TheJournal.ie uses cookies. By continuing to browse this site you are agreeing to our use of cookies. Click here to find out more »
Dublin: 14 °C Sunday 19 May, 2013

Varadkar: Banning alcohol ads at sports events is ‘not practical’ (despite Labour plans)

Leo Varadkar said the plan to ban alcohol advertising would stop Ireland from hosting the final of the Heineken Cup next year.

Image: Sasko Lazarov/Photocall Ireland

LEO VARADKAR HAS said that the plan by Labour Minister of State Róisín Shortall to ban alcohol companies from sponsoring sports events is “not practical”.

The Minister of Transport, Tourism and Sport said that the plan would have a major financial impact on many clubs and organisations across the country.

“It would make our participation in tournaments like the Heineken Cup very difficult, and Ireland would not be able to host the tournament’s final next year,” he told Retail Intelligence, the e-bulletin from Checkout magazine. Instead he proposed a rigorously-enforced code of conduct for the alcohol industry.

“Ideally we would need to bear in mind that Ireland is only a small part of a bigger English language and European media market,” he told Retail Intelligence.

We can ban advertising and sponsorship on RTE and TV3 but we cannot stop Sky Sports and BBC from beaming it in, not to mention the internet.

His comments directly contradict those of Róisín Shortall who has been working on the proposal for a number of months which would see national sporting bodies phase out the advertising of alcohol at sports events of a period of time.

Minister Shortall told the Dáil this month that Irish society can no longer tolerate the level of alcohol abuse that exists, particularly among young people who are more likely to be influenced by alcohol advertising.

Poll: Should alcohol companies be banned from sponsoring sports events?

Sports sponsorship by alcohol brands to be phased out >

Where everybody knows your name: pub goers want better jacks and Wi-Fi on tap >

Read next:

Comments (41 Comments)

  • The problem isn’t alcohol, the problem is stupid people and unfortunately you can’t ban them either

    Reply
  • For once I agree with Varadkar

    Reply
    • Ha, was just going to say the same!

      Reply
    • crazy me too still never have any respect for him

      Reply
    • Chris 29/05/12 #

      Ah he seems to be well able to speak out and be critical of current or proposed government activities..which is good in my book

      Reply
    • Spot on. What’s with the Nanny Statism? I generally support Labour, but I feel insulted that they think my intelligence and abilioty to choose as an adult has been found to be soooo wanting that they need to start implemenmting legislation like this. I’m surprised at Labour; I’d always thought it was power crazed perverts like Dermot Ahearn, (he of the blasphemy act) Jabba the Hut aka Mary Harney, and former injustice minister Michael McGhoul that were up for this kind of controlling nonsense. Get a grip Gilmore!

      Reply
    • I’m in a similar situation Geoff. I voted for Labour in the last general election but have been very dissappointed with their performance so far. Would consider myself an exLabour / Independant voter now. I guess I am a niave student who was fooled into thinking that “it’s Labours way or Frankfurt’s way!”

      Reply
    • Pig Boy 29/05/12 #

      There is too much duty for the Government to lose . They need the money

      Reply
  • hold on are you sure varadkar said that? can’t be. I agree.

    Reply
  • Banning alcohol advertising will not solve the problem of alcohol abuse in this country. Neither will closing off licences early, restriction of shop sales or any other form of prohibition.

    There needs to be a fundamental shift in the attitude to alcohol consumption in this country. That comes through education, at home and in schools.

    Hiding the drink is an easy way out and won’t work.

    Reply
    • This is exactly the truth regarding alcohol and Ireland. It’s out attitude to drink and not any shinny adverts that draws us to it. The social problems linked with alcohol that Martin Mac speaks of above are brought to the surface by over indulgence but alcohol is not the root cause of these horrible crimes/illnesses, and to blame alcohol solely is to do a disservice and hiding away other key factors like mental illness which unfortunately is still considered taboo in Ireland. Rather than try brush it under the carpet and hide away from the problem by banning everything and anything associated with it, should we not be confronting the underlying key component factors that contribute to this behaviour. After all, the vast majority of drinkers do not involve themselves in any of the above and enjoy alcohol responsibly. The others that do need treatment and/or education as to the other contributing factors that lead them to behave the way they do and the consequences of these actions.

      Reply
    • Completely agree Eoin. As is said on a regular basis in this country, “It is an Irish solution to an Irish problem”. The drinks industry does a lot for local sporting clubs and the for the sport in general. These areas should not be targeted due to some idiots who think they are more than man.

      Reply
    • Yippee 29/05/12 #

      Well said, I think it’s time to think outside the box re alcohol use/abuse. Prohibition and minimum pricing certainly doesn’t work. You only have to look at cigarettes. The amount of contraband that’s coming into the country because criminals realise they can make money by selling it cheaper than the shops can is shocking. God knows what other chemicals are in those cigs when you can’t be sure where they came from. There is certainly an attitude problem in this country towards drinking, and until that is solved none of these other measures will have any noticeable effect.

      Reply
  • its called the H Cup in France. Where alcohol adverstising in banned.

    Reply
  • Well the banks did a lot of damage to the economy over the last few years?
    RBS 6 nations is gone

    Heineken is the offical beer of the olympics, good bye…

    Carlsberg for Euro 12, goodbye…

    Actually Nike has used child labour so we have to ban them…. bye to well everything

    Lets just ban sports on TV for the PC crowd…

    Reply
  • Responsible drinking begins at home….. going to fridge

    Reply
  • “…would have a major financial impact on many clubs and organisations across the country.”

    So when pubs and clubs are effected (many owned by TD’s and their families don’t forget!) they won’t do anything – but if a supermarket sells cheap drink, O’ well thats different, that must be stamped out and a minimum price must be brought in with the excuse that its done because of teen drinking – when also in fact the statistical data shows that such sales are declining too!

    Not that FG and Labour want to hear that!
    Hell no… As FG said themselves in their election manifesto as regards drink: “Fine Gael recognises the importance of the Irish pub for tourism, rural jobs and as a social outlet in communities across the country. We will support the local pub by banning the practice of below cost selling on alcohol, particularly by large supermarkets and the impact this has had on alcohol consumption and the viability of pubs.”

    So its not about the youth then is it really???

    They are just looking after their own – don’t be fooled – well except for the dumb complacent sheep of this nation that will swallow any old crap FG and Labour now and for some time is dishing out to the dopey that swallows it meekly!

    Reply
  • If what Leo is saying is ture, they must never have held the Heinken Cup Final in France so…. Oh wait…

    Reply
    • only 3 times ever and once in the last 10 years. all times it was referred to as “H Cup”. The ERC and FFR lose revenue as a result of this as their value proposition is not as strong.

      Reply
  • John F 29/05/12 #

    After all the nonsense Varadkar has uttered since he entered office he was bound to say something sensible sooner or later!

    Reply
  • Good man Leo, for once that unpredictable beak of yours has spouted some sense

    Reply
  • Leo has the spine to call this one. His colleagues are either too insipid to form their own opinion or parrot nanny stateisms instead. #Leo

    Reply
  • How about banning Varadkar.

    Reply
  • Alcohol is the biggest problem this country has, kills familes, starts violence in the streets, depression, sick days, over crowds hospitals, rape, murder the list is endless…..but no there little business would be ruined if they banned advertising it. This country is a complete joke and you know it.

    Reply
  • Guess who’s getting a nice kickback from Guinness…

    Reply
  • Another of those dirty government tactics to impose more laws upon us.During the 70s and 80′s youth were different.There was more parental control.You could drink and smoke once you were over 18.There was much less public violence.

    Reply
  • neo1 29/05/12 #

    So true Martian

    Reply
  • Study after study has show alcohol cause more finacial and health damage to society than cannabis and ecstasy. It must be tackled seriously just like tobacco adverts. Formula 1 seems to be doing ok without the fag ads. Rugby thrive without beer ads.

    Reply

Add New Comment