TheJournal.ie uses cookies. By continuing to browse this site you are agreeing to our use of cookies. Click here to find out more »
Dublin: 15 °C Wednesday 19 June, 2013

Shatter to write to Magdalene survivors after criticism of State’s response

Magdalene Survivors Together have criticised the government nearly a year after a UN committee recommended an inquiry into the State’s involvement in the running of the infamous institutions.

Alan Shatter (File photo)
Alan Shatter (File photo)
Image: Laura Hutton/Photocall Ireland

JUSTICE MINISTER ALAN Shatter is to write to one of the advocacy groups for survivors of the Magdalene Laundries after the government was criticised for a lack of response to their concerns.

The Magdalene Survivors Together (MST) group said earlier this week that the Shatter and the Minister of State for Disability, Equality and Health, Kathleen Lynch, had failed to undertake a “restorative and reconciliation process” which was promised to them last September.

“It is quiet clear that Kathleen Lynch and Minister Shatter have completely failed the women on both of these counts. The Restorative and Reconciliation Process has been completely and utterly forgotten about,” the group said this week.

“Both Minister Shatter and Kathleen Lynch have made no attempt to explain why this process has been delayed, held up or indeed as Magdalene Survivors Together see it, abandoned altogether.”

The group met with Senator Martin McAleese this week who is chairing an inter-departmental committee examining the State’s involvement in the institutions which operated in Ireland from 1922 to 1996.

The group has submitted over twenty survivor testimonies which they say outlines the State’s interaction both directly and indirectly with the institutions.

Almost a year ago, a UN Committee Against Torture recommended that an inquiry be held after stating that it was  ”gravely concerned at the failure of the State to protect girls and women who were involuntarily confined between 1922 and 1996 in the Magdalene Laundries”.

Another survivors group, Justice for Magdalenes, criticised the government this week for what it said was an unacceptable delay in implementing the recommendations of the UN committee.

A Department of Justice spokesperson told TheJournal.ie this week that the Minister will be writing to the MST group this week.

“With regard to the restorative and reconciliation process, I can advise that Minister will shortly be writing to the Magdalene Survivors Together group on this matter.

“At this point, I cannot pre-empt what the Minister’s plans are in relation to the process,” the spokesperson said.

The inter-departmental committee is due to make its final report in the autumn, a report which the Department of Justice said would then be considered.

Read: Magdalene survivors criticise ‘unacceptable’ delay for apology and redress

Read: Calls for governmment reparation for Magdalene Laundries survivors

  • Share on Facebook
  • Email this article
  •  

Read next:

Comments (12 Comments)

  • It might be better if he met the survivors instead of writing to them. Thats the least he could do and show some respect.

    Reply
  • Oh no that man hasnt got a sympathetic bone in his arrogant body

    Reply
  • The Government has no interest in progressing this. As the state is involved in the abuse along with the Catholic church.

    Reply
  • He will hire an advisor to draft the letter it will be passed to his secretary to type and she/ he will rubber stamp Shatters name on it. It will somehow sound like this Bla Bla Bla and Bla Bla Bla no matter what words the letter contains it will be false promises and lies

    Reply
  • This is what I get so angry about every day. The disrespect that these people are been shown by Shatter and the rest of these so called Ministers of the Irish Government. If he had a soul or had a conscious he/they would meet with groups of these people that suffered disgusting fear and brutality in their childhood and is still living it each day. He needs to sit down and listen, listen personally to their nightmares.

    Then … he might understand a little of what they are going through each day and pain that people like him are making them still go through. All they want is for him to take the time out and show that he actually cares. To this day, all they show is disrespect and very much lack of care for these people.

    Reply
  • delay delay delay, maybe they will go away. Heartless politicians.

    Reply
  • i am not interested in education ..a nun who hasbeen a thorn in my side for more then 50 yrs said in an email awe mary i could have seen you in any of the top universaties but too bad you were poor ..that same nun is the one kept me at the back of the class adding tplus 2 _4 day after day ..slap after slap .then at 13 had me put to work n the collage as a skivvy … i had an accident then got sacked no compensation and decades later was asked did i get compensation ..that same nun with a social worker had me sent to castlepollard .. same nun wrote to psychiatrist in castlebar about me .. i do not want education i want what is due me ..i worked all day and prayed morning noon and night i was made go mass .. i was roared at told not to speak at the dining tables ..not to ask questions .. i was told to shut up more time then i care to rember and let me say this nuns do swear …hoars we were called and much much more .. could not lie down if you were sick or tired and im glad cos high park had places to put yu if you laid down and no doctors no death crts ..i sent a diagram of that hell hole to sally mulready in london ….i will never forget nor will i forgive never

    Reply
  • I write this without being predigest
    Ireland is and always was a democratic state men and women lost their Lives for this freedom and must be remembered for such heroism on their backs this is a great democracy and a great people, so today the people deserve to hear the truth. The Magdalen Laundries were every thing that a democracy is not it was a dictatorship where women were forced to work without any crime and locked away and had their babies taken away from them of ten sold for profit plus the actual abuse on the Ladies own lives as well as the abuse of their democratic rights, This Minister must see this from this point of view as every irishman and woman believed this state to be democratic. They were forced to work with no pay it was NOT the dark days those dark days were medieval times but this was later and up to contemporary times, to the birth of the 40s the first adolescence culture, the Rocken Roll Years, The swinging sixties, the glamrock 70s and even the Soul and reggie 80s where men and women were enjoying their lives dancing drinking celebrating, young women enjoying their freedom but behind these walls were a hard life, a cruel life, none of the listed good times but sheer horror a nightmare of fear and corruption, BLOOD SWEAT AND TEARS WAS WHERE THESE EXPRESSIONS CAME FROM.
    JUST AS THE INDUSTRIAL SCHOOLS WHERE THE PUBLIC WERE LED TO BELIEVE CHILDREN WERE FED SCHOOLED AND CARED FOR THEY TOO SUFFERED THE SAME FATE AT THE HANDS OF THE ROMAN CATHOLIC CHURCH IN IRELAND.
    Where was their human rights where was their equal rights where was their democracy, If these women and children are to be judged by they should be lucky to have a roof over their heads and food in their tummy then what did Ireland fight and die for? So the fat cats can fill their mansions and their dogs? No Poverty is and was a crime against the Irish poor kept there by Greed. These children and ladies worked fingers to the bone in these illegal hell holes and the public were led to believe so different, they are all due wages with interest welfare health, pensions, homes, most are old struggling and dying, the Education minister is keeping all survivors of both schools and Laundries SECTIONED AS VICTIMS, to explain to the public why they invented funds, where all finances will be paid to this office and not the “WITNESSES OF THESE CRIMES” education was constantly first hhhm why? the money. These women and children are now of great age dead, dying, sick, in hospital, in rest homes, in rehabs, on the street, struggling on welfare, still suffering disabilities, on basic pensions, no understanding of living normal lives, busy rearing children and grand children, nursing the sick friends and family, prison, mental problems, no family, living on very basics in rural areas no transport or just not at all interested in education by the way young children of survivors did not qualify for the education fund seems like child development is not oart of education for a child’s future but we know this by the cuts in the budget of the high society of ireland.
    I am sure all gets the point WHY IS EDUCATION ON THE SURVIVOR FUNDS AND FIRST? I THINK THEY JUST DID NOT CARE ABOUT THE SURVIVORS THEY HAVE FEELING FOR THE STRUGGLES THEY HAVE TO PUT BREAD AND BUTTER ON THE TABLE. WHERE IS THE LIST OF WHO BENEFITTED FROM THE SO CALLED EDUCATION FUNDS THE SURVIVORS THEMSELVES OR JUST SOME OF THE FAMILIES? not a hard question
    The Education Minister even admitted himself he is spearheading the 50 50 deal where Religious compensation toward witnesses/survivors ( sectioned as Victims) are now retitled as contributions from the Religious to pay their 50% of the redress costs, Being that the Government admitted by their own free will that they were guilty and as guilty as the Religious then that guilt can only be 100% each or not at all. So is the Education Minister trying to reshuffle the the Justice Department of Ireland, by saying If two people commit the same crime they can now share 50% each of the fine or do 50% of the time? This seems to be the case. When they pay bills they have always reassured the public of the tax returns on such BILLS, They received over 50% back on the Redress and report bills, anyway what was their rush we survivors were going no where fast? we could not afford to. Surely they did not have to pay such high costs in the first place? One office would have done where is the breakdown of the Bill of Redress and report costs who got paid so much of tax payers money? and why? NONONO cant have that now can we? I bet that would have angered the public, plus how much in taxes did this Government get back?

    Reply
  • I hope Shatter encloses a BIG Fat cheque with the letters. As far as I can see as a member of the ACCAW, the Evil Rotten Roman Catholic Church’s end is nigh in Ireland. Mass attendances are critically low according to Arsebiship Diarmiud Martin of Dublin. Parishes have no priests. Priests are being made to take a pay cut.
    The Evil Rotten Roman Catholic Church is not a Christian Religion. It was founded on Satanic and Pagan cults.

    THERE IS NO “GOD”, SO STOP WORRYING.

    Reply

Add New Comment