 years.

      Reply
  • And we laugh at the Middle East where rape is a form of adultery, here you get punished with an unwanted child. Time for Ireland to grow up and stop messing around with issues that don’t concern the general public, this is for the woman to decide and everybody else to F’off.

    Reply
  • Wonder what the attitude would be of a pro-life supporter if one of the victims was his little sister…

    Reply
    • My cousin of mine was raped by a person who was known to her, but not involved with her. The child she conceived is now 6 and is very much loved by her and all her family.

      Reply
    • Some people choose to keep baby, they shouldn’t be condemned or made feel ashamed for keeping the baby.

      Reply
    • @karla

      That is true karla. But what for those who do not want to go through with the pregnancy?

      Reply
    • I reckon a woman who finds herself pregnant as a result of rape should receive whatever support, counselling and treatment she needs to do what is best for her. Whether that be to keep the baby, offer it for adoption or have an abortion. But it should be a decision that she gets to make – no one should force her in any direction, she’s already been forced into sex against her consent.

      If we could simply offer her all of these options as standard then perhaps pro choice and pro life sides could stop fighting and start working together to improve conditions and supports for babies once they are born so that abortion doesn’t seem like the only option to as many. We could work together on prevention of unwanted pregnancy by promoting factual sex, relationship and emotional education and free contraception so even though abortion is permitted – as few happen as possible..

      Women will seek out abortion if they want to, this is a fact of life as much as pregnancy itself, they’ve done it since they discovered the right toxins.. If it is legal and regulated, then at least it is done safely. There is a far larger problem behind abortion, and outlawing it doesn’t do anything to help resolve that problem.

      Reply
    • Karla how can you not see the irony in your comment?

      Shanti – well said.

      Reply
  • From a human evolution point of view, I’d prefer if rapists procreated as seldom as possible.

    Reply
  • I think the fathers do have a say, any person I know whom have had a abortion have had supporting partners

    Reply
  • JakkiB 11/01/13 #

    Shocking to see those figures!
    And lets be honest it is more than likely higher as not all victims report Rape, Pass those figures onto Alan Shatter please!!!

    Reply
  • I have read and I have heard comments about abortion Times are a changeing let the woman decide what Is best for her and her unborn child .let the teenager who comes home pregnat parents decide what they would like to do see the Image of the man that raped there daugter every day stir back at them through Innocene eyes .and have traumatic effects on the mother of the child.If times are a changeing the priest should be allowed to marry and have kids rather than decideng what Is best for other people kids .the goverment cut child allowance so why do they not want to legalise abortion for people who may not be able to afford a baby.the other alternative use the pill.

    Reply
  • Who knows if these figures are accurate ? They are put out by the pro abort machine backed by the big abortion providers who are eagerly awaiting to get their bloody hands on Irish women , not because they care but because killing is a big lucrative business !

    Reply
    • So many fallacies I’m not sure where to start.. So you would force a woman to be used as an incubator, even though the sex that created that embryo was non consensual? You would give her no say whatsoever in autonomy over her own body..

      Can you not see what is inherently wrong with this view? Or do you simply not care?

      Reply

Add New Comment