TheJournal.ie uses cookies. By continuing to browse this site you are agreeing to our use of cookies. Click here to find out more »
Dublin: 10 °C Thursday 23 May, 2013

Column: ‘Deep down, I am still angry at the unfairness of it all’

Helen Browne describes her experience of infertility, and asks for people to be more sensitive to this painful condition.

Image: p886 via Flickr

I WAS DIAGNOSED with endometriosis in my 20s, and when I got married I knew that I would have difficulty in conceiving.

My Fallopian tubes were blocked. IVF treatment was quite new in Ireland and there was only one clinic at the time and I didn’t want to go for IVF treatment. I didn’t know too much about IVF and at that time there was no internet (that will tell you how long go it was!). I opted for surgery to unblock my tubes. Unfortunately, the surgery was unsuccessful. I knew then that for me to have my own child, I would have to go the IVF route. To be pregnant, give birth and have the opportunity to breastfeed my baby was so important and fundamental to me.

Following our second unsuccessful IVF treatment, I was so low and alone. The feeling of isolation was overwhelming that I decided to go for counselling. After 5 minutes I knew this was not for me at this time – what I needed was to meet and share my pain with those who knew what it was like. That was when I co-founded NISIG, the National Infertility Support and Information Group. Sharing our experiences, pain and disappointment help me immensely.

Three of us women set up the group. There are three outcomes following infertility: success, adoption and acceptance. Ironically each of us reached a different outcome ourselves, so we covered those three between us. For me, following three fresh cycles, four frozen cycles and miscarriages, I had to deal with not ever having my own child or children.

When all I ever wanted was a family, it was a devastating blow to realise it wasn’t going to happen. This is especially so when I’ve been through the demanding regime of fertility treatment and had a glimmer of hope that all might be fine – only to discover that actually, it won’t be.

After each treatment cycle, I went through a range of emotions. I felt depressed, angry, bereaved, anxious, and guilty and it was very difficult for me to see a future without children in our lives.

Infertility treatment had taken over ten of our twelve years of married life. I was exhausted mentally, physically, emotionally and financially.

I felt socially excluded; my friends had new friends through their children. Rituals and the passages of life were denied me: our children’s christenings, confirmation, marriage, and our grandchildren.

A lonely and isolating grief

Although I’m a positive person it was exhausting keeping up a front and I withdrew from a lot of activities. Our decision not to pursue further treatment or adoption evolved over many years. I can look at it reasonably strongly now but deep down I am still angry at the unfairness of it all.

It can take a while, if not a lifetime, to come to terms with the idea of accepting life without your own children; especially if it’s something you’ve always set your heart on. Following fertility treatment your hopes are high that it will be successful, only for it to be taken away from you so many times, so cruelly. It is a horrendously lonely and isolating grief, because it is not embraced and acknowledged by society. NISIG has a 24/7 mobile number and I would sincerely hope this would alleviate some of the isolation.

There were many difficult periods for me during my infertility journey. One that sticks out so much in my mind was insensitive remarks that were said to me over time. Believe me when I say, these insensitive remarks are often uttered by mothers. I have now learnt to deal with it. I continue to smile, look elsewhere and count to ten and make an excuse to leave.

Dealing with infertility is hard. Your God-given desire to have children is thwarted. As you grow up, people say to you “When you get married and have your kids…” Everyone assumes fertility. Infertility shatters your identity. You have a picture in your mind. You are married. You have your dream home with a lovely back garden. But where are the children? Infertility shatters your rosy picture.

Infertility is often misunderstood. People take it lightly. A person with a chronic disease or terminal illness gets support from all those around them. But to a couple struggling with infertility, these same people offer platitudes. “Count all your blessings!” “Take mine!” or “Relax, it will happen.”

Infertile couples suffer the same, or a similar, level of intense anguish and heartache as those who are dealing with serious illness and they need to be treated with compassion and care.

Life without children may not be how I envisaged our life to be. I must admit that attending counselling and having a very kind and patient husband helped me to be where I am today. I will always miss deeply not ever being a Mum and us not being parents.

I ask for people to be more empathic towards other people’s pain and to those who don’t fit the mould. Those who have left their twenties and are not married, those who are in their forties and have not had a longed-for child. For older people who cannot tell tales about their grandchildren. Stop and think now before you speak.

Helen Browne is the co-founder and chairperson of NISIG, the National Infertility Support and Information Group. To find out more, visit nisig.ie.

Read next:

Comments (7 Comments)

  • Helen, I hear & acknowledge your acute pain & sense of loss. I’m so sorry for your loss & your heartache. You are very brave both in sharing your personal journey and for raising this matter. I for 1 will try to be more aware & be very careful about what I say. It’s great that there is now a support forum for others sharing similar feelings & emotions. God Bless. Anne

    Reply
  • The smugness of the ‘mums’ is at the root of all this Helen. It was ever thus. Single people have always been treated cruelly in Ireland also (‘You’re too cute’). Think of all those gaudy engagement rings we had to twist around our fingers ‘to make a wish’ just because someone wanted to be one up on her neighbours. The modern cult of the vulgar wedding reinforces these attitudes.
    Parenthood, contrary to popular opinion, does not instantly confer virtue or wisdom. If only it did. I have always been irritated at the way people describe themselves as ‘wife and mother’, the tone suggesting that they are paragons at both roles. Some of civilisations greatest people have been childless, all three Brontes, George Eliot, Jane Austen, Leonardo, Proust…etc., etc.Their wisdom was the greater methinks. An in-law of mine constantly repeats ‘Ah sure, what would she know. She has no children of her own’. I found this most insulting when she said it of a dear friend of mine.
    I was single and childless long enough to observe these attitudes. Fortune eventually favoured me and I have two grown up daughters but I regard this as just good luck and no mark of virtue on my part. Out of habit I still root for the single and the childless. Bon courage Helen.

    Reply
  • WillLynch – your comments are ill-informed and – I’m sure – very hurtful for the author. It’s bad luck – not natural selection – that she is infertile. To imply that the human race is better off without her offspring is nasty and cruel.

    Reply
  • Terry – it was not my intention to be hurtful. I think you are misconstruing my words.
    I was trying to re-frame a negative experience into a positive one for the writer’s benefit.I started off by saying “I hope you take comfort”

    If you change the way you look at things, the things you look at change.

    I hope that my comments are not “ignorant”. Indeed I would consider myself remarkably well read on evolution and how indifferent it is to human suffering. To seek to find meaning in it is to drive yourself mad.

    For what it is worth, personally speaking, I have spent the last 20 years looking after my father who is crippled with MS. I don’t get angry at how “unfair” this is – I just accept it in a Buddhist fashion and grin and bear it as best I can.

    Here is a great extract from Richard Dawkins’s River out of Eden:

    “A female digger wasp not only lays her egg in a caterpillar (or grasshopper or bee) so that her larva can feed on it but, according to Fabre and others, she carefully guides her sting into each ganglion of the prey’s central nervous system, so as to paralyze it but not kill it. This way, the meat keeps fresh.
    It is not known whether the paralysis acts as a general anesthetic, or if it is like curare in just freezing the victim’s ability to move. If the latter, the prey might be aware of being eaten alive from inside but unable to move a muscle to do anything about it.
    This sounds savagely cruel but, as we shall see, nature is not cruel, only pitilessly indifferent. This is one of the hardest lessons for humans to learn.
    We cannot admit that things might be neither good nor evil, neither cruel nor kind, but simply callous-indifferent to all suffering, lacking all purpose”.

    I hope the writer adopts and finds the happiness, joy and meaning she is seeking that way. This has the other advantage of helping a kid who dearly love and doing our planet a much needed favour too.

    So the question couples in this situation have to ask themselves is – Why Not Adopt?

    Reply
    • Will, that question is answered in the article.

      Three of us women set up the group. There are three outcomes following infertility: success, adoption and acceptance. Ironically each of us reached a different outcome ourselves, so we covered those three between us.

      I find that you insistence of acceptance and adoption to be just as hurtful as societies insistence that I settle down, be in a relationship, become a parent.

      As someone who has left their 20′s and never had a relationship – let alone gotten married, I very much sympathise with the flippant hurtful comments that the majority of people make. Also the empty platitudes of how easy I have it, how things will change, there’s always tomorrow, look on the bright side etc…

      Reply
  • I hope that you will take some comfort in knowing that unfortunately, Natural Selection is anything but fair. It is a very sophisticated, effective process that is amoral and utterly indifferent to how you feel as an individual. Not everyone is supposed to reproduce. Indeed this is precisely why it works so beautifully and efficiently.

    I decided for ethical reasons not to have kids from the age of 15.

    Why not adopt?I am sure you would make wonderfully loving parent who could give so much joy, happiness and material comfort to so many kids that are unwanted today and are cruelly left in the overflowing and under-funded orphanages of our world.

    Having children is a base primal genetic drive and people do so out of vanity and innate selfishness,even if you are not consciously aware of this.
    It is about replicating your genes at the expense of a dangerously over-populated planet with dwindling resources. Not having a child is equal to 85 years of 100% recycling.

    Besides, given the huge systemic risk in the global financial system that is teetering dangerously on the brink of collapse again and given the danger posed by global heating and apocalyptic climate change why on earth would anyone want to bring a child into such a dangerous and uncertain world?
    The post WW2 consumer dream that we blissfully enjoyed from 1945-2008 is over.
    Things are going to get an awful lot worse. I certainly wouldn’t want to inflict upon a child on what is coming in the next 100 years.

    Here’s the excellent comedian Doug Stanhope on why not having kids is the good, moral, eco-friendly thing to do if you are a conscientious citizen.
    http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=YkgDhDa4HHo

    Reply

Add New Comment