TheJournal.ie uses cookies. By continuing to browse this site you are agreeing to our use of cookies. Click here to find out more »
Dublin: 10 °C Tuesday 21 May, 2013

Half of proceeds from State assets sale must pay down debt – Troika

The government is keen to use all of the money from the sale of State assets in “one shape or another” to fund job creation initiatives but the Troika appears more focussed on reducing the debt.

Minister for Public Expenditure and Reform Brendan Howlin (File)
Minister for Public Expenditure and Reform Brendan Howlin (File)
Image: Mark Stedman/Photocall Ireland

THE TROIKA HAS reaffirmed that Ireland will use half of the money raised from the sale of State assets to pay down its debt though the government appears more keen to use the money to seek additional lending to fund job creation.

Under a deal reached with the Troika in May of last year, the government plans to use half of the proceeds from the Sale of state assets for job creation measures while using the other half as a fund to underpin additional lending from institutions like the European Investment Bank.

This money would also go towards job creation initiatives, the government believes.

But in a draft European Commission report seen by TheJournal.ie the Troika says that the Irish government is “committed under the programme to use at least half of the privatisation proceeds for debt reduction”.

In answer to a parliamentary question in October last year, Public Expenditure and Reform Minister Brendan Howlin was keen to emphasise that money raised from the privatisation of State companies would be used for job creation.

He said: “It has been agreed with the Troika that all of the Government’s proceeds from the programme will be available, in one shape or another, to support job creating initiatives in the economy.”

In the answer, Howlin goes onto acknowledge that the other half of the money is “destined eventually to pay-down debt” but says that in the first instance it will be “constituted to underpin additional lending” into Ireland.

This could be done through the European Investment Bank and could support further job creation measures, Howlin said. However, the Troika’s view would appear to indicate it is more keen to see debt serviced.

The Troika also notes in the draft EC report that precise projects which would benefit from the funds raised through privatisation have yet to be identified.

The government said last month that the sale of State assets will begin this year. It has previously said that parts of Bord Gais, ESB (now Electric Ireland) and Coillte will be sold off in the hope of raising around €3 billion.

May 2012: Half of proceeds from sale of State assets can be used for jobs – Howlin

Read: New insolvency regime may not help troubled mortgage holders – Troika

Read: Troika recommends cuts to specialist doctors’ salaries

In full: TheJournal.ie’s coverage on the leaked European documents >

Read next:

Comments (76 Comments)

  • Lets be very honest about this, what they’re actually demanding for is a sale of assets owned by the Irish people to pay off banker and speculator gambling debts.

    Reply
    • mart_n 11/01/13 #

      What’s worse is the selling of assets will invariably lead to further job cuts… you’ll then have the Troika threaten us because not enough is been done to secure jobs, while at the same time demanding that the government spend less on job creation.

      It’s disgusting really… we’re been screwed from every angle.

      Reply
    • we are being asset stripped gentlemen plain and simple

      Reply
    • Correct, all while being governed by a party big on privatisation. Fine Gael are up to their necks in this and could easily renegotiate to save our family silver.

      Reply
    • Read Naomi Kleins ‘The Shock Doctrine’ for a trenchant & frightening description of how exactly this has been done before. The sovereign value of everything belong to the people which provides a sustainable life is being ‘monetized’ & privatized to the very people who caused all this hardship.

      Reply
    • Looting and pillaging first thing that comes to mind .

      Reply
    • @P Ni Riogain I recommend you read “Confessions of an Economic Hitman” by John Perkins to see exactly what is being done to this country.

      Reply
    • Paul 11/01/13 #

      @ Graham and P. Ní, brilliant book recommendations, just to add to them a link to the hit man interview

      http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=aqIHKWd9rSc&feature=youtube_gdata_player

      Reply
    • Ryan'O 11/01/13 #

      I haven’t read those books but I will now that you suggested them. It’s essential to gain as much knowledge as possible about the current world economic situation and our own in particular. Spread the knowledge. Scare the shit out of our so called representatives. Knowledge is power. They can’t censor us just yet!

      Reply
    • This the Troika talking, so what we need now is a government and a in particular the Taoiseach of this country, who the people elected to lead them, to go and tell the troika NO.

      Mark my words, Pinocchio Kenny will be on every news medium over the coming days saying that this is unacceptable and he won’t stand for it, but it’s all complete bluster, he will do absolutely sweet FA about it. The guy is completely clueless.

      Reply
    • Why is the 3rd WORLD, THE 3RD WORLD, the money barons have robbed these countries of their enormous assets, minerals,oil, et al, and its not current assets ,but assets that may come on line in the future
      They lend these countries billions at extortion interest rates, knowing full well they will never be able to pay,so as collateral they snap up all the wealthy assets , and pay buttons for them. These crooks ,IMF,WORLD BANK, ECB, ARE WEAPONS OF WAR.

      Whist some years ago Bono and Geldof, were kissing ass, and organizing fund raising ,the IMF insisted on interest repayments from these nations which were twice the amount paid out to them by these charities,

      Any Irish government who allows the nations assets (the peoples’ assets) TO BE STOLEN ARE TRAITORS,AND THE PEOPLE OF IRELAND IF THEY SIT BY AND WATCH, ARE A DISGRACE TO ALL THOSE, WHO GAVE THEIR LIVES OVER PAST CENTURIES. It must be stopped, QUITE SIMPLY, DON’T PAY ANY MORE MONEY TO THESE WEALTHY BOND HOLDERS. IT MUST BE STOPPED. DON’T PAY.

      Reply
    • MVM 11/01/13 #

      @ peter,I agree with what you mean, its a true saying
      The rich get richer and the poor get poorer
      But a lot was down to the Irish person who borrowed way beyond their means so much that property went way beyond its value
      Builders couldn’t knock houses up quick enough the average 3bed Simi in my area was built for about 100k site included and sold for 300+ now however 150 will buy the same house

      Reply
    • Selling loss-making assets such as ESB, Bus Eireann etc. Isn’t asset- stripping. It’s liability stripping.
      Having said that, attempting to service unserviceable debts is a waste of resources.
      Also, Naomi Klein is economically illiterate.

      Reply
    • Paul 11/01/13 #

      Is it better to know that the emperor has no clothes or to have a receipt and proof of how expensive those threads are? Naomi Klein isn’t economically illiterate, she has shown that the economic hegemony is a fraud, not the same thing, however this is difficult to see if you haven’t opened your eyes.

      Reply
    • Paul 11/01/13 #

      Is it better to know that the emperor has no clothes or to have a receipt and proof of how expensive those threads are? Naomi Klein isn’t economically illiterate, she has shown that the economic hegemony is a fraud, not the same thing, however this is difficult to see if you haven’t opened your eyes.

      Reply
    • Current Irish government are traitors. Just like the last. Selling off Irish assets funded by Irish people over the years for what?

      Reply
    • So we never borrowed the monies to sustain an artificial boom period for hears more than was prudent and we didn’t have the highest per capita income in the EU and we didn’t buy more properties in Spain , Portugal and Bulgaria than any other European Nation and we didn’t enjoy sales of high end Mercedes cars that were the highest per capita in the world . So someone is telling porkies!

      Reply
    • Yes Irish Banker, Speculator, Developer, Gambler debts.

      How did you expect the loans from intenational lenders to work? Write off the loans because we were collectivelt too thick to scream ‘stop this madness’?

      ‘Oh, you loaned 1/4 of a billion to some bs-artist in D4 building a 37 storey tower hotel ? … well of course you don’t need to pay us that back. The loan purpose was so ridiculous in the first place’

      ‘now lets continue on down the list of who you lent the money to that we lent you, so who is Sean Quinn and what did he need the loans for?’

      Reply
    • Michael J, arbitrasure – shush now! The truth hurts. No one wants to hear that. So much better to slip into denial / victim mode and pretend the Celtic Tiger never happened.

      Reply
  • We really are up the creek if we continue to dance with the Troika or should we say our friends in the ECB. We need debt forgiveness and write downs not shovelling our money into black holes like we are doing.

    Reply
  • Just a quick google search there on profit on these companies (all of 3 second each)
    ESB €469 million profit 2012
    Bord Gais €94m profit 2012
    Coillte almost €20m profit 2011

    I know that is not what the state gets, but is this not a case of selling the family silver.
    These are state assets that make the state money, create jobs and provide important services, you only have to look to Eircom to see what happens when you sell state assets.

    Reply
  • Why don’t we all stop shiting on here all the time and contact your local TD and hassle the life out of them instead of writing here, email or phone them go to their clinics and make them earn their money and put up on this site who you phoned what you said about the subject and what they are doing about it, get organised

    Reply
  • DB 11/01/13 #

    There off there heads if they think they get 3 billion. Smart investors will hold off and when nobody is buying they will force the price down. Once the sales are complete asset stripping will commence and then be sold off again.

    We will be rode hard by investors.

    The government are not competent enough to use the money to stimulate the economy. The money will be spent and no benefit realization will be done to see what we got for the stimulation.

    Reply
    • DB…
      I think you’re right.
      The points you put across are basic business principals.
      “The bottom line is the only thing that matters “.
      Seeing as we have nothing but ex- teachers in Government…. I’d ask the question!!!
      Name one successful ex teacher that made it big in the commercial sector!!!!
      I’m so tired of bluffing ex teachers !!!

      Reply
    • Ryan'O 11/01/13 #

      Ginger ones not count for extra :)

      Reply
    • As a teacher I resent that comment. There are lots of great teachers in the country….they are in our schools, not politics ! The shower you are talking about never wanted to be teachers anyway…and were probably no good at teaching either ?

      Reply
    • Not defending them but Pat McDonagh of Supermacs fame if your interested.

      Reply
    • Aer Arann is also run by an ex-teacher.

      DB – “They’re off their heads…”

      Reply
    • Didn’t Obama do some teaching, Oprah was one too and how can we forget Mr T!!!! All fairly successful, maybe not in the commercial world like you asked but all successful.

      You see most be who go into teaching do it to help and have, at the beginning at least, a notion to help others. While most business people have a notion of looking after themselves first as that’s what’s needed to succeed in business. Most politicians (former teachers and non teachers) rely very heavily on the advice of the highly paid private sector advisors. Maybe this is where you should aim our ire? Look at James Reilly, when he was head of the IMO he negotiated big rises for his members, compare this to his efforts to gain savings for the government.

      Reply
    • I thought Aer Arann had gone bust. Like the Irish State.

      Reply
    • well stop electing them then.

      Reply
  • MVM 11/01/13 #

    That’s fairly interesting selling your assets so they will be privately owned and see a massive increase in charges,ah well looks like its no oil,gold or anything else we need in the future

    Reply
  • Cleaning the Irish state out by deception and lies and more lies…..absolute shocker !!!

    Reply
  • “This money would also be go towards job creation initiatives” (sic) – Wakey wakey….!!

    Reply
  • Now Enda and Co !! It’s time to put the feet down….tell them to f@”:?? off !

    Reply
  • This is exactly what has happened to the south American countries , coincidence ? , I think not . Now the next thing is huge escalating bills ,this is the way the IMF works

    Reply
  • So half the money will go towards creating jobs but they don’t know where and the other half will go into the debt hole that wasent ours in the first place, and that’s for starters by the end they will asset strip the country sell it off to pay back a national debt most of which was nothing to do with us. That’s some deal, meanwhile Iceland told the banks to go bust instead of their people and are coming out of recession

    Reply
  • We may not as well have any Government. The Troika seems to be dictating waht needs tyo be done and of course the Government are bowing to their every need.

    Reply
  • Lets have a vote on our future in Europe, we’re entitled too it as citizens and should demand it!

    Reply
  • WHY sell?, lease to the highest bidder and politely tell the troika, that’s the deal or we go no further. Royalties to the State, to boot. or default, even better. Or wait for the collapse of a very unsustainable premise, monetized debt. And compensate all hurt during this debacle, including families who have lost members to stress and suicide victims remembered and compensate mortgage holders for the misleading adverts about property market. All too much for the law to interpret?. Very fond of interpreting potential.

    Reply
  • troika opinion on funds rised from state assets won’t matter ee plan to have rid of them before years end. there isn’t a hope in he’ll we have sold anything beforehand. 5 years into the recession we and haven’t reformed the middle management of the health sector.

    Reply
  • Go take a long walk off a short pier troica.

    Reply
  • funny how the spin it as a good thing to sell off the peoples assets . How the hell will me you or any one else know for sure what the get from the sale’s and then how much the put into “job creation”?
    One thing for sure whether it happens in a short time or 20 yrs time it will come out that one of our politicians benefited from one sale or another. It is after all Ireland the country where politicians who are found to be corrupt are allowed to stand again with no ill consequence. Arthur Daly comes to mind

    Reply
  • It a sad state that we don.t have a government of the people .by the people .for the people..instead a bunch of idiots who will.bend over backwards for a pat on the head and to be told there doing a grest job for there employers…BANKS.and please stop trying to pretend that there doing the work of the irish people..

    Reply
  • Assett stripping is putting it mildly. The government in this country seem hell bent on surrendering all power to the Europeans in Brussels for a few slaps on the back. Along with surrendering power the country is to be sold piece by piece to private concerns, we’ll be walking in the McDonald’s Forest, swimming in the abhainn Pfizer and heading down Sr?id Coca-Cola to get milk from the biggest shopping conglomerate going as all our indigenous small businesses are gone.

    Reply
  • Has anyone is Ireland heard that phrase ‘sod off’ – if so can someone start using it instead of lying where the doormat goes with welcome printed.

    Reply
  • Nydon 11/01/13 #

    Same international investors bailed out when Irish tax payers paid back the banking debt now use our money to buy our state assets in a forced sale and at rock bottom prices.
    Government miss two goes and go straight to jail.

    Reply
  • Troika this Troika that put your right hand out for the Trrrdroika.

    Reply
  • Barstewards , all of them , the future is dark and dank , the truth hurts , so fook off red thumbing barstewards

    Reply
  • They want their loan money back. Do excuse me I meant bail out money.

    Reply
  • What advice from the Troika next week? maybe they should branch out into other areas like the home for example. Wash hands after going to the bathroom – The Troika or Turn heating off altogether to save money- The Troika. It’s like we’re being potty trained by these ba****ds.

    Reply
  • bunch of tossers

    Reply
  • This is exactly what has happened to the south American countries , coincidence ? , I think not . Now the next thing is huge escalating bills ,this is the way the IMF works. We are going to be rode fro evermore.

    Reply
  • Banksters Ponzi scam of asset stripping national resources to the political elite business friends and massive increases in ordinary people’s usage of such services like in the UK 1980’s thatcher privatized scene has still damaged the UK’s ability to grow in recessionary times should be a warning to all nations this downsizing does not work.

    Reply
  • Robbery on a few levels. Selling off the people’s assets to pay someone for a debt the people did not have anything to do with. Furthermore, as a stimulus for private enterprise, a few will profit greatly at our expense.

    No to the sale of state assets.

    Reply
    • this experience should teach the electorate to pay more attention the next time now that the importance of being a citizen and participating proactively in democracy is so much better appreciated.
      the gravity of what fianna fail presided over and the total combined incompetence of the Dept of Finance, Central Bank and Regulator are what allowed this to happen.

      Reply
    • Ryan'O 12/01/13 #

      No FG are allowing this to happen. FF started the truck but FG are happy to drive it to the destination. Give over with the blame game. The responsibility for this mess is shifting with every steep FG take.

      Reply
  • Yup…we guessed the bailout of the banks wouldn’t come cheap

    Reply
  • Loving that the journal is now bring us exclusives, pity they don’t include the most positive news :(

    Reply
  • Chris Sanders presentation here on world economics may be of interest to people http://www.localcampus.com/Regions/Europe/Ireland/Videos/New_Energy_Era_Forum_2012/Chris_Sanders.html

    Reply
  • See p. 50 of European Commission here: “Use at least half of the proceeds from state asset sales for eventual debt
    reduction while also reinvesting the remainder of the total realised proceeds
    in projects which are of a commercial nature, meet ex-ante cost benefit
    criteria, enhance employment and preserve long term fiscal sustainability,
    including Programme and EDP fiscal targets.” – http://ec.europa.eu/economy_finance/publications/occasional_paper/2012/pdf/ocp115_en.pdf

    Reply

Add New Comment