This site uses cookies to improve your experience and to provide services and advertising. By continuing to browse, you agree to the use of cookies described in our Cookies Policy. You may change your settings at any time but this may impact on the functionality of the site. To learn more see our Cookies Policy.
#Open journalism No news is bad news

Your contributions will help us continue to deliver the stories that are important to you

Support The Journal
Dublin: 11 °C Saturday 6 June, 2020

This letter is most blatant Big Tobacco threat to a Taoiseach you're likely to see

Carroll Industries threatened to stop investing in businesses if new laws come in

Image: PA Archive/Press Association Images

WE’RE ALWAYS HEARING about the influence of ‘Big Tobacco’, but this 1986 letter to the Taoiseach from the chairman of a tobacco company is about as blatant as it gets.

In the letter, Don Carroll of multi-national tobacco company PJ Carrolls’ tells the Taoiseach that the company may decide to stop investing in Irish businesses if a new bill goes through.

At the time, the government were proposing more tobacco regulation including increasing the size of warnings on packets and advertisements.

Carroll argued that his Irish-owned businesses would be hit harder by the laws because they depend so much on the Irish market compared to their competitors.

Essentially, he argues that the Department of Health is going it alone and not considering the consequences which could include Carrolls’ choosing to stop investing in Irish businesses:

IMG_2091 Source: National Archives

Unilateral action by the Minister for Health, within his existing powers, decided on solely in relation to the perspectives of his Department, must have serious discriminatory impacts on Carrolls’ tobacco industry and investment capacity.

It could no longer contemplate the policies which it is now pursuing which envisage new investment outside the tobacco business of some £50 million over the remainder of this decade.

IMG_2092 Source: National Archives

The final three paragraphs above letter contain a complaint that the Minster for Health won’t speak to the tobacco industry:

Surely it would not be unreasonable to request the Taoiseach to secure that no new regulations made by the Minister for Health pending consideration by the relevant government departments of the broader context involved.

Since the minister will not have any discussions with us, there seems no alternative to seeking the Taoiseach’s intervention.

May I say in conclusion that I am conscious of the propensity these days for special interest pleading.

Obviously Carrolls has special interests. But I do believe that an objective consideration of the balance of the considerations would be likely to result in a different conclusion from that which would be reached was action to be taken solely in the light of the perspectives of the Department of Health.

Read: Big Tobacco lobbied hard and aggressively… but lost anyway >

Read: Big Tobacco says plain-packaging laws are a ‘failure’ – are they telling the truth? >

  • Share on Facebook
  • Email this article

About the author:

Rónán Duffy

Read next: