We need your help now

Support from readers like you keeps The Journal open.

You are visiting us because we have something you value. Independent, unbiased news that tells the truth. Advertising revenue goes some way to support our mission, but this year it has not been enough.

If you've seen value in our reporting, please contribute what you can, so we can continue to produce accurate and meaningful journalism. For everyone who needs it.

Piketty in Dublin yesterday JOHN MC ELROY
piketty mania

Electric Piketty: The economist 650 people came to see

He wrote one of the most influential books so far this century – but can he keep a room full of Dubliners awake?

THERE WAS A buzz around Croke Park yesterday that you don’t usually associate with an hour-long talk about one hundred year trends in the distribution of capital and income.

But the headline speaker was no ordinary academic bore. He’s the latest to be granted the dubious title of ‘rock-star’ economist.

Usually, this means that a smattering of people will turn up to your talks. This, however, was different. There was anticipation in the air. The man from Paris would tell us all where we’d gone wrong.

Jack Horgan-Jones / Jack Horgan-Jones / /

For context, a recent lecture by no greater personage than Nobel prize winning economist, not to mention New York Times columnist, Paul Krugman in UCD drew about 50 people.

But even in such exalted company, Thomas Piketty is of a different class. 650 people turned up to Croke Park to see the Professor from the Paris School of Economics speak about inequality.

What’s more, they paid for the privilege.

Such was the level of hype that an insider quietly confided in that whatever line organiser TASC was trying to push would invariably be blown out of the water by the dapper Piketty.

The great and the good

It was certainly the place to be seen for the great and the good of the Irish left (and leftish). Union top brass such as David Begg and Jack O’Connor were doing the rounds, backed up by SIPTU communications head Frank Connolly.

Politicians also were on the beat. Joan Burton had a front row seat, with Senator Fiach Mac Conghail and Europe’s nearly man Eamon Ryan also among the crowd.

Peter Matthews was also in attendance, and, when he got his turn to address the room, wasn’t cowed by TASC chair Paul Sweeney’s half-jocular threat to cut his microphone off if he went on for too long.

The Patrick and Thomas show

Piketty is a compelling speaker, as is the man tasked with responding to him, Central Bank Governor Patrick Honohan (who admitted to being a fan of the book, disappointing those who expected a scurrilous attack from this organ of the orthodoxy).

ThomPik Jack Horgan-Jones / Jack Horgan-Jones / /

Piketty and Honohan seemed to get on like a house on fire, in fact.

When Patrick put up his slides on the impact of budgetary policy on different income bands, Thomas twisted fully 180 degrees in his chair and nodded enthusiastically along as the Governor talked us through it.

PikettyBack Nothing excites Thomas like some new data, it seems Jack Horgan-Jones / Jack Horgan-Jones / /

Nonetheless, there is a limit to how long people can do heavy intellectual lifting on a sunny Friday afternoon.

The collective mind seemed to wander when Piketty got into the minutiae of his work.

However, we could be wrong. Far be it from to suggest the audience was anything but rapt.

Perhaps the smattering of nodding heads were doing so in agreement, and maybe those closed lids were done so in deep contemplation rather than slumber.

Plus, as we said, it was very warm indeed.

Revolution in the air?

The hardcore economics fans would definitely have been satisfied by Piketty’s talk, but it was only once the question and answer session got started that the rhetorical temperature really began to rise.

Despite the Professor’s stated desire for “an informed and quiet discussion about taxation”, one questioner from the audience was determined to ask whether it was not, in fact, time for “mass revolt by the people”.

MatthewsQ The panel face Peter Matthews' question Jack Horgan-Jones / Jack Horgan-Jones / /

Another implored Piketty to come and lead us in our struggle. Ursula Barry of the school of social justice in UCD made a well-received call for the proceeds of any wealth tax to be ringfenced for domestic use, rather than in the service of debt.

The crowd clapped enthusiastically, chided the Governor, and generally had a good time. Piketty, who was in top lecturer form and formed a good double act with the ebullient Honohan, seemed to enjoy himself.

At the end of the day, one gets the sense that it was the economics fans that went home happier than the revolutionaries. A cheerful “let’s do it” from the main man at the end went down well, but it was hardly Hasta la victoria siempre.

Even rock-star economists are still economists first, and entertainers second. This one, it seems, is no revolutionary, but he makes an impressive fist of the other brief.  

Read: The world’s most famous economist thinks the property tax is unfair>

Read: Why 600 people will be at a sold-out event in Dublin today just to hear this rockstar economist talk>

Your Voice
Readers Comments
    Submit a report
    Please help us understand how this comment violates our community guidelines.
    Thank you for the feedback
    Your feedback has been sent to our team for review.