#Open journalism No news is bad news

Your contributions will help us continue to deliver the stories that are important to you

Support The Journal
Dublin: 8°C Tuesday 19 January 2021

'Not good enough': Family of woman shot by garda killer says GSOC is not properly resourced

Siobhan Philips was shot by her partner in October 2015.

Garda Tony Golden
Garda Tony Golden
Image: Garda Press Office

THE FATHER OF a woman who was shot alongside Garda Tony Golden in 2015 has said he is ”extremely disappointed but not surprised” at the content of a report into the incident.

Seán Philips’ daughter Siobhan was shot by her partner Adrian Crevan Mackin, who then turned the gun on himself. Both Garda Golden and Mackin died from their injuries.

A Garda report into the incident, which happened in Omeath in Co Louth on 11 October 2015, published yesterday found that two domestic violence incidents involving Siobhan were not properly logged on the Pulse system by gardaí.

Siobhan has a brain injury, lost one eye, has had extensive facial reconstruction surgery, and has had to learn how to walk and talk again. She has launched a damages case against the gardaí.

Her father had contacted gardaí to express concern about her in September 2015. Seán Philips today released a statement on behalf of his family.

It states: “Not one of the issues that we have consistently raised has been adequately addressed in this report. In fact this report only serves to cause further distress and trauma for our family.

“We are especially shocked by the fact that the report confirms that the investigation by the gardaí into the shootings concluded as far back as May 2017. Despite relentlessly seeking updates we were never told at any time that the investigation had concluded.

“We have also been in regular contact with GSOC and we know that they have been struggling to get documentation from the gardaí and the Special Criminal Court.”

Last month, GSOC launched High Court proceedings to obtain transcripts relating to appearances by Mackin before the Special Criminal Court.

Letter to apologise 

The statement notes that GSOC sent the family a letter this week to apologise “for not having made better progress and reiterated to us that the ‘resourcing of the investigation and our office in general is causing great difficulties and hampering the progress of the investigation’”.

“This is simply not good enough. The Government has a responsibility to ensure that GSOC is properly resourced,” the statement adds.

Peter Madden, the family’s solicitor, said the report “confirms both our long-held view, and that of the family, that only a public inquiry can get to the truth of the tragic avoidable events in Omeath in October 2015”.

TheJournal.ie has asked GSOC for comment.

‘An abhorrent crime’ 

Commenting on the report, Minister for Justice Charlie Flanagan said the shooting of Garda Golden and Siobhan Philips was “an abhorrent crime”.

“Conscious of the gravity of this matter and the concerns expressed by the family of Ms Siobhan Philips, as well as by local public representatives, I have taken the decision in the public interest to publish this report.

“The report is subject to a number of minor redactions for necessary legal and security reasons.

“I have been assured by GSOC that the publication of this report will not have any adverse impact on the independent investigations underway and we should not prejudge the outcome of those investigations,” Flanagan said.

Comments are closed due to ongoing legal proceedings. 

Read: Woman shot by garda killer Adrian Mackin launches damages case against gardaí

Read: Tony Golden murder: Gardaí misclassified victim’s domestic violence incidents

About the author:

Órla Ryan

Read next: