#Open journalism No news is bad news

Your contributions will help us continue to deliver the stories that are important to you

Support The Journal
Dublin: 14°C Saturday 31 July 2021

Trump keeps saying ‘enemy of the people’ — but the phrase has a very ugly history

It was also uttered by the likes of Nero and Hugo Chavez.

Image: Evan Vucci/PA Wire

OVER THE LAST two weeks, US President Donald Trump has repeatedly referred to media outlets that he dubbed the “fake news media” as “the enemy of the American People”.

Trump repeated the attack at a speech at the Conservative Political Action Conference on Friday, saying: “They are the enemy of the people.”

The phrase “the enemy of the people” has a long history that Trump may or may not have known about.

Over the course of the last century, it has been used repeatedly by dictators and autocrats to delegitimise foreign governments, opposition parties, and dissenters.

Though the phrase dates back to Roman times and the reign of Emperor Nero (who was declared “an enemy of the people” by the Roman Senate), it came into use in the modern period during the French Revolution.

Nero - Wikimedia Commons Source: Wikimedia Commons

Ennemi du peuple was used to refer to those who disagreed with the new French government during the “Reign of Terror,” a period during which thousands of revolutionairies were executed by guillotine.

While it was featured as the name of a Henrik Ibsen play, its next prominent use was by the Nazis.

During the Third Reich’s rule in Germany, Propaganda Minister Joseph Goebbels referred to Jews as “a sworn enemy of the German people” who posed a risk to Adolf Hitler’s vision for the country, according to The Washington Post.

It gained its widest use by Joseph Stalin during the early years of the Soviet Union. In the nation’s early years, Vladimir Lenin and Joseph Stalin used the term vrag naroda (enemy of the nation/people) to refer to those who disagreed with the ideologies pushed forth by the Bolshevik government and, later, adopted by the newly-formed Soviet Union.

File:Lenin and stalin crop.jpg - Wikimedia Commons Source: Wikimedia Commons

This could include anyone from the clergy who did not want to adopt state-enforced atheism to writers to political opposition that questioned the ideologies of the new government. Later picked up by Stalin, such a designation could mean immediate imprisonment or removal to a labour camp.

“All leaders of the Constitutional Democratic Party, a party filled with enemies of the people, are hereby to be considered outlaws, and are to be arrested immediately and brought before the revolutionary court,” said Lenin in November 1917.

As reported by The New York Times, the phrase lost popularity in the 1950s when Soviet leader Nikita Khrushchev came into power and denounced Lenin and Stalin’s use of the term to refer to anyone who disagreed with the leaders.

“The formula ‘enemy of the people was specifically introduced for the purpose of physically annihilating such individuals,” Khrushchev said in a 1956 speech to the Soviet Communist Party.

Nina Khruscheva, Khruschev’s great-granddaughter and international affairs professor at the New School in New York, told The New York Times that it was particularly shocking to hear the language of “state nationalism [that] is always the same regardless of the country.”

In recent years, Venezuela’s Hugo Chavez also called political dissenters “enemies of the homeland.”

Venezuela Colombia Source: AP/Press Association Images

Trump in recent week has renewed his assault on the “fake” media, accusing major news outlets of fabricating sources and stories, and branding them “the enemy of the people”.

“They say that we can’t criticize their dishonest coverage because of the First Amendment, you know, they always bring up the First Amendment,” he told Republican supporters during a keynote speech.

Trump built his campaign on criticizing the mainstream US press — most of which overtly opposed his election — as biased, and has intensified his rhetoric since taking office, routinely accusing the media of overstating his setbacks and downplaying his accomplishments.

A week ago, at his first solo news conference, the 70-year-old launched a long diatribe at the dozens of journalists present, blaming their “dishonesty” for the troubles of his month-old administration.

- Veronika Bondarenko, with additional reporting by AFP

Read: Maintaining tradition, Trump declares March ‘Irish-American Heritage Month’ >

Published with permission from:

Business Insider
Business Insider is a business site with strong financial, media and tech focus.

Read next: