TheJournal.ie uses cookies. By continuing to browse this site you are agreeing to our use of cookies. Click here to find out more »
Dublin: 11 °C Thursday 20 June, 2013

Bad planning contributing to Irish obesity levels – An Taisce

An Taisce’s comprehensive report suggests urban sprawl means more time in cars or transport – and less time physically active.

An Taisce says poor planning means people spend more time commuting - and are becoming more overweight as a result.
An Taisce says poor planning means people spend more time commuting - and are becoming more overweight as a result.
Image: Mark Stedman/Photocall Ireland

AN TAISCE’S comprehensive report of planning practices at Irish local authorities has suggested that poor planning, and the refusal of councils to honour planning strategies, has contributed to Ireland’s obesity problem.

The report, published earlier today, says poor planning practices and the willingness of some councils to approve inappropriate developments has helped to contribute to urban sprawl.

This is a major contributor to what An Taisce calls an “obesogenic environment” – saying the commuter lifestyle is a contributing factor to weight gain and obesity.

An Taisce characterises this environment as leading to increasing obesity:

…due to increased car dependency, few opportunities for spontaneous exercise, longer commuting times and less time for physical exercise becoming a feature of life for many people.

The ‘State of the Nation’ planning report says Ireland’s adult obesity rate is now higher than in 18 states of the USA, and suggests that the poor planning practices have also helped to contribute to childhood obesity where young people spend much of the day travelling.

On a similar vein, the report says “development sprawl” is also primarily responsible for a 170 per cent increase in greenhouse gas emissions, making it almost impossible to meet its EU targets by 2020.

Under the European targets, member states are required to increase energy efficiency by 20 per cent by 2020, and also bring carbon emissions down by 20 per cent compared to their 1990 levels.

“The almost complete failure by the Irish planning system to rationally control development and plan a society around public transport is directly responsible for making this task extraordinarily formidable,” the report states.

The report says poor planning is also one of the reasons why Ireland is the second most oil-dependant country of all EU states, and one of the societies most dependant on private cars.

Other effects of a failure to centralise development in urban areas include the “hollowing out” of town centres as commercial units spread to rural greenfield areas, the “hugely inefficient and prohibitive cost” of infrastructure like broadband, and the “social costs of inadequate healthcare provision”.

Read: The 9 worst councils in Ireland’s planning system

More: Absence of local tax saw councils approve too many developments

Case study: Ennis: “Some of the most senseless zoning excesses of Celtic Tiger”

Pic: Ireland is Crap at Planning Map of the Day

  • Share on Facebook
  • Email this article
  •  

Read next:

Comments (53 Comments)

  • Irish planners and developers showed no forward thinking…who would’ve guessed?

    Reply
    • Developers in fairness are only out to make a profit and planners in Ireland are not let plan! Councillors in Ireland are too involved in the whole planning process and have the power to over rule professionals at their own job. That is why planning in Ireland is a mess.

      Reply
    • How councillors uneducated in urban/rural planning and architecture are simply allowed to over throw and rubbish the good intent, planning and design of planning and design unprofessionals in this country is beyond me. Our architects are winning major competitions across the world. We have the expertise but we are stuck with these misguided gombeen politicians who are out to serve their own. We have to reform local government root and branch.

      Reply
    • Woops!! that should read professionals!

      Reply
  • What about all the mothers that drive down the road to bring their kids to school, can’t blame everything on the transport system. Most people are just getting lazier.

    Reply
  • Dave 16/04/12 #

    Hmm…let me see. Low density development leads to greater distances to access services, meaning increased car use and less walking. Makes sense to me…when I lived on the continent, I just didnt need a car. I walked everywhere I needed to go, had public transport for anywhere that bit further. Couldnt say the same here!

    Reply
  • Irish kids are fat because they sit infront of the tv or pc all day and yea its their parents fault for letting them..not tv ads mac donalds or any other half cocked idea for lazy parents

    Reply
  • I’d say Mcdonalds can’t believe there luck on this one.

    Reply
  • cimada 17/04/12 #

    Why are these reports only ever after the event I mean couldn’t they have intervened earlier with hey lads that’s a tight bit a crap zoning get yer arse in gear… Wtf is the point of these regulators apart from to diagnose the problem when it’s too late. It’s too late now to fix it so why bother wasting money on a report? Is it just me? Careful now, down with this sort of thing.

    Reply
  • Much food = big fat belly.
    Fatty, walk to try to get thin
    Fatties no eat they no stay fat
    Not government fault you’re a big fatty. Own fault.
    Do we have to blame someone for everything?
    The blame culture removes personal responsibility.
    The eating culture piles on the pounds.

    Reply
    • It’s a contributor to the obese/over weight epidemic…… And rightly so. After 5 years in my current job, which is 1.5 hour drive one direction (minus traffic) i’v put on a fierce amount around the middle. Spose I wouldn’t have that if I could walk to work.

      Reply
    • Walk the dog at night. Needs must and all that. Your big fat ned kelly is a
      killer for sure. Eat pears, but don’t be like a pear.
      With a few months dedication & determination you can he half the man you are today. And give up the pints. They are the worst for causing the big pooku

      Reply
    • Driving doesn’t make you fat. Eating too much shit makes you fat. Get up an hour earlier or go to bed an hour later and exercise! Excuses are easier to make than the gym is…

      Reply
    • Read the report instead of just this article. It made sense to me. I know people who commute between 3 and 4 hours a day to work. Add a working day of anywhere between 8 and 12 hours (all have to work more to keep the same job these days). That is a potential 16 hour day before you see your children and read them a story before bed. You want them to skip that bedtime story and drive further to the gym instead? Sorry guys, but that is a really crappy lifestyle, partly caused by stupid zoning.

      Reply
    • Totally disagree P Wurple. My work day + commute often totals 15 hours. I have 3 happy kids that i spend time with for as long as they are awake. Now I can sit on my ass, pissing and whinging that I’m getting fat or I can do something about it. You can use whatever excuses you like to apportion blame somewhere else and deflect personal responsibility but ultimately your health and fitness is in your own hands and not a planning authorities. Excuses and laziness are responsible for this obesity epidemic.

      Reply
    • Who needs a gym? Walk the dog

      Reply
    • P Wurple 17/04/12 #

      Hmm, on second thoughts, I think you’re right. The report is making assumptions here. There isn’t any reference to the actual weight of people who commute. People who live in the country aren’t the fat ones in my experience… there are plenty more obese people in the inner city where they can walk and cycle to everything. It’s not those who work long hours and drive all the time who get fat. It’s people who have a lot of time to eat.

      Reply
  • Blame the Bankers!!!

    Reply
    • What about the local councils?
      What about the media for failing to live up to their role as the Fourth Estate, raking in the euros for property porn advertising?
      What about the failure of every Irish government to introduce a proper system of local government?
      And what about the failure of the people to demand a proper system of local government, instead of the short sighted clientist system we’ve had up until now?

      I’m being provocative here I know.

      Reply
    • EMD 16/04/12 #

      At your peril Ryan :-) Rock on….

      Reply
    • Don’t forget the household charge surely! That hundred quid could have been spent on a gym membership or fresh fruit. The internet made me obese by delivering my shopping. And texting made me obese by reducing my need to meet people face to face. Hell, on that basis, phones, Morse code and smoke signals are making me obese. I’m off for a jog

      Reply
  • America is the most obese nation with the UK in second place, both of their transport systems are second to none. Laziness and over indulgence is the reason people become fat, along with sitting in front of the tv for hours stuffing their faces watching something crap. Touchy subject

    Reply
    • Uk and Us public transport do not consist entirely of the London underground and the New York sub way systems alone. You’re making up stuff to prove a point.

      Reply
    • “America is the most obese nation with the UK in second place, both of their transport systems are second to none. ” SERIOUSLY??? America’s transport system is second to none? have you actually travelled much in the states? They are a worst case scenario with massive urban sprawl and urban centres bisected by unsightly and crumbling highways. As for Amtrak, they make me proud that we have Irish Rail.

      Reply
  • Eh, well if all those fat people got bikes and walked more then it would be leading to a healthier society.

    Reply
    • The report is kinda saying that… People have houses miles from anywhere due to some seriously rubbish zoning.. Too far to cycle, have to spend hours commuting every day to work. Road in front of their house is too dangerous to play on, kids stuck inside unless they are ferried to organised play events.

      When you work 10 hours a day at a desk, and are in a car for another 2 hours each way on that, where and when are you able to cycle or do anything except collapse in bed and do it all over again tomorrow.

      Reply
  • HAHAHAHAHAHAHAH…

    HAHAHAH…jesus christ, it’s like a report a 12 year old would write for a school project. Priceless, obesity caused by bad planning! An Taisce – a great bunch of lads..

    Reply
  • So if all these people weren’t commuting so much they would be walking, biking, exercising more?
    Bullshit!

    Reply
  • on obesity..
    The National Obesity Taskforce in 2005 made a range of recommendations for Government, the health and education sectors, planners and the food industry to implement policies to curb the dramatic year-on-year increases in obesity in Irish society. A key recommendation of the Taskforce is that planning policies must be proactive and encourage spontaneous increases in physical activity in adults and children and deliver environments that support healthy food choices and regular physical activity including adequate walkways and amenities, and ensure public transport provision is explicit in the planning process.
    Physical environment
    The Department of the Environment, Heritage and Local Government should develop coherent planning policies for urban/rural housing, transport, amenity spaces and workplace settings to encourage spontaneous increases in physical activity in adults and children.
    The Irish Financial Services Regulatory Authority should examine the high costs of public liability and their impact on physical activity. It should foster initiatives to address these costs.
    The Taskforce is confident that the Report will assist those who are involved in developing policy as well as those who plan, manage and deliver services.
    The Report will be brought to Cabinet by Minister of State at the Department of Health and Children, Seán Power TD.
    also see the report of the Irish Heart Foundation
    http://www.irishheart.ie/iopen24/pub/building_young_hearts_final_pdf_2010.pdf
    Changes in the physical environment to promote and support increased levels of physical
    activity have the potential to reach a greater population and therefore achieve greater public
    health impact than individual measures. They are potentially less costly and more enduring
    than traditional educational physical activity interventions. Research has shown that the way
    communities are built either encourages or inhibits physical activity levels through influencing
    how people move around and within their communities.

    Reply
  • Planners, developers and councils have never been able to manage, select or develop projects professionally EVER.

    Local communities have no amenities like pools, gyms, social clubs, libraries, skate parks etc. The lack of these contribute to obesity more than commuting and the government want us to pay a household charge for what if these vital services don’t exist.

    Councils have blown their budgets on maintaining their own existence through empire building and creating jobs for their buddies.

    They break our backs with taxation, they rip out our guts in making us pay for rogue bankers and they have stolen our soles with life long mortgages that were unsustainable.

    When will the people if Eire stand up and fight for our civil liberties? When will enough be enough!

    Reply
    • It’s not that long ago that getting a mortgage was a civil liberty. Now you can’t pay it back you want the rest of us to say “enough is enough”.
      We are a great country for looking around for someone else to blame when our decisions turn to shit

      Reply
  • jimbo 16/04/12 #

    WTF has two Luas trains got to do with been obesity?

    Reply
  • What is the link to the LUAS?

    Reply
  • Jim Daly 17/04/12 #

    We should ban planning before the 9pm watershed.

    Reply
  • Bryan 17/04/12 #

    People have over simplistic views of obesity. There are many contributing factors, laziness is very low on that list. Obesity is an eating disorder. It can be a learned behaviour children being rewarded with sweets to adults comfort eating. The one thing it is is a viscous circle that is hard to break.

    Reply
  • Rob 17/04/12 #

    i’m lost here!!

    so are they saying its better to build in the arse end of nowhere so that everyone has to walk for miles??

    or that living above your office in the city centre is the healthier way forward??

    Reply
    • neither – I didnt say anything – just direct quotes from reports . Several people above have said that it is laughable that someone would try and link planning to obesity – obviously people who know better dont think so.

      Reply
  • it is laughable linking planning to obesity…people are fat because they ate fat lazy couch potatoes

    Reply

Add New Comment