TheJournal.ie uses cookies. By continuing to browse this site you are agreeing to our use of cookies. Click here to find out more »
Dublin: 10 °C Saturday 18 May, 2013

RTÉ decides to axe Prime Time Investigates

One RTÉ executive retires and another resigns his post and moves to another position in the station.

Image: Mark Stedman/ Photocall Ireland

TWO RTÉ EXECUTIVES have left their positions as a result of inquiries into the Prime Time Investigates programme ‘A Mission to Prey’. The Prime Time Investigates series is also to be permanently shelved, RTÉ has announced.

Ed Mulhall, the Managing Director of RTÉ’s News and Current Affairs division, retired from the broadcaster from March 2012, according to a statement just issued by RTÉ.

Ken O’Shea, Editor of Current Affairs, has resigned that post. He is now “transferring to an assignment in Television, reporting to the Commissioning Editor for RTÉ Two”.

RTÉ also announced today that it has convened an External Investigation Board “into all personnel matters arising in respect of the programme ‘A Mission to Prey’.” This board is currently investigating and is to deliver a report to RTÉ’s Group Head of HR. RTÉ said it won’t comment on the work of the board until it has reached a conclusion.

Until that document has been examined by RTÉ, it won’t be commenting on the fates of reporter Aoife Kavanagh and executive producer Brian Pairceir, who were also involved in the ‘A Mission to Prey’ programme. The two stepped aside from their posts while the BAI carried out its inquiries.

The revelations came as part of an announcement from RTÉ Director General Noel Curran on “significant changes in the personnel, editorial management structure and operations of RTÉ Television’s current affairs output”.

The Broadcasting Authority of Ireland yesterday said that it had finished deliberations on an independent inquiry by its Compliance Committee into how an RTÉ Prime Time Investigates programme called ‘A Mission To Prey’ had defamed Fr Kevin Reynolds in May of last year. RTÉ paid Fr Reynolds a substantial amount in damages in the High Court last November as a result of the aired allegations that he had had a child by an underage girl while working as a missionary in Africa in the 1980s. These allegations, RTÉ said in an apology last October, were “baseless, without any foundation whatever and untrue”.

RTÉ is yet to comment on the BAI’s final report on the matter – today, RTÉ said that it is still awaiting “receipt of the formal notification of decision”, and it will have two weeks to examine the report itself when it receives it. However, the State broadcaster said that it was going to make this announcement about the restructuring of its current affairs department in the light of its own discussion in recent months.

Two documents were published today by RTÉ. One is a document called ‘Journalism Guidelines’. The other is ‘Key Actions and Changes: A Re-structured Current Affairs, New Journalism Guidelines, Editorial Standards and Training’ which outlines the decisions taken in light of the recent controversies in RTÉ.

Some of the major points of the documents are that:

  • Prime Time Investigates will not return to air but new investigative television programmes will come from a new Current Affairs Investigations Unit. This unit will be “multimedia”, producing special investigative docs for both TV and radio.
  • Restructuring in the Current Affairs department means that five senior posts (including those two vacated by Mulhall and O’Shea) will need to be filled. “There will be external recruitment but no net additions to RTÉ headcount”, said the statement.
  • Those five posts to be filled are: Managing Director RTÉ News and Current Affairs; Managing Editor Television Current Affairs; Editor of Prime Time; Editor of Frontline; Editor of RTÉ’s Investigations Unit. The final three of those will report to the Managing Editor of Television Current Affairs. Previously, the functions of those latter four posts were pretty much under the remit of the Editor of Current Affairs. The new Managing Editor of Television Current Affairs person will then report directly to the MD of News and Current Affairs.
  • All RTÉ editorial staff will be trained in the new Journalism Guidelines from late April/early May onwards.
  • A new Editorial Standards Board will “oversee standards”. The members of this board are: RTÉ News Managing Editor Michael Good; RTÉ Radio 1 head Jim Jennings; RTÉ Television Director of Programmes Steve Carson; Eleanor Bleahane of RTÉ Solicitors’ Office; Head of Broadcast Compliance Peter Feeney.
  • There will be a revised complaints procedure – and the Editorial Standards Board will have a role in that.
  • An External Investigation Board is currently carrying out an inquiry into “all personnel matters” arising from the ‘A Mission To Prey’ controversy. Its results will go to the RTÉ human resources department. The people on that board are former Employment Appeals Tribunal head Gaye Cunningham; BBC Trustee Richard Ayre; former senator and Northern Ireland Ombudsman Dr Maurice Hayes.

What happens to the rest of the ‘A Mission To Prey’ crew?>

RTÉ: Full statement on “two very serious editorial failures”>

Read next:

Comments (35 Comments)

  • Why? Its done more good than harm… its one of the few RTE programs that uncoverd serious problems and dealt with important issues in the country…

    Reply
    • True but how many did they make up.

      Reply
    • Yes torpedo I agree with you. On one program that I have personal knowledge of there was a lot of stuff made up even though it did highlight certain problems & brought them to the publics attention the over riding fact from my experience was spin sensationalism & down right lies &.corruption. Witnesses were paid large amounts of money & described as whistleblowers. My overall view of this program, which before this was quiet high,was water down completely & everytime after this I watched the program I would think how much of this is really true. After all what is prime time. The truth is its a tv program designed to entertain.

      Reply
  • So we will just have to do with tv3 repeating their documentarys about travellers, prostitutes, and Gangland Ireland.

    Reply
    • @ Seamus

      Also all the cheap tapes/recordings they’ve bought from Sky1 and ITV. which most of us have had the choice of watching already. The only programme I give any time for is “Midweek”. All the rest, amateurs and rubbish.

      Reply
  • Only show on RTE I watched.. even though it was a tad annoying at times.

    Reply
  • RTE have now, through their stupidity, built a wall around the media questioning Missionaries and their conduct abroad.

    Reply
  • Yet Craig Doyle Live is on every night practically….yep, we can expect more inanity and trash TV from RTE I guess.

    No science programming, no history/nature programming, no arts programming to speak of, no serious journalism. Ireland’s lobotomy continues apace….

    Reply
  • One of the best shows that RTE did. Investigative journalism is something that this country badly needs to have.

    Reply
    • Yep, but it should be a reasonably basic stipulation that the content is factual and without bias and not just a more genteel packaging of what populist nonsense TV3 has to offer. That story reminded me of the “if she floats when drowned then maybe she wasn’t a witch after all” school of thought. This was a decent man, people need to however briefly, put aside the Catholic Church’s sins.

      Reply
  • Don’t worry folks, whilst the name Primetime Investigates is gone, along with some of its staff, it will be replaced with something similar.
    One of the few programmes on TV that does a superb job.
    Of course, every now and again mistakes such as the Reynolds case will be made.

    Reply
  • I’ll have to watch TV3 now for all my cutting edge journalism.

    Reply
  • Paul Brady makes a good point sad to see it go…it has helped countless people! The real tragedy is what will go undetected in Ireland without it!

    Reply
  • jimbo 03/04/12 #

    RTE Should be axed..

    Reply
    • Agreed! Can we have a rally against the €170 annual tv tax please!

      Reply
    • Yes.

      It’s only an expensive government PR machine anyway.

      Reply
    • id of been happy for the people responsible to of been axed, instead one is transferred and promoted, one gets to retire(on the bonanza pay day that the government had last month) on a massive pension, and the other two quietly go back to work, but hey this is Ireland no-one in a position of responsibility ever takes and responsibility except for their own pay, which is paid by all taxpayers (both in public and private sectors)

      Reply
    • Hear hear jimbo
      Anyone I have spoken to is of the opinion that RTE is a dinosaur of a broadcaster.
      Especially with the mega choice of channels on satellite tv.
      And what really bugs me is the fact that we still have to pay a tv licence. (160 Euro).
      I am additionally paying SKY TV approx. 45 Euro per month for their services.(which is fine).

      Reply
  • Did I miss something? Was it not RTÉ’s Aoife Kavanagh who’s shoddy journalism is at the root of this fiasco? How come her head was not the head that rolled?

    Reply
    • Hi – please note that we have explained what is happening with Aoife Kavanagh and exec producer Brian Pairceir in par 5. A decision can’t be made until the BAI’s findings have been studied by RTE.

      Reply
  • Hmmmm. Didn’t think they would go that far.

    Reply
  • May God forgive me for what I am about to say! This reminds me of the Catholic church/Rome what they did for years with rotten priests and ignored the problem hoping it would go away! What RTE have done here is that they have “moved” people around. Two of them were retiring anyway, I feel. So they haven’t really reprimanded anyone for what was done to Fr. Kevin Reynolds on Prime Time Investigates.

    Just like the Government of any day …. a law upon themselves. Maybe we should take a stance here. Don’t pay our TV licences because we’re not getting the service we pay for!!! Do what the ‘bull Hogan’ did. He wasn’t and isn’t happy with his property taxes/management payments and didn’t/doesn’t pay!!!!

    Reply
  • One of the few worthwhile programmes on, although of its to make room for an x-rated fair city I’m all for it

    Reply
  • It was shite anyway. They investigated the Cork Hurlers strike in 2009. WTF, how pathetic. RTE is a propaganda joke. George Lee was running riot in there for five years. Whoever put news and current affairs in one unit should be sacked as well. While they’re at it they should get rid of Fair City

    Reply
  • louise 03/04/12 #

    Shame ;(

    Reply
  • John 03/04/12 #

    First we refused to register for the household tax, then we refused to renew our tv licences….Perhaps they see the writing on the wall.

    Reply
  • The Journal should expect at least one senior applicant for the news journalist position! http://www.thejournal.ie/were-hiring-attention-news-journalists-405745-Apr2012/

    Reply
  • overpaid,the whole lot of them.They dont deserve a quarter of the wages they get.Then when any of them retire,they get a huge pension,a big golden handshake,then just walk into a new job on probably more money then they were on.Same in the government,they retire,get a huge pension,then walk into a new well paid job.You only have to look at our old friend bertie,starting a new job in Nigeria,well paid,gets 150,000 from the IFF every year ( for trying to sell off our forests),then we give him 3,000 euro a week,and for what,been corrupt.Things have to change in Ireland,but it has to start changing at the very top.They are all getting away with murder at our expense.

    Reply
  • Just how do you go about getting a job in RTE or even get invited to go on a Kenny or Marian F radio show? Seems to be a recycling of the same people all of the time. Are they getting paid by RTE?

    Reply
  • Critical though I am about those in power it is we who support them and put them where they are by keeping our mouths shut when we need to speak up. We all need a dose of honesty.

    Reply
  • Like Gay Byrne and a few more he will become a consultant and sub contract through a private business. These guys don’t retire – too greedy for more.
    Mind you Vincent Brown commented on his program during the protests in the. West that “Irish men say they woud love to RAPE this one or that one” and it a common expression. Nothing was said about that and I found it really damaging to all the good work of the Rape crises centre. I also feel that the CEO of the Rape Crises Centre should have resigned as they did not comment in it they just agreed to get more air time on TV 3 apparently.

    Reply

Add New Comment