We need your help now

Support from readers like you keeps The Journal open.

You are visiting us because we have something you value. Independent, unbiased news that tells the truth. Advertising revenue goes some way to support our mission, but this year it has not been enough.

If you've seen value in our reporting, please contribute what you can, so we can continue to produce accurate and meaningful journalism. For everyone who needs it.

Sam Boal/Photocall Ireland
MCK Rentals

Private investigators fined for unlawfully obtaining addresses of Credit Union members

MCK Rentals unlawfully gathered people’s addresses from the Department of Social Protection and the HSE.

TWO DIRECTORS of a private investigation company have admitted to unlawfully gathering personal information about people and passing it on to a credit union.

Margaret Stuart and Wendy Martin, who are both directors of MCK Rentals Ltd in Greystones, pleaded guilty at Bray District Court to unlawfully passing information to Tullamore Credit Union.

MCK Rentals was fined €7,500, while Stuart and Martin were each fined €1,500.

The women were separately charged with 22 other counts of breaches of the Data Protection Acts 1988 & 2003.

RTÉ has reported that the Assistant Commissioner at the Office of the Data Protection, Commissioner Tony Delaney, told the court that MCK Rentals had contacted both the Department of Social Protection and the HSE by phone and obtained people’s new addresses by pretending to be someone else.

The Data Protection Commissioner welcomed the rulings, noting that they will likely have “far-reaching implications” and send out ” a strong message to private investigators and tracing agents”

In the first instance, it sends to comply fully with data protection legislation in the conduct of their business and that if they fail to do so, they will be pursued and prosecuted for offending behaviour.

“Secondly, it serves to remind all companies and businesses who hire private investigators or tracing agents that they have onerous responsibilities under the Data Protection Acts to ensure that all tracing or other work carried out on their behalf by private investigators or tracing agents is done lawfully.”

Critical of credit unions

The Commissioner was critical of credit unions who hired MCK for not establishing what methods the firm used to obtain access to new address information.

“This is particularly shocking in circumstances where trace reports containing new address details of members were returned to Credit Unions within hours, in some cases, of being sought.

“Rather than carrying out due diligence prior to hiring MCK Investigations, the Credit Unions asked no questions, they took the unlawfully obtained personal data and used it, and they commended the success rate of MCK Investigations to their colleagues in the sector,” the Commissioner stated.

These are the first prosecutions to be completed by the Commissioner against private investigators for breaches of data protection laws.

The case is ongoing.

Read: ‘No data breach’ says Irish Water, despite sending 6,329 letters to the wrong address

Read: The Data Protection Commissioner is getting a new office, but keeping the one beside a convenience store in Laois